Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Giovanni’s | Monticello NY – Facebook
. 98% recommend (30 Reviews). . $. . Open now. . 4457 State Route 42, Monticello, NY, United States, 12701. Services. . Specialties. Dine-in. Contact info.
Giovanni’s – Authentic NY Pizza Experience in Monticello
Discover Giovanni’s, a beloved pizza restaurant in Monticello, NY. Enjoy crispy pizza by the slice, hearty Italian specialties, and warm, friendly service.
Giovanni’s Subs & Pizzeria, 4457 State Route 42 … – MapQuest
Giovanni’s Subs & Pizzeria is a local eatery in Monticello, NY that specializes in serving a variety of subs and pizzas.
Reviews
Tarkia McGrier-Hamilton
I wanted a Cuban sandwich but made with chicken and no ham. Kudos to the cook. I was told at first they couldn’t do it but to satisfy a customer it was made. The taste I was looking for exceeded my taste buds. Thank you!!!
… moreJeffrey Phelan
As Good as a Deli Gets, Fast,Courteous and Delicious!
… moreEmanuel Pascal
I recently take out at Giovanni’s restaurant in Monticello, and unfortunately, my experience was far from satisfactory. The overall cleanliness of the establishment left much to be desired, with noticeable dirtiness throughout. Additionally, the lack of proper cleaning standards was concerning. The pizza I ordered had a poorly cooked dough, with only the exterior receiving any attention, and it certainly lacked freshness. Furthermore, the sandwiches my companions ordered were disappointingly identical despite being different selections. The most concerning aspect was the lack of proper hygiene practices among the staff, with only the cashier wearing gloves while others handled food without any protection. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this restaurant. It was a one-time visit for me, and I have no intention of returning.
… moreSelene Inparadise
OMG. First time here, just passing through town. Got the meatball sub half – and it’s huge! And the taste, it’s exactly as I remember from my days growing up here. The texture of the hero was spot on!! Meatballs must have been cooking all day, delish!! If I’m still in town tomorrow, I’m coming back to try their eggplant parm!
… moreC B
Great subs here. I have been getting food here since I was a little kid and they were in their original location next to Paul Paskows liquor store where burger king is now. Their staff is friendly and good at their trade. Prices are fair. Never have had a bad experiance here in 30 years. You have to try their Godfather with everything!!!
… moreMechel Donato
Oh my goodness if I could choose zero stars I would !!!!!
What a horrible experience … once again, this is the third time that we have ordered food this month and each time it was just awful .. we went back a second and third time thinking maybe they were just having a bad day maybe there was a new cook but this seems to be the norm now absolutely awful food !!! The Stromboli was completely raw, meatless and tasteless. The pizza tasted like Ragu Sauce and rotten cheese !!!
Tonight will certainly be the last night we ever order from this place ever again !!!!!
… moreWhat a horrible experience … once again, this is the third time that we have ordered food this month and each time it was just awful .. we went back a second and third time thinking maybe they were just having a bad day maybe there was a new cook but this seems to be the norm now absolutely awful food !!! The Stromboli was completely raw, meatless and tasteless. The pizza tasted like Ragu Sauce and rotten cheese !!!
Tonight will certainly be the last night we ever order from this place ever again !!!!!
Cody Fegley
We had pizza and garlic knots. I thought pizza was good my little 3 year old told the cook it was not. Staff were super friendly joked with our younger children and were overall very nice.
… moreFrancis V
Are you looking for delicious food? Good prices? It’s here! If your looking for marble floors? Waiters to take your order & fine wine? Don’t come here . I have been coming for 3 years now and the meatball sub is as delicious as the first time. The staff are friendly and helpful.
Thanks for great food!
… moreThanks for great food!
Vincent Apollonio
The pizza was okay but I’ve had better. I made the mistake of thinking I was in N.Y. and the pizza was going to be great no matter where I was…..Not the case. The sauce tasted like they opened the can of raw tomatoes and poured it on without cooking it. We had pepperoni, mush and olives on it. Pizza was crisp on the bottom but the top needed to be cooked little more. It was done just enough where the top of the pizza wasn’t left too soft which in turn left the raw mushrooms they used slightly undercooked The crust could’ve been a little crispier was a tad too soft.
The subs we ordered were great. Tuna melt, cold tuna grinder and three shaved steak grinders. The steak grinders had sauteed mush, onions and peppers the meat was sauteed and flavored perfectly and tasted great. Tuna melt and cold tuna were excellent, the tuna was made nicely not too much mayo and not too dry. Only thing I didn’t like was that they used yellow american cheese on the melt.
… moreThe subs we ordered were great. Tuna melt, cold tuna grinder and three shaved steak grinders. The steak grinders had sauteed mush, onions and peppers the meat was sauteed and flavored perfectly and tasted great. Tuna melt and cold tuna were excellent, the tuna was made nicely not too much mayo and not too dry. Only thing I didn’t like was that they used yellow american cheese on the melt.
Paul Gianquinto
Giovanni’s is a Monticello legend. Excellent menu. Great food. Home of the “Godfather” sub. There are probably poems written about that hero . Highly recommend.
… more