Hanna Hill
This is 1000% my favorite place to eat in the Keys. This is the one place I recommend to new travelers. You can’t beat the fresh seafood and outdoor seating, combined with the fun upstairs bar with great deals. I love that meals are ordered under a fun question and answer for the order versus just your name. The seafood is always fresh and prepared well. Portions are very comparable to the price. I will eat here several times during my stay. Our go-to order is stone crab, hot peel n’ eats, a side of fries, and calamari. The fish sandwich is also amazing. Their whole menu is done well, you can’t go wrong with any order.
… moreLeonie T
This spot has great potential. The view is lovely, and the seating area by the water is super relaxing.
We ordered the fried octopus and the lobster Reuben, since we heard that’s what King’s Fisheries is famous for. The sandwich could have been amazing if the sauerkraut hadn’t ruined it for us. To be fair, as Germans, we think our sauerkraut (and bread—but that’s another story) tastes the best, so others might actually enjoy it.
Unfortunately, we just didn’t like the flavor, even though the lobster itself was very tender and juicy. The octopus, on the other hand, was quite tasty.
So overall, it didn’t go as well as we had hoped, even though we really wanted to love this place.
… moreF. Ploi Pagdalian
What an experience. Keys Fisheries is everything you hope for in a true Florida Keys experience. The food is grilled to perfection — the Mix Grill (lobster, scallops, shrimp, and mahi mahi) bursts with flavor in every bite. The views are absolutely breathtaking, especially from the second-floor bar, which offers the best vantage point for sunset. Every evening, they raise a glass and make a sunset toast — a charming ritual that captures the laid-back spirit of this place.
A must-visit for fresh seafood, stunning scenery, and that unmistakable island vibe.
… moreBeing Journal
I’ve come here since 2009, and this is one of my favorites seafood restaurants in Marathon. I was disappointed with the foods. Went here for stone crab but it wasn’t in season. So sad. Cashier seem like brand new, slow and weak.
The conch chowder was fishy. I didn’t like it. Boneless chicken wing also not good. Skinny fried calamari. The oyster crackers were chewy and smelly.
This place was at the top of my list but I’m not going back. Price and quality left me disappointed.
… moreSunshine Levin
Oh divine lunch! We had lionfish tacos and a hogfish sammy at Keys Fisheries. We skated in right as they cut off the line before they closed for Christmas. These are fish best served fresh, and ours were fresh!!!
… moreMark Campbell
Hang around for sunset shots (traditional) and a beautiful sunset! The Stone crab claws are awesome! Get there early it fills up quickly
… moremaurice solner
I had the ruben… was leary of it, but they are famous for it… when in rome lol it was good, but a 1 and done for me, fries were quite tasty and crisp. My Gf had a decent drink and we loved the location.
… moreStephanie R
We stopped by for lunch after our kayak guide recommended the stone crab claws. They did not disappoint! The crab dip was very good, as well. Everything we ordered from sandwiches to salads was fresh and delicious. We could not enjoy the view, as it was too chilly and the plastic was down, but the space is roomy and had a fun coastal vibe to it. You order and pick up at the counter, so it’s no frills with great food!
… moreOliver Berlic
The bartenders are great and attentive. This is some of the best seafood you can find on marathon. And they have great pricing. Honest and fair. Definitely stop by to see the tarpon and nurse sharks as it’s always entertaining.
… moreBrittany Moss
This is our fourth trip to the Keys and hands down the best seafood meal I’ve eaten. The atmosphere is so fun. We were there after dark so you could see the huge tarpon and nurse sharks in the marina. We had the paella and it was 10/10!!! My 13 year old said it was one of the best things he’d ever eaten. We also had the crab and artichoke dip and key lime pie. All were excellent.
… more