Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
We are delighted to announce that our grand opening is scheduled for Thursday, June 12th. Our restaurant will feature a retail market highlighting the seafood we serve on our menu. Order any menu item for takeaway or dine in, and browse our selection of fresh fish to prepare at home.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 14 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
Phone: (516) 584-6982
Website: https://sunsetfishandlobster.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: spotapps.co
Related Web Results
Sunset Fish & Lobster Grill & Market – Bayville, NY
We went to Sunset Fish & Lobster Market for dinner. We had the lobster rolls with sweet potato fries. The waiter and waitress were very nice and professional.
Food Menu – Sunset Fish & Lobster Grill & Market – Bayville, NY
Our Menu · Starters · Raw Bar · Soups · Sandwiches · From the Fryer · House Specialties · Land Lubber · Salads. Add-ons: Shrimp (6) +$15.00 | Salmon +$15.00 …
Sunset Fish & Lobster Grill & Market – MapQuest
Get more information for Sunset Fish & Lobster Grill & Market in Bayville, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Last Updates
Reviews
Adam Arguijo
One of the best tasting lobsters rolls! Our dine in meal was amazing octopus was cooked perfect, and the lobster was caught that morning 🙂 I will definetly be having another dinner date here
We also had a catering on a other occasion, highly recommend the food and service 🙂
… moreWe also had a catering on a other occasion, highly recommend the food and service 🙂
Michael Anthony
Always a red carpet when we attend this waterside restaurant. Food and service is first class and super fresh seafood is unmatched! I especially enjoy, selecting the fish you would like prepared and the chefs tailoring the plate. To go options are also excellent also with daily specials
… moreSJMG15 S
I had the lobster roll at Sunset Fish and Lobster Market and it was hands down the best I’ve ever had. The lobster was super fresh, perfectly cooked, and they were generous with the portion. It came on a warm, buttery toasted bun that complemented the lobster without overpowering it.
You can tell the seafood here is high quality. everything is fresh and you really taste the difference. The service was friendly and quick.
… moreYou can tell the seafood here is high quality. everything is fresh and you really taste the difference. The service was friendly and quick.
Helen Mann
Really good lobster roll with homemade chips. I love that you can choose between hot or cold lobster roll. Great menu overall, looking forward to coming back!
… moreBruce W
We went to Sunset Fish & Lobster Market for dinner. We had the lobster rolls with sweet potato fries. The waiter and waitress were very nice and professional. We really enjoyed the lobster rolls. We are looking forward to going back again.
… morechris borer
This place is amazing. Right next to the sound. The food is phenomenal. The shrimp tacos were so good and the omelette was stellar. Great food and amazing atmosphere. I can’t wait to come back during the summer
… moreRita Schaller
We were looking for a seafood place near the water on a Monday and this restaurant was one of the few opened. We were so pleased by the delicious food we were served! The lobster bisque was full of big chunks of lobster. The crab cakes were wonderful and so was the lobster roll which cost less than it did in Maine last week! It is not a fancy place but very clean and the owner was very friendly! They also sell a wide selection of fish that you can buy to take home.Its only been opened for a few months but I think it will develop a following of customers.
… moreKay Valino
Lobster roll and clam strip platter delicious and fresh! Home made chips had the biggest crunch. Overall a really nice late lunch, and the view of the water is a plus! Highly recommended with attentive staffing and casual vibe.
… moreIvan Torres
I wish I had the better experience that others had. I ordered 2 Shrimp platters and 1 fish and chips. And it was pretty bad. The shrimp were over cooked, badly, and the breading they used had an awful taste which made it worse. The shrimp was gummy and chewy and hard to swallow. I couldn’t make it past 2 pieces of shrimp and my wife gave up after the first shrimp she ate.
I decided to eat the Fish and Chips instead and that was weird. The fish itself was slimy. It looked as if the batter didnt cook evenly and the texture really threw me off. It wasnt flaky like fish and chips are normally. Sadly, I spent a good amount of money just to throw the food out because of it’s taste. I hope that this was just a bad day and the next time, it will be better.
Side note, the home made chips with old bay seasoning was actually really good and the staff were friendly. The place is very clean and they have a large selection of food to choose from.
… moreI decided to eat the Fish and Chips instead and that was weird. The fish itself was slimy. It looked as if the batter didnt cook evenly and the texture really threw me off. It wasnt flaky like fish and chips are normally. Sadly, I spent a good amount of money just to throw the food out because of it’s taste. I hope that this was just a bad day and the next time, it will be better.
Side note, the home made chips with old bay seasoning was actually really good and the staff were friendly. The place is very clean and they have a large selection of food to choose from.
Doondar Wood
Very impressive. The oysters were some of the best I’ve ever had. I got the po’boy and it was right up my alley. I might make this place a more frequent stop. Can sit down or take out. It’s kinda set up like a deli when you first walk in but there’s seating to the right and a couple tables on the sidewalk with umbrellas where you can see the LI Sound. If you are planning on going to the beach. Its about 200 yards away. Totally walkable. Or you can walk directly across the street and just look at the water. But it’s not a beach. Just views of the sound. Theres also a small playground right across the street for the kids. Really nice little spot. Definitely recommend. Bayville is the hidden gem of Long Island. Support small business!
… more