Address and Contact Information
Address: 2121 Queen Anne Ave N, Seattle, WA 98109
Website: http://www.cornellyqueenanne.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: toasttab.com
Related Web Results
Cornelly Queen Anne
Cornelly (@cornellyseattle) · Seattle, WA – Instagram
Cornelly Queen Anne – Order Online
Reviews
We were celebrating our wedding anniversary and the service was incredible. Noah treated us so well and made excellent recommendations. Happy to report the pizza is just as good as the original location, and the Caesar salad was even better than I remembered. The Gemelli bolognese was cooked to the perfect texture, and the mint was a nice change. Highly recommend for a special celebration where you want great food at a fair price, and no pretension.
We can’t wait to come back. Thank you Noah!
Cornelly is an absolute must-visit for anyone in Seattle looking for exceptional pizza. Tucked away in Queen Anne, this spot delivers an experience that is both cozy and incredibly delicious. From the moment you walk in, the warm and inviting atmosphere makes you feel right at home, setting the stage for a fantastic meal.
While the entire menu looked appealing, the pizza is unequivocally the star of the show. We ordered a pie and it was simply amazing. The sourdough crust was a masterpiece of texture and flavor—perfectly chewy with a delightful tangy finish and a beautiful char from the oven. It provided the ideal foundation for the high-quality toppings, which were fresh, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. Each bite was better than the last, showcasing a clear passion for the craft of pizza making.
The service was friendly and attentive, adding to the overall positive experience. Cornelly isn’t just serving good food; they’re creating a wonderful dining environment. It has instantly become my go-to recommendation for anyone craving truly top-tier pizza. If you’re looking for a meal that will leave you smiling and planning your next visit before you’ve even left, this is the place. Highly recommended!
As far as my own experience goes, food and service was solid. We ordered the Tagliatelle, the Fun Guys Only pizza, and the Hamachi Crudo. The pizza crust was nice and crispy, and the mushrooms were delicious. The restaurant is warm and inviting, and I appreciate the large bathrooms which we were able to do a diaper change for our baby in. I’m glad we were able to give this place a try.
My friend and I ordered the Chicory Caesar, the Classic Pep, and the Bucatini. The Bucatini came out cold and was pretty dry, though the spice on it definitely helped and kind of saved the dish. The classic pepperoni wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t anything special either—fine, but not a standout.
I think I came in with high expectations given all the buzz and, as a pizza lover, I left feeling underwhelmed. The food was unmemorable, especially considering the price, and I’ve had better pizza elsewhere for less. I don’t think I’ll be back, but I am glad I tried it!
Our salad came out quickly but wasn’t well done – it was full of grit and hadn’t been properly washed or drained, so it was very wet, gritty and the dressing was watered down. Disappointing.
We ordered two pizzas and a pasta. The first pizza came out quickly and was just barely cooked with no color on the crust. The pizza delivered to the next table was burnt- they are very inconsistent. About 20 minutes later our second pizza came out (fun guy) a lot more cooked. Both needed more sauce, and the mushrooms could use some salt or oil. The pasta didn’t show up until after about an hour. The server asked if we wanted dessert, and we reminded them about the pasta which she had forgotten and had never checked on us. The pasta was tasty – I just wish it had come out while we were still eating. We ended up taking it home with us. In all, very disappointing. The food was like 3-4 out of 5, but the noise/music volume was excruciating, so we won’t likely hurry back anytime soon.
I was amazed with Capitol Hill location pizza a couple years ago, but due to parking issues I rarely visited. I was so happy to discover Queen Anne location with 2 parking lots near by.
Pizza that we ordered had exceptionally dry crust (I even hurt my hard palate). Ginger lemonade was too gingery I barely made 4 sips my throat was burning.
This was end of our dinner (photo), as you can see we only finished our salad out of things we ordered (drink, pizza, salad, pasta)
Pizza dough is stretchy and tender, pasta has bite and holds to sauce nice, tiramisu with the cocoa nibs and salt instead of cocoa powder is such a hit.
If the owner is reading this I am begging you to have warm chocolate chip cookies w/ ice cream on the dine in menu again. A Cornelly Pizzookie would go so hard.
This was especially disappointing since other recent reviews show the scallops prepared much more lightly and appealingly (see screenshot of a review posted a month ago). A good server experience, but the chef’s response left us feeling dismissed.
The dining experience can be made more family friendly: there are high chairs but no booster seats; no kid craft/menu to engage little ones so it was difficult when it took 15min to even place an order – we had to take our kids out for a walk. Background music was very loud and its acoustically hard to have a conversation.