Mancino's Grinders & Pizza - Plymouth, IN 46563 - Menu, Reviews, Hours & Contact

Plymouth Mancino’s Grinders & Pizza Miller Drive · CHEESE PIZZA. Additional Toppings 10″-$1.50 each, 12″-$1.75 each, 16″-$2.25 each · WHITE PIZZA. Garlic Butter …

Mancino’s Pizza and Grinders

A pizzeria with a bread bakers soul, creating the very best in pizza & grinders! With only the highest quality in meats, cheeses and vegetables.

Reviews

Jennifer Spencer

I ordered a pepperoni pizza and garlic sticks with garlic butter, and not a single piece of this food had any flavor to it. The sauce was very bland. I loved to order garlic butter with my food and this garlic butter didn’t have a hint of garlic flavor to it, barely butter flavor to it. It was like vegetable oil and a cup, and I love pizza and breadsticks. It’s my favorite, but I will not be returning to this Mancino’s again highly highly disappointed, save your money and go to Little Caesars.

… more

Cayla O’Connor

10 out of 10! Today was our first time trying this place and it was so, so good! The best we’ve had so far in Plymouth. Their grinder is phenomenal and their pizza was delicious as well! We will definitely be making this a weekly stop. Staff was also friendly at pick up and the order was made fast. I’m very happy we found this place.

… more

Zach Schramm

As a self-proclaimed pizza guru from Chicago, I hold my pizza to a high standard. Mancino’s Pizza in Plymouth, IN, not only met but exceeded my expectations.

I ordered the 12” pizza with sausage, pepperoni, and spinach, and it was cooked to perfection. The crust had a great texture, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Each bite was super tasty, striking that ideal balance of savory and satisfying.

It’s safe to say that Mancino’s has earned a spot on my list of go-to pizza places. If you’re in Plymouth and craving a delicious pizza, Mancino’s is a must-try!

… more

Nathan Zaragoza

Decided to get the Mancino Club, took a bite & had to take a two second pause. Literally said out loud “oh my gosh!” from how well this sandwich was put together & tasted. They are generous with their ingredients & portions. Will definitely be a returning client!

… more

Tara Howard

This place has always been me and my fiancé’s favorite spot to eat. We have been going here for awhile, and the food has always been beyond amazing. Staff is always super kind and accommodating. We now go about twice a week, once for lunch and once for dinner. Anytime we choose to do take-out, the quality is still great and very fresh. I will forever rave about this place!

Side note: one thing I wish they had is a grinder meal 1/4 grinder, pick a side (not just chips), and medium drink.

… more

Bruce Peterson

Love me a good sandwich spot. We ordered the cowboy steak, Hawaiian bbq chicken, and yeti fries. Delicious. Great customer service too. We’ll definitely be back!

… more

Richard Rizzo

I had picked up an order on 01/09/25
The order was $24.00 total.
I give the food a MINUS 5 for the following reasons.

A $22.00 BLT Grinder which is bread, lettuce, tomato bacon bits. Or should I say as hard as bacon bits. Went right into the garbage Tasted like crap. I could have made the same sandwich for about $5.00. Not $22.00

Also an order of French Fries. Dried up, stuck together, had to be sitting out and or under a heat lamp for hours. Rock Hard Tasted one. Right into the garbage with the grinder. $24.00 of food into the trash.
I don’t think the rats would eat this stuff. I was not about to drive all the way back to the restaurant. And not looking for a free meal. Nor a refund. I will never use this restaurant again.
People check your food before leaving if you are going to use this restaurant.

I never leave a bad review but you people earned this one. Worst food ever. Don’t know how you can serve it.

… more

Sean Turner

I just left this restaurant, and I’ll have to say, I love the service that I received. I know I was cutting it short by coming within 10 minutes of them closing, and when I walked in, I asked if I made it in time to get a grinder. I was told that the oven was off, but that they would make me a sandwich right away. They then turn the oven back on, got my order, and made it right away. Kim was the one who stayed back and made my experience here the best. I’ve always loved the food, and I’ve been coming to Mancino’s since I was a teenager. I’m now 45. I’ve also worked in restaurants for a number of years, so I know how important the hospitality is in creating return customers. Kim definitely has that hospitality. Absolutely loved her. Great job Mancino’s.

… more

Deion Jones

Mid. Fries were undercooked & pizza is average. The sauce is unique but that’s about it. Pizza is best home made

… more

Ramona Hill

We went to Mancinos today and got grinders. I got a Trio Grinder. It is delicious!! The lady that took our order was so nice and answered all our questions before we ordered. The business is very clean too !!
Oh..we live in Michigan City and we were in Plymouth visiting our granddaughter. Certainly worth the stop ! I miss the local Mancinos that was close to us. ** I can’t figure out how to add aphoto **

… more

… View more

Mancino’s Grinders & Pizza

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results