Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Relaxed, brick-clad neighborhood pub serving hearty comfort eats alongside cocktails, beer & wine.
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Friday | 12 PM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 12 PM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Monday | 4 PM–12 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1346 Main St, Cincinnati, OH 45202
Phone: (513) 954-8415
Website: https://www.facebook.com/The-Pony-OTR-1327700877321830/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Pony OTR | Cincinnati OH – Facebook
The Pony OTR, Cincinnati. 4017 likes · 16 talking about this · 1887 were here. Neighborhood bar with great bar food + drinks, games, and overall fun…
ThePonyOTR – Instagram
Third Eye Amber provides a great base for our beer batter. We have made a few other tweaks to both the fish fry and the wing process. The Pony has always …
The Pony – Visit Cincy
The Pony · 1346 Main St., Cincinnati, OH 45202 · (513) 954-8415 · Visit Website.
Reviews
Heber Alonso de la Parra Morales
A nice local restaurant/bar with a great selection of beers—feels like the perfect after-work pub. I had a cheesesteak sandwich, and it was fabulous, along with some cheese fingers that were also great. The spicy ketchup was a nice touch. On the downside, the service was cold and unwelcoming. Also, food took a long time to get our table. I only tipped because they helped me charge my phone; otherwise, I wouldn’t. Another drawback is the lack of free parking. Still, it’s a good spot to hang out with friends.
… moreSean Brady
One of my favorite bars downtown. All food is made from scratch, and smaller menu size, meaning what they do make is freaking amazing. Awesome bartenders & good beer selection.
… moreTabitha Addy
The chicken strips weren’t pretty good! Great fries! The Philly cheesesteak was ok but needed some more spice or something.
… moreLex
I heard that the fries here were some of the best in town, so I stopped by before a MOTR show to grab a bite with friends! Genuinely shocked how GOOD everything actually was…I came for the fries but I think about the chicken tenders at least daily. Both were perfectly crispy, paired with a great selection of dipping sauces. Their house ranch (unsure if it’s proprietary or a specific brand?) was top notch. The G&T I ordered wasn’t anything to write home about, but for how tasty the bar food is I truly didn’t care.
I only removed a star because we put in an order of fries for the table that was lost and never came, but that’ll happen to any bar every now and again during insanely busy periods. Otherwise the staff were locked in and provided great service. Will be coming back!
… moreI only removed a star because we put in an order of fries for the table that was lost and never came, but that’ll happen to any bar every now and again during insanely busy periods. Otherwise the staff were locked in and provided great service. Will be coming back!
Hannah Levings
We are from out of town. We came here for a baseball game years ago and LOVED everything.
Came back to see the Bengals and Detroit play and can only say that the food and staff have gone down hill. Wings? Much smaller. Please, please, get the bigger ones back and just hike the price.
The hottest sauce they have in the menu tasted like tomato soup expired with Tabasco added. I think it fermented too much? It was bubbling if you shook it.
Bar staff? Taking shots and beers with people I’m sure they know and rude as hell. Don’t mind that in a dive bar setting like this but they could not be bothered with any one else in the building. I was excited to come back here and was pissed off.
Very disappointed and will be hoping Cincinnati gives us a new wing place to check out when we come back.
… moreCame back to see the Bengals and Detroit play and can only say that the food and staff have gone down hill. Wings? Much smaller. Please, please, get the bigger ones back and just hike the price.
The hottest sauce they have in the menu tasted like tomato soup expired with Tabasco added. I think it fermented too much? It was bubbling if you shook it.
Bar staff? Taking shots and beers with people I’m sure they know and rude as hell. Don’t mind that in a dive bar setting like this but they could not be bothered with any one else in the building. I was excited to come back here and was pissed off.
Very disappointed and will be hoping Cincinnati gives us a new wing place to check out when we come back.
Michael Santangelo
Some of the best chicken and fries in the city, hands down. Their chicken is freshly fried, their fries are fresh cut, and the sauces are made in house.
If I were to give two suggestions to the place, it would be to identify a better ventilation solution as you are guaranteed to leave smelling like grease. Secondly, ordering food at the bar can be cumbersome, it would be a lot easier to order from a QR code at the table for food.
… moreIf I were to give two suggestions to the place, it would be to identify a better ventilation solution as you are guaranteed to leave smelling like grease. Secondly, ordering food at the bar can be cumbersome, it would be a lot easier to order from a QR code at the table for food.
Patrick Kaple
Wing dip, wings, fries. Like the 3 horseman. They were out of beef when we went but honestly when you have so many ridiculously good chicken options it did not matter.
The buffalo pizza logs were also a very delightful app.
… moreThe buffalo pizza logs were also a very delightful app.
Maison Arroyo
We heard the food was good, so we decided to check out the Pony. First time going, and wow it was a good time.
Relaxed vibe, great (but small) menu, and awesome food, although, the beer selection was lacking.
It was nice there were booths as well, on top of the bar itself – I liked that we were able to sit down and eat and chat at a table vs a bar.
Benches were kinda dirty though lol, but nothing terrible
I got the honey mustard wings they have – and wow, absolute bangers, seasoned perfectly & piping hot.
The burger with a slice of bacon was stupid delicious. A little overcooked on the meat but it wasn’t even noticeable enough to care about. Cause that bacon kicks you in the mouth on your first bite.
Simply put their burger is severely underrated.
the fries were unbelievable – flat out some of the best (and thickest) I’ve had in a while. Flaky, crispy, crunchy & covered with sea salt, their fries are a must.
All in all, cool spot to grab a bite and have a beer and if you’re bar hopping, one worth stopping in!
… moreRelaxed vibe, great (but small) menu, and awesome food, although, the beer selection was lacking.
It was nice there were booths as well, on top of the bar itself – I liked that we were able to sit down and eat and chat at a table vs a bar.
Benches were kinda dirty though lol, but nothing terrible
I got the honey mustard wings they have – and wow, absolute bangers, seasoned perfectly & piping hot.
The burger with a slice of bacon was stupid delicious. A little overcooked on the meat but it wasn’t even noticeable enough to care about. Cause that bacon kicks you in the mouth on your first bite.
Simply put their burger is severely underrated.
the fries were unbelievable – flat out some of the best (and thickest) I’ve had in a while. Flaky, crispy, crunchy & covered with sea salt, their fries are a must.
All in all, cool spot to grab a bite and have a beer and if you’re bar hopping, one worth stopping in!
Maureen Capretta
Walked in on a Friday evening, and our group was definitely seen coming in… didn’t get a hello and did not get served, even standing at the bar holding money out waiting for over 10 min. It was busy, but not crazy. One bartender was washing dishes, the other came over to whisper to the one washing dishes, and then walked right past us to lean over and talk to customers who had drinks/didn’t need a served at the time. It felt as if they do not serve our group on purpose. So we walked out. Extremely rude & very disappointing!
… moreKelsey Meyer
Loved this place! The habanero garlic wings were SO GOOD. They reminded me of a spicy teriyaki a bit if you’re into that (I am). The ranch was really tasty too! I’m OBSESSED with the fries. I kept dipping the fries in the wing sauce & ranch (trust me do it!) the beef on weck was good,but will definitely get more wings next time. I feel like the beef on weck would be good with a creamy horseradish sauce vs the plain horseradish (personal opinion, it was still good). Drinks were great. LOVED the atmosphere & location!
… more