Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Long-running small chain with retro flair for pizza & other Italian comfort fare, plus beer & wine.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bellmore | Hours + Location – Umberto’s Pizza
Umberto’s of New Hyde Park—Nationwide Shipping. The Umberto’s Family has … Hours & Location. 208 Bedford Ave, Bellmore, NY 11710 · 516-409-1400. Sunday …
Bellmore Menus | Umberto’s Pizza in NY
Pizza · Regular Pie. $24 · Sicilian. Square pie, 12 slices. $28.95 · Grandma. Square pie, 12 slices. $26.95 · Grandma Broccoli Rabe & Sausage. Square pie, 12 …
Umberto’s of Bellmore (@umbertosbellmore) – Instagram
Umberto’s of Bellmore, NY We Ship Nationwide! Voted Best Pizza Long Island! Try our authentic pasta & entrees. Call us at (516) 409-1400!
Reviews
Gabriella Sobell
My family and I have been coming here for years, and when I came in to pick up my order tonight, I noticed a new crew of employees behind the counter, that I haven’t seen before. We ordered a cheese pizza with garlic KNOTS!! Simple enough, right? We were told to come within 20mins, and we did. When we arrived, the order was NOT ready, and we did not receive our garlic knots!!! Instead, they gave us chopped up bread pieces with garlic bread oil/seasoning on it. Thankfully they didn’t charge us for it, according to the receipt, but we didn’t know about this until we got home. HOWEVER the CHEESE PIZZA apparently came to $28.35!!! EXCUSE ME??? Almost $30 for a CHEESE PIZZA??? It honestly didn’t even have the same consistency as before!!!! I did however, over hear the cook come out and say they didn’t have any garlic knots. If (and since) that was the case, they could have told us so we didn’t have to bother wasting food??? Or maybe ask us what can they give us instead, and still make a profit from the order??? I don’t know. Anyway- seems like Umbertos may have switched owners, or managers? Otherwise, I can’t see why they have a whole new slew of workers that I never seen before, and have terrible service. Our food order was not ready, when it was supposed to be, no garlic knots, but instead give us chopped bread???? And the cheese pizza didn’t taste as good as it used to be! Just tasted bland- and the cheese wasn’t stringy. Idk… hopefully this was a 1 time mess up???
… morePwagismyname
I frequent this place every time I’m in town, and the pizza is good but yesterday they did something that bothered me so much I have to leave a review.
They have all the pizza on display with an untouched Sicilian pie. After visually inspecting all my options I decided it looked best so I ordered one slice. After several minutes of waiting I noticed the pie still had all the pieces untouched. So I said, “oh I thought I was ordering what I was looking at.” The counter people chuckled after seeing how frustrated I was.
Then it comes, an old Sicilian slice that had been sitting there the entire day (it’s 5PM now). I was very irritated and took a bite into a cold Sicilian slice, yes, that’s how long it had been sitting there for. So I walked up to the counter and requested another slice and paid again. I left the old slice on the table after I finished to leave a message.
Don’t display customers food that they will not be getting served, and if you can tell the customer is really unhappy with what you just deceived them into getting, you should probably not charge them twice for it. If that slice was on display, I wouldn’t have ordered it.
… moreThey have all the pizza on display with an untouched Sicilian pie. After visually inspecting all my options I decided it looked best so I ordered one slice. After several minutes of waiting I noticed the pie still had all the pieces untouched. So I said, “oh I thought I was ordering what I was looking at.” The counter people chuckled after seeing how frustrated I was.
Then it comes, an old Sicilian slice that had been sitting there the entire day (it’s 5PM now). I was very irritated and took a bite into a cold Sicilian slice, yes, that’s how long it had been sitting there for. So I walked up to the counter and requested another slice and paid again. I left the old slice on the table after I finished to leave a message.
Don’t display customers food that they will not be getting served, and if you can tell the customer is really unhappy with what you just deceived them into getting, you should probably not charge them twice for it. If that slice was on display, I wouldn’t have ordered it.
Adam Holtzer
This review is because of a great experience I had with one of the employees in their named Jessica. Jessica was helpful, friendly, patient and helped me with various questions I needed to know about having Delivery for an event I was hosting. Keep up the great work!
… moreEdwin Valentin
Don’t go here because I want them all to myself. Lol the food is outstanding. The Capellinis are incredible. Not to mention everything else they make including the rice balls. Umberto’s is making pizza great again. Guess what? they also deliver quickly. I’m so happy I moved to Merrick, this is the best spot.
… moreJ
I called for a delivery, I am one town away, I called and asked how much for a delivery and the guy says it is a $20 minimum.. $20 minimum to go to the next town?
I was gonna order a hero, plus tip, not like I was only ordering 2 slices of Pizza.
The guy on the phone tells me, that’s only gonna come out to $14 for the hero, so he was basically making me have to add stuff on just to get to the $20 minimum so, they can deliver it. When they do that, it takes off of the tip I was gonna give the delivery guy, so that sucks for him.
They have excellent food, but I am never ordering from them again… That was an insult. Not like i was having the guy deliver 30 minutes away or something, then i would understand him saying a $20 minimum for delivery to pay for the gas, but to the next town over which is like 5 minutes away?
… moreI was gonna order a hero, plus tip, not like I was only ordering 2 slices of Pizza.
The guy on the phone tells me, that’s only gonna come out to $14 for the hero, so he was basically making me have to add stuff on just to get to the $20 minimum so, they can deliver it. When they do that, it takes off of the tip I was gonna give the delivery guy, so that sucks for him.
They have excellent food, but I am never ordering from them again… That was an insult. Not like i was having the guy deliver 30 minutes away or something, then i would understand him saying a $20 minimum for delivery to pay for the gas, but to the next town over which is like 5 minutes away?
LINY 1234
I really wanted to like this place. My son and I started going here after his games. We went only a couple of times and we really enjoyed the pizza. I tried the sausage roll one time and unfortunately that was pretty bad, it was very soggy and not too tasty.
I’m giving a negative review because of the service. The guy with the curly hair was not that pleasant to begin with, not that big of a deal, but more than that I’m confident that he hooked me for $10. The total was $24.75, I handed him $40 and he gave me back $5.25 in change. The reason I didn’t confront him was because I was in the middle of a happy conversation with my son about his accomplishments. I didn’t even want to bother bickering with someone who either can’t count or is trying to rip me off. I’m pretty certain because I looked at my bills before I handed it to him, I returned from the ATM where they dispensed only $20’s to me ($100 total). I was more amazed that he would do that, I knew right away, and he sheepishly looked at me while I waited for my pizza. I’d rather go this route than go back and forth with a stranger in front of my kid.
I’ll admit the pizza is very good (rolls maybe not). Please double check your bill, your change and stay alert if you go here. To the owner, hopefully you can get some good staff ( a smile, basic counting skills) in there so your pizza can shine. I’m so tempted to give only 1 star, looking at the other reviews the service seems to be a real problem . This was such an unforced error, like c’mon why are you operating at this level in this nice town?!
… moreI’m giving a negative review because of the service. The guy with the curly hair was not that pleasant to begin with, not that big of a deal, but more than that I’m confident that he hooked me for $10. The total was $24.75, I handed him $40 and he gave me back $5.25 in change. The reason I didn’t confront him was because I was in the middle of a happy conversation with my son about his accomplishments. I didn’t even want to bother bickering with someone who either can’t count or is trying to rip me off. I’m pretty certain because I looked at my bills before I handed it to him, I returned from the ATM where they dispensed only $20’s to me ($100 total). I was more amazed that he would do that, I knew right away, and he sheepishly looked at me while I waited for my pizza. I’d rather go this route than go back and forth with a stranger in front of my kid.
I’ll admit the pizza is very good (rolls maybe not). Please double check your bill, your change and stay alert if you go here. To the owner, hopefully you can get some good staff ( a smile, basic counting skills) in there so your pizza can shine. I’m so tempted to give only 1 star, looking at the other reviews the service seems to be a real problem . This was such an unforced error, like c’mon why are you operating at this level in this nice town?!
Jessica Solano
The food here is incredible! My personal favorite dish is short ribs and mashed potatoes that they have as a special. This dish is absolutely to DIE FOR!!! The staff is incredible and it feels like home when you come here! LOVE, LOVE, LOVE Umberto’s!❤️❤️❤️
… moreMary Jane
The place is nice and cozy. It has a family atmosphere, and the food is very good. We ordered calamari’s as a starter, the flavor really surprised me at how delicious they were. For the main course we ordered spaghetti carbonara and penne a la vodka. 10/10 I will definitely return.
… moreHolly Karp
This Umberto’s has the best of everything. Food is so authentically Italian. Not greasy or loaded in sauces just quality perfectly prepared food. Service – exceptional. I envied The atmosphere bringing me back to my childhood. The wall with beautiful papers distressed perfectly. I was mesmerized and wish I could inquire about the artist who was sent me back in time.
… moreDaniel Pino
Umberto’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Layout/atmosphere
*Booths in front by display case, tables in back; three TVs; backyard area with tables
Food/drink
*Margherita Pizzetta – quite good; thicker crust; really liked the tomatoes/sauce
*Vodka Square Slice – solid; very thin; oily
… moreLayout/atmosphere
*Booths in front by display case, tables in back; three TVs; backyard area with tables
Food/drink
*Margherita Pizzetta – quite good; thicker crust; really liked the tomatoes/sauce
*Vodka Square Slice – solid; very thin; oily