Bianca W.
Absolutely loving Pizza Mart. The pizza is outstanding—perfectly cooked with a great crust and generous toppings. I ate here with my boyfriend and we loved it. Such a cozy, enjoyable experience. This place truly does pizza right, and we’ll definitely be back!
… moreRyan Rainford
WOW, what can I say about A Pizza Mart First Hill… I’ve been a fan since it opened almost ten years ago!
Other than it’s more than just your run of the mill Pizza Joint (which the pizza is yummy). The people that work here are legitimately some of the best bartenders in Seattle and they pride themselves on creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere for the guests.
The neighbors and surrounding businesses have created this space as more of a community meetup or third space, if you will.
The music is great, movies on the TVs are fun to watch & they play the sports here! Go M’s, Go Hawks!
There is Trivia on Wednesdays and RuPaul’s Drag Race (with sound) on Friday’s.
I cannot emphasize enough how much of a neighborhood, community, all inclusive place that this has become. We are all Fam here at APM First Hill.
… moreBobby Moran
I’ve gone to every pizza mart and am a regular in a sense. I went to Pizza Mart at First Hill last night with some friends who were visiting all the way from the East coast for a wedding. I talked this place up, and was excited to bring my friends. Then, when we arrived, we got in line and quickly realized we were in one of the server’s way. It was trivia night and I understand you all were busy, so I did my best to get out of her way. Instead of being kind, she said (in the snottiest, rudest tone), “You’re literally right where I need to be going!” to me in front of my girlfriend and my 2 friends. I felt bad, but I also was pretty upset somebody could be that rude to a customer at a place I trusted and am familiar with, a place I go to regularly. I told my girl friend and friends I did not wish to stay and they understood as they saw the way this rude woman spoke to me. Instead of spending $100-200 in your establishment, we left, and went to the pizza place a block away which was honestly a really pleasant experience. I’ll never go to the First Hill location again, thanks to this rude, entitled employee. PS, I’ve worked plenty of customer service oriented jobs myself, not once, EVER, did I treat an patron like that no matter how busy or frustrated I was. Makes me sad.
… moreAngelo Rocha
This was my first time coming to this place and I’ve tried other pizza spots before this. This place was very well welcoming upon arrival with a positive social vibes which made it even more positive.
Our server was the bar tender and she was very friendly with us and all the guest she was making drinks for. The pizza we had couldn’t compare to anything I’ve have tried before and to replicate this or outdue this spot will defiantly be hard to compete with. The pizza alone hit all the right spots on the tastebuds upon the first bite. Coming here is very well worth it!The pizza was made fresh and the dough had that rise to it. Perfect amount of toppings, sauce and flavor throughout the pizza. I strongly wish I can order this pizza through the phone and have them shipped it to me! This will definitely be the first spot I come to eat when I visit again!
… moreNeo One
About a week ago, A Pizza Mart was found during the early dinner hour while trying to take care of my cravings for brew and pizza.
The atmosphere was chill with a mix of sports and action movies showing on the screens. It’s cozy there, not a large dining area but it offers some window seats, seats facing the screens and obviously a few bar seats.
This pizza spot is located at First Hill near the freeway, about 3 blocks and walking distance from the downtown hotel I’m often using during my Seattle visits.
Yes the bartender was friendly, the large pizza with veggies was great and the IPA’s on draft were cold. Total bill was reasonable and worth it. Definitely will go back again soon.
… moreJeremy Yowell
A Pizza Mart was a cool start to our Seattle visit. Really appreciated their hours, service, and chill vibes. Food was good but not amazing, but the options available fit the experience and were fun overall. Cool spot!
… moreSara Hilliard
yall are wrong and thieves. I spent Almost $40 on Christmas last year thru the slice app. When I went to go pick it up the door was locked and lights were off. At the entrance on Seneca. I don’t know if there’s another entrance or what. But I assumed the app made a mistake and you guys were closed since it was Christmas. I call the next day to get a refund and the person who answers the phone was rude and kept telling me the manger was not there. I called like 3 days in a row never able to speak to a manger. I dispute the charges thru my bank and at first they gave the money back so I assumed I got my refund. Now two months later I find out my bank declined my disputing the charge. So now 2 months later I will have to go in person to get my $40 back cuz when I tried calling multiple times back in december I was never able to speak to a manger. This is a huge company. I know you have $40 to waste. I do not. Shame on you.
… moreRobin Nelson
It’s been a while since I reviewed any place let alone one in Seattle. But looking around for a decently priced place to eat that wasn’t 4 miles away is far harder than I remember the last time I visited so when I stumbled upon a pizza mart I knew I had to make another one. A super fair price, great food, great safe atmosphere and not insanely busy (though it deserves to be). If you’re staying downtown for PAX and everywhere is inexplicably closed by 4pm, stop in here. You won’t regret it.
… moreCB 31
The bartender was VERY concerned about getting his tips. It felt extremely awkward and we left early because of it. Me and my friends went outside to smoke. (We left our things at the table) And when I come back in the bartender says “do you not tip at bars?” We weren’t done, we weren’t leaving we just stepped outside to smoke. We were planning on coming back in and ordering more drinks, but after his temper tantrum about not tipping at the counter (do people not leave cash on the table anymore?) we decided to leave. He cost the business a couple hundred and himself at least another $40. Also just to add on, we were there for over 2 hours he did not ask to start a tab, every drink was paid for at the counter, sorry if I don’t wanna figure out 15% of literally every transaction and wanted to leave it till the end. We will not be back.
… moreChris Pacifico
The pizza was really good, the service was quick and friendly. The only issue I had was I ordered wings but got bread sticks. I was really hungry and didn’t want to wait. That being said the pizza was very good and light on the sauce (my favorite). The bread sticks (although not wings) were tasty. I would order from here again.
… more