Tony Del Pino
This was my 1st time having pizza in Long Island. Growing up as a Brooklynite, I had no reason to look for pizza elsewhere.
What an incredible date spot in the middle of RVC. Old school coal oven pizzeria. The original flooring is still intact. The menu is straightforward, with wine and beer options available as well.
We ended up getting a Pep/Sausage combo. A great balance of cheese to sauce. Fresh mozzarella. Acidic tomato sauce. A tasty pie. I wish it was a bit crispier, but that is just my preference. Delicious nonetheless!
… moreFrank Lee
The service was prompt and courteous although it was a slow night. The food was overall good but portions were on the small side. We found the six small baked clams pricey at $20. The pizza was flavorful but the bottom should have been firmer as the slice flopped when picking it up. At $15 for a glass of wine we should have received a higher quality wine than a $9 bottle at retail.
Overall in my opinion not worth a return visit.
… moreMarianna Flannery
I just had my daughter’s baby shower in the front side room at Blue Moon. The staff were so accommodating. They helped make the party run seamlessly. The food was fantastic and plentiful. Everyone loved the family style service. They helped with set up and take down and even let us set up the night before after their dinner service was completed. It was great having two private bathrooms too. I am so happy I chose Blue Moon to celebrate this wonderful day! I highly recommend Blue Moon for your next event or just a lovely dinner with friends. Thank you to Erica and Victor and Faith who couldn’t do enough to make this day special for us.
… moreDawn D
Made reservations for a Friday night dinner. We were seated right away. The service was excellent & the food was delicious. This was my first time here, but it was definitely not my last.
… moreLuke Henry
We wanted to try a new pizza place in RVC so we decided to give the Blue Moon a shot and it was well worth it. The margarita pizza is by far the one of the best that we’ve had in the area. LeAnn was out waitress and she was fantastic. We will definitely be back. If you’re in the area, I recommend you stop by.
… moreTeena Phillips
This restaurant was amazing!! The wait staff were so accommodating and kind! The private dining room is large and yet cozy at the same time! The food was PHENOMENAL!!! It was an awesome place to have our office Christmas party!
… moreJacqueline Vita
I have passed this quaint restaurant many times but just never had an opportunity dine here. It was sure worth the wait. The staff is attentive, polite, and swift in the order taking and delivery of our food. We enjoyed two paninis for lunch. The grilled veggies and chicken cutlet paninis were cooked to perfection. The bread had nice flavor and a good crust. The fillings were ample and accompanied by a yummy sauce served on the side. A great spot for lunch and from the black board specials, we shall visit for dinner very soon.
… moreScuba Divemaster
Wonderful service, the staff always make me feel welcome and are proactive, polite and friendly. The restaurant is very cute, cozy and decorated nicely. I ordered a calzone here after having great ones in 2022, not sure if the ownership or head chef changed since then. But the new calzone does not resemble a calzone, it is more like a heavy roll, almost like a chicken roll. Also, it was burnt to the point it was acidic. I hope Blue Moon will use this feedback to improve, and produce a light fluffy calzone in the correct shape and consistency, instead of this brick-like burnt slab.
… moreBetsy Purvis
Staff was extremely friendly and efficient, we had Caesar salad, meatball hero and pepperoni pizza everything was fresh and delicious!
… moreC Jiles
This is a local gem, and our server(Josh?) did not steer us wrong. We used to dine at Blue Moon years ago, before we moved, and decided to dine here Friday 10/6/2023. It was after 9:00 pm and the staff was welcoming and attentive. The 3 different types of complimentary bread, baked clams, Striped Bass special, Tiramisu dessert, and cappuccino were delicious. The entrée was large enough to share with my husband, and pictured are the specials menu, leftover Striped Bass entree, and half of the dessert. We highly recommend Blue Moon and will definitely return at our next visit to New York. Thank you for an excellent dining experience!
… more