Michael Barnett
Colin was awesome at Selma’s Pizza. Even as a busser and making salads, he was working hard the whole time and had such a good attitude. Our table was cleared quickly, everything stayed clean, and the salads were fresh and made perfectly. He was super respectful and always moving, making sure things ran smoothly.
You can tell he really cares about doing a good job, Selma’s is lucky to have him.
… moreMrBlockHeadHero
Best Chicago style IN OC! I tried the peppy pizza with riacata cheese,goat cheese and made it Chicago style ($5 extra). I would definitely recommend their Chicago style pizzas, personally best item on their menu. Paid $44 for a large pizza that I added custom things to. Honestly was very worth the price and it filled me so I wasn’t hesitant about the price. Would definitely for special occasions or unless you want an amazing pizza!
… moreTony G
Really love this. As a Chicagoan I have a problem comparing it to home. But now as a resident here I’ll say it’s closer to anything you’ll find outside of the city. Get pizza here. Enjoy it. It’s awesome.
… moreMark Skorupa
We moved away from OC 5 years ago. Selma’s was always our favorite pizza place when we lived here so when visiting, we had to go for dinner. You know how you have great memories of places when you move away only to be disappointed when you finally go back? Well, I am happy to say that was not the case here. It was even better than we remembered. It was a busy Friday night but we were able to sit at the bar. Service was fast and the pizza and beer were amazing. Highly recommended!
… moreNick Kristobak
Enjoyed our meal here, had the wings, margarita pizza and cheese pizza. Pizza was good but the wings were better really enjoyed the buffalo wings and buffalo chicken salad. Actually the salad was the best part. Nice patio as well
… moreMo Ghazal
Best Chicago style pizza in south county! Also one of the best places to get wings! Selma’s is one of my family’s favorite places to eat. Pizza, calzone, wings. Beer and wings. Wine and a pizza. Just an easy neighborhood joint for us. Oh, and the garlic parm fries! And the bruschetta!
Service is not their selling point. But the food is so good we just keep coming back regardless.
… morePilar Rey
We ordered a 1/2 tray of lasagna, 1/2 tray caesar salad, and 6 New York Cheesecake two days before our New Year’s Eve Party. One hour before we were allowed to pickup the food on New Year’s Eve, Selma’s called to say there was an error and they can’t make the lasagna for us.
They offered a baked ziti dish as a substitute that was terrible. The baked ziti was almost all noodles and very little meat and cheese.
Also, the the lasagna ordered as a meal on its own comes with a side of garlic bread. Even though we ordered a 1/2 tray of lasagna we were told at pickup we would have to pay extra for the side of garlic bread.
We are disappointed because we live nearby and it is convenient for us to order food here for our parties. Considering the circumstances, we feel we overpaid for the meal and would not wish to purchase food from Selma’s again in the future.
… moreNicole Povich
This place is inconsistent. Sometimes it’s great and other times the pizza has a rock-hard crust, clearly a pizza dough problem and the turkey wrap is loaded with old rotting lettuce and skimping on turkey. I can’t trust it.
… moredermeister0000
I tried pasta, wings, Chicago-style pizza, and personal cheese pizza. All the food is carbs floating in tomato sauce. Maybe it’s OK as a bar snack, but I would not visit Selma for the food.
… moreKaren Otto
First time at Selma’s
It was kind of busy but not overcrowded.
There’s a cute little fire pit going with comfy bench seats along with family style seating along with high tables and chairs and booth style seating too
Super cool to see Casey and Bob jamming out with some great tunes ♥️
I ordered some chicken tenders (can’t go wrong with those) along with the pretzel bites.
The pretzel bites were super friggen good ♥️
I ordered a Cape Cod with Tittos Vodka and that’s that!
Late
… more