Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
No-frills, counter-serve operation specializing in pizzas, pepperoni rolls & chicken wings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4290 Bee Ridge Rd, Sarasota, FL 34233
Phone: (941) 371-3333
Website: https://fivestarpizzasarasota.com/?utm_source=google
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Sarasota | Five Star Pizza | FL
Dine in or order delivery in Sarasota at Five Star Pizza. Taste our fresh dough, real cheese, and hearty toppings!
Five Star Pizza | FL
Experience fresh, hand-tossed dough and premium toppings at Five Star Pizza in Florida. Order now for fast delivery or carryout!
Five Star Pizza – Bee Ridge | Sarasota FL – Facebook
Five Star Pizza – Bee Ridge, Sarasota. 362 likes · 4 talking about this · 29 were here. Family friendly dine-in, carryout, and delivery! we have fresh…
Last Updates
Reviews
Dorothy Bean
The food was ok, which is why I gave two stars instead of one. Unfortunately they wouldn’t accept their own $12 “gift card” that they sent out as an incentive to bring in business. The gift card literally says “no strings attached” and says nothing about not being able to use it in conjunction with your own rewards points/coupon. It seems silly to lure in new customers and immediately lose those same customers over $12 but I guess that is how they run their business.
… moreAlison Goser
Reliable, fast, and budget-friendly! Open until 3 AM with an XL 2-topping deal for under $20 that can’t be beat. It isn’t NY style, but the quality is high and the delivery service is always on point. Highly recommend if you want great pizza without the long wait. Our family’s go-to spot! $5 delivery can’t be beat.
… moreRaymond Kallatsa
The staff was so friendly. Garlic bread was the best I’ve had, that is no lie. The pizza was scrumptious! And can’t forget the cinnamon roll for dessert that was out of this world. If you pass this place up. You are making a big mistake!
… moreCarey Johnston
I love the Wisconsin cheese and they are one of the few places that has green olives anymore. Staff is always friendly and make sure you’re happy. Garlic bread and cinnamon rolls are amazing too! They always give you Parmesan which is cool too. They usually have deals too, like tonight we got a text for 40% off which was why I ordered!
… moreMelinda Rutherford
I dont eat in so cant really rate the atmosphere. From what I see at the register it’s just fine though.
Alice rocks though. She remembers us so when I placed an order that I had nothing noted for square cut she called to make sure that was so. Made sure our order was accurate. Also order on their website not through Doordash etc If you’re picking up. You earn points and rewards for things like free garlic knots that are super good btw.
Pizza is good and cheap for the size. They have an $18.99 special. Big pizza with 2 toppings. You can also earn points. Go check them out if you haven’t
… moreAlice rocks though. She remembers us so when I placed an order that I had nothing noted for square cut she called to make sure that was so. Made sure our order was accurate. Also order on their website not through Doordash etc If you’re picking up. You earn points and rewards for things like free garlic knots that are super good btw.
Pizza is good and cheap for the size. They have an $18.99 special. Big pizza with 2 toppings. You can also earn points. Go check them out if you haven’t
Kathy Odom
I order the cinnamon rolls every few days, and they’re the best I’ve had anywhere. They’re always really nice and kind to me when I pick up and so I really appreciate that
… moreThomas
I tell everyone Five Star is the best delivery pizza in the SRQ area. The big chains (dominoes, Pizza Hut even hungry howies) are all awful compared to five star. I also appreciate that 5 star isn’t overly salty like the others!! Amazing pizza keep it up!!
… moreKatherine McLaughlin
I can’t say enough good things about this location. The staff is very helpful and polite. The food is great. I never have a problem with this place
… moreTroy Davidhizar
Another great Sarasota restaurant! Had Five Star delivered tonight (so that we could enjoy them on the beach). On time and fresh. Staff was friendly. Sauce is delicious and crust cooked perfectly. The plain cheese pizza was very good. I recommend their version of a meat lovers pizza. Generous toppings and not greasy like alot of pizzas topped heavily with meats.
… moreSophia Neubauer
Despite not being able to taste due to a bought with COVID I can say the texture of their pizza is very good. Came visiting all the way from Orlando bringing the whole family we got the largest pizza they offer and it fed all six of us with left overs! It was a good decision to come here, and now any time we are in town we will for sure eat here.
… more