Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 3–7:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New York Pizzeria | Waterville NY – Facebook
New York Pizzeria is a family owned restaurant we are committed to only serving the best of everythi
New York Pizzeria | Waterville NY – Facebook
❄️$50 GC to the New York Pizzeria (Frank & Rosa’s, in Waterville!) ❄️ $50 GC to Dollar General!! ❄️ $25 to Serene Touch and Gingerbread house kit!!! GOOD LUCK …
New York Pizzeria – Waterville: Authentic New York-Style Pizza …
Discover New York Pizzeria – Waterville at 111 W Main St for generous toppings, fresh slices, subs, and wings. Enjoy consistently delicious food with …
Reviews
Jessica(info) Miracle
This may just be the best pizza I’ve ever had and for a ridiculously low price. We got 2 slices of pizza, 2 meatball sliders, and 2 drinks for right around $18. We were both stuffed. The service was great. The atmosphere is cheesy, but in the best way possible. We are visiting from Colorado and this was a surprise I was not expecting!! Highly recommend!!
… moreCollin Smith
This pizzeria is perfect, the food is exceptional, with large portions and being delicious. The staff is very helpful and quick serving your food. It also has a large indoor eating section for a pizzeria. I would never not recommend this place.
… moreDouglas Seitz
Had some of the best food was really good I’ll be going there from now on
… moreAutumn Owens
Environment and people are nice but the pizza is undercooked and has too much on it. Like it is cooked and edible but it is way too blonde. It’s like they’re cooking the pizza juuuust until the cheese is melted and then they take it out. No leopard spots of browning and there’s so much cheese it all slides to the middle.
… moreMatt P
I was driving through Waterville and noticed this pizzeria. Stopped in for a slice and it was very very good. I was greeted instantly by the pizza maker and my slice was more than perfect. I will definitely stop back again on my next time through Waterville
… moreJoe L
Excellent pizza and cooked perfectly. Sauce has a great flavor profile. Crust was spot on also Great friendly service at this rustic pizza joint.
… moreAaron Strong
We moved to the area about a year ago and tried out a few of the local pizza places. After a lot of not so good pizza, finally found NY Pizzeria in Waterville. It is consistently excellent. Toppings are generous. Food is yummy! Service is small town great!
Service is personal and outstanding, whether it’s the owners or the staff. This place is always slammed, yet they are happy to greet you, politely take payment, and say good bye when you leave.
Yesterday I ordered a pizza with extra sauce on one half. My crazy aunt likes lots of sauce! They mentioned adding it on the side, so I went with a whole pizza with sauce. Then, I got there. The owner showed me how I could tell which side had the extra sauce. They did it! Half extra, half regular.
We’ve had multiple subs, appetizers, slices, garlic knots, and whole pizzas. Everything is always consistently yummy. I don’t know they do it, given how busy this place is. Their systems work!
These people are the best! I hope to come back to this place for years!
… moreService is personal and outstanding, whether it’s the owners or the staff. This place is always slammed, yet they are happy to greet you, politely take payment, and say good bye when you leave.
Yesterday I ordered a pizza with extra sauce on one half. My crazy aunt likes lots of sauce! They mentioned adding it on the side, so I went with a whole pizza with sauce. Then, I got there. The owner showed me how I could tell which side had the extra sauce. They did it! Half extra, half regular.
We’ve had multiple subs, appetizers, slices, garlic knots, and whole pizzas. Everything is always consistently yummy. I don’t know they do it, given how busy this place is. Their systems work!
These people are the best! I hope to come back to this place for years!
Sandy Abbott
Frank’s is always the best! Great food,atmosphere, and people!!!!! Celebrate grandkids Birthdays every year here.
… moreTedd Gras
The first time there and the staff was so warm and welcoming. Even the local customers that were there to get their food were super friendly. Great food suggestions from everyone. I was recommended this place by a friend. I will definitely be going back again to sample more of what they have to offer. Prices are great. Bulk sausage being pulled into pieces and put on the pizzas and the mozzerella cheese was like it was freshly shredded if you were at home making your own pie. It is worth the time to go there.
… moreJulianne Burchill
Best place around this area. Wings are cooked to perfection with just the right amount of sauce. And the pizza is loaded!! You definitely get your money’s worth. Plus you walk in and everyone is always so nice and working so hard.
… more