Lynn Stefaniak
My sisters have always ordered from here
Tonite she ordered two pies
This is the first time I’m having Paradiso
We ordered one regular cheese pie
The second pie was half olive and half spinach
The food came on time , hot and with lots of napkins and utensils
Very good , delicious !
… moreChristina X2
Our table ordered meatballs, Fettuchini with Scallops and Filet of Sole. Portions were Large and delicious! The waiters were kind and attentive! Will definitely go back!
… moreBig Ash
I am so obsessed with the Chicken Marsala slice. I personally think it’s worth the $6+ for the one thick slice, since it’s all I need. The Vodka slice is also pretty tasty and I love the fact that it doesn’t have pasta in it. The sauce is soooo delicious, I wish I could swim in it! ♀️
Staff is nice and attentive. I do wish they would use less of their bare hands to pick up the food though. I mean the tongs are RIGHT there. That’s just the germaphobe in me but my brain wants to believe that the heat from the stove is burning up said germs still tastes yummy though!
… moreYesenia Reyes
Extremely rude staff from the moment I called to place the order through pickup. I was treated as if the food was free. In a time when everything is so expensive, the least customers should expect is basic courtesy and kindness. Very disappointing experience.
… moreDerek Slattery
This place has great pizza. I have never had a bad slice and their specialty slices are the best on the island. They are deep dish so you get your monies worth and they have such a great variety. I high recommend the new bbq pizza and the honey mustard pizza. They are a must have
… moreSusan MacDowell
Great little semolina rolls, served warm. Eggplant rollatini had a bit too much cheese for my taste, but the ricotta mixed with pesto was creative and amazing. Excellent pomodoro sauce.
… moreStratmangler 27
Another great pizza place in RVC. Great selection of pizza and Italian dishes.
They have a dinning area for by the slice customers and a sit in space where you can enjoy full course meals.
The place has a handfull selections of pizzas which are reasonably priced and their employees are all pleasant to deal with. The establishment as a whole is well kept and clean and the only thing is they are a little hidden and in a low traffic part of the complex.
… moreDread InNY
Let’s be clear. I have been a customer to this place for probably about 15 years now. Not the least expensive pizza place and not the best. However they have some really good specialty slices. Let me explain the low rating. I went in on July 6th 2023. The gentleman behind the counter was helping another customer. Although she ordered, he kept a casual conversation going for about 7 minutes. He never looked my way. He never said one moment. And while there were three other men behind the counter, no one came to ask if I needed help. He smiled in her face, thanked “Debra” by name and turn the other way. Not once the be even look at me. Another worker came past me tapped him on the leg and asked him to take me. Mind you this person had walked past three times looking at the counter. Never once addressed me as a customer. Now he’s addressing me after being prompted. I looked at him with a surprised look. He looked me by returning my look as if it was funny. His following interaction was cold, short and not welcoming. It’s not my typical experience to wait and be ignored in here. That’s why I didn’t leave. However, I will leave this review. I’m hoping it is because it just was a bad day for them and not because there was a black man waiting to be served.
I have included photos of both men as well as the pizza if you’re interested. I informed my 6 year old son who was present that we will spend money where wanted.
… moremarc JZ
Remarkable food, we’ve been loyal customers for over 25 years. Now in retirement we order food to take to Florida. Their pizza freezes well and we reheat in our air fryer and have pizza parties poolside in the winter, delicious! Benny, the owner is the kindest sweetest gentleman. Coming home to NY from JFK our car service vehicle had unfortunately gotten a flat tire, Benny brought us our dinner that we phoned in at Kennedy, and gave us a ride home to Oceanside. He reminds you that there are good people and we are blessed that he also makes the best pizza hands down! We’re New Yorkers and Paradiso in Rockville Centre has the best! They should start a frozen delivery service Nationwide like Katz’s deli for discerning customers who want truly delicious food year round:)
… morePrimrose Thompson
We love their pizza! Is it the best in New York? No, but it’s pretty good. It’s not too greasy and the crust is pretty yummy too. We love their Margherita pizza…fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and basil. A definite winner.
Went back à few times, pizza had some misses. There is a lack of consistency. One night, I ordered a Margherita pizza and it was so soggy that we couldnt eat the whole thing. Then, one night I ordered a soup and it was delicious, but the next time I tried it was absolutely disgusting. I told the cashier about it, showed them the full bowl, he made a snarky comment about my daughter seeming to enjoy it. My 4 year old daughter was lifting it up with a spoon and dropping the globs because she tasted it and it was so disgusting. He still charged me for the nasty soup and I’m just not going back there. Pizza on Fridays in a ritual for my daughter and me, but me need a spot that is consistent with their food.
… more