Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Counter-serve eatery dishing up pizza, pasta, subs & Italian entrees in a casual storefront space.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 154 Carroll Island Rd, Middle River, MD 21220
Phone: (410) 335-3433
Website: https://bestmargheritapizza.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Margherita’s Pizzeria: Home
11771 Belair Rd, Kingsville, Maryland 21087. (410) 593-9800. OR. Carroll isl., Middle River. 154 Carroll Island Rd, Middle River, Maryland 21220. (410) 335-3433.
Margherita’s of Carroll Island | Middle River MD – Facebook
154 Carroll Island Rd, Middle River, MD, United States, 21220. Links. . bestmargheritapizza.com. Services. . Specialties. Dine-in · In-store pickup …
Margherita Pizza Of Middle River – Grubhub
Middle River, MD 21220. (410) … The driver was great. View all reviews. FAQs. Q) Does Margherita Pizza Of Middle River (154 Carroll Island Rd) deliver? A).
Reviews
Ostine Chen
I don’t know how to express my love for their sun dried cherry tomato chicken ranch pizza. It is just so good and I order a whole pizza everytime I go there. It is a MUST try. Their bread is just so good and appetizing. It fills up a whole family and you may even have left overs.
… moreDave White
Absolutely the best pizza we’ve ever had. Our family can’t help but order here every time we’re in Middle River/White Marsh.
… moreCorey
On Wednesday, May 7, 2025, I called at 5:48 PM to place a pickup order for a cheesesteak sub. Unfortunately, the condition in which I received the sub was unacceptable.
Upon returning to the store to address the issue, I showed the staff the state of the order, but no one seemed to know how to respond or offer a resolution. I was met with confusion rather than assistance.
As a paying customer, I believe in supporting local businesses, but I also expect a standard of quality and service. Regrettably, based on this experience, I do not plan to return.
… moreUpon returning to the store to address the issue, I showed the staff the state of the order, but no one seemed to know how to respond or offer a resolution. I was met with confusion rather than assistance.
As a paying customer, I believe in supporting local businesses, but I also expect a standard of quality and service. Regrettably, based on this experience, I do not plan to return.
Truva Kaplan
I love coming here and sometimes take the 59 out to Carroll Island just for this restaurant. They sell by the slice so you don’t have leftover pieces in a cardboard box to carry around. Very cozy place never had a bad bite here!
… moreErica Novik
*Update: Came in for dine in service. Food was good. No complaints. Not really a sit down restaurant more so carryout. It was very warm inside. We enjoyed the food and the time together. Restaurant was clean and relaxed. I liked the coastal decorations and the plates. Just not my favorite place to dine in.
I ordered the Margherita pasta with a caesar salad and shared it with my girls. The food is so good. Its a nice treat when your craving seafood pasta. The seafood is good quality and the sauce is delicious. My late sister loved this pasta so now its my homage to her. Will be ordering again.
… moreI ordered the Margherita pasta with a caesar salad and shared it with my girls. The food is so good. Its a nice treat when your craving seafood pasta. The seafood is good quality and the sauce is delicious. My late sister loved this pasta so now its my homage to her. Will be ordering again.
Nicole Fox
Love this place. I’ve gotten pizza, spaghetti pie, Italian cold cut on focaccia(so so good), and multiple different salads. Always thrilled with everything I get. They have great weekday lunch specials!
… moreD Solomon
You have to try the procutto and mozzarella sandwich. It is served on fresh baked bread and is always delicious.
The staff is wonderful. Highly recomend this restaurant.
… moreThe staff is wonderful. Highly recomend this restaurant.
J D
This is one of my favorite places to get food! Everything is always so delicious and they never get our order wrong. The crab Chesapeake pasta dish is the best thing I’ve ever had!
… moreBrittany Garland
Delicious, family friendly place. Pizza slices are my favorite since there are so many options. I’v been going to the Kingsville location for years but found the Carroll Island location not too long ago. Have already gone twice, will sure to go back and definitely have told my friends!!
… moreTiffany P
Used to love this place and it would be where we would go for family outings often. Over the past year, the crust will literally show up wet. Not soggy from oil, but literally wet and almost falling apart. Similar to when someone puts bread in the sink. (GROSS) It happened a couple times but I figured maybe they would get a new chef or something eventually and kept coming back. They had to realize eventually and correct it right? Idk… I will say I didn’t receive a wet pizza the last time I went, but tonight I tried to go and the kids at the register tells me they close at 8:45 and that we can’t eat there regardless of it being 8:30 and the place being advertised and closing at 9. It really makes me sad because this used to be my favorite place but this place has gone so down hill. If only they kept the good workers. Or at least hired new people who wanted to work. If you go there after 5 they don’t allow you to sit on the right side of the restaurant because they don’t even want to clean up. They are in a rush to hurry up and leave before the store is even supposed to shut down apparently. I guess the boss don’t work evenings? I’ve worked at delis and carry out spots. This is not how things are done normally. Maybe you can’t put an order in at a certain time but that’s not what I was told. I was told that he can make the food but I have to leave at 8:45. Sorry boy at the register with glasses… It says right on the door what time you guys close so you aren’t fooling anyone.
… more