Nancy P
There was about a 45 minute wait for our party of 11. The pizza was delicious. The crust has a very good flavor. Our children were given a small ball of pizza dough to entertain them while we waited for our food. The sides of the building were garage doors which were open. The fresh lake breeze was lovely. We could watch children playing on a large splash pad. It was quite noisy with the din of voices. It was hard to hear the rest of our party in conversation. It seemed a bit pricey, but definitely overall a positive experience.
… moreKaren
Its it’s own destination. Where you can be in a historic building, that is still an active train station for Amtrak. Then over look Lake Michigan with a huge beach available. You’ll never be disappointed.
We ordered 3 large. Margherita. Undertow. Meat Mania. Fantastic!
Reasonably priced, especially for the whole atmosphere given.
Totally go! You’ll not be disappointed in the least. Just remember, it can get really busy on the weekends
… moreMarissa WT
We had such a delightful evening with our nomad friends in St. Joe and chose Silver Beach Pizza for dinner. I can’t recommend it enough—10/10! We picked it specifically because of their clearly designated gluten-free and allergy-aware menu, and they truly delivered.
The pizzas were fantastic (and that’s saying something coming from a Chicago girl!). I’m not a deep-dish lover, but I do appreciate a great thin crust, and Silver Beach nailed it. We ordered the Garlicky Greek with dairy-free cheese, plus a gluten-free cheese pizza—both were absolutely delicious.
The prices were very reasonable, and the staff was super friendly and helpful, making the whole experience even better. I’d totally go back again!
… moreAmy Kilgren
This spot is one of our family’s all-time favorites for gluten-free pizza! We hadn’t been in a few years and were blown away by how much they’ve leveled up — not only is the pizza better than ever, but they’ve added some seriously fantastic breadsticks too. If you’re in town and have someone gluten-free in your group, this is the place to go. Everyone — gluten-free or not — will walk out happy and full!
… moreJacinda Greene
Pizza is usually delicious, that’s why we come back. Understandably seating is hard to get without a 2 hour wait. But the server giving the pizza we ordered was so UNFRIENDLY. She gets a 1/10 (because at least she handed me the pizza) We’ll probably be back next season when we visit, hopefully she won’t be We got the cheesy bread, very good. Kids say 8.5/10. Got UJ Sunburst pizza, weird but decent and fresh tasting. Kid says 5/10 (I say 7.5/10) And got BBQ chicken pizza, good. Kids say 6/10 (I say 7/10).
… moreTom Deesto
Great pizza. Chicagoans, if you love Aurelio’s, you’ll love Silver Beach. Good draft beer choices. Cool atmosphere with Amtrak along the side and great views of the sunset across Silver Beach. Always busy. Pro tip – the rooftop deck (indoors) takes reservations (no kids) but you need to call a week in advance for prime times. Service is always great despite how busy they are.
… moreJon Schoenborn
Good pizza selection! Good beer selection! Great time! I had lunch in the Overview Bar area and sat on the lake side. There was a good view of the lake and waves crashing. Good view of the park!
… moreAlan Hedrick
Just as they said – GREAT!!! Unique pizzas … had the Harvest Pizza … odd one but was so fantastic. We loved it. Made good friends at the bar. Drinks were fantastic. Staff was super great!!!
… moreAlexa Beltz
Was told there was a 20 minute wait, and we were sat within 7. Server was super nice and food came out quickly. I really enjoyed the Irish Nachos (loaded fries) and my mom loved the Bruschetta. Pizza crust was crispy and delicious. Really neat place! Would definitely visit again next time we are visiting town.
… moreH
Stopped in and tried a gluten free pizza which i really enjoyed, a regular pizza, gluten free breadsticks quite dense consistency. My son enjoyed the chicken tenders and fries. No wait to be seated on a busy Thursday beach day. The fans felt great as a break from the heat.
… more