Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 15725 37th Ave N Suite 5, Plymouth, MN 55446
Website: http://elmarsnypizza.com/bagels
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bagels – ElMar’s NY Pizza
Bagel Pop-Ups. Thank you for visiting! Our hand rolled, kettle boiled bagels can now be reserved online. Please see below for details.
ElMar’s NY Pizza
BAGEL POP-UPS · Order Online · BAGEL POP-UPS. ElMar’s New York Pizza. 15725 37th Avenue North, Plymouth, MN 55446. [email protected]. Hours. Today. Closed …
ElMar’s Bagel Pop-Ups Taking Off In Plymouth – TC Jewfolk
So when there is bagel news, I act on it with impunity! A few years ago, ElMar’s NY Pizza opened in Plymouth (15725 37th Avenue North), and I’m …
Reviews
Peter Schmidt
Tough review to write, because the bagels are delicious, the egg and bacon are very good, the processed American cheese they put on as THE ONLY CHOICE ruins the whole thing. Paying that much money to have plastic cheese is ridiculous. With all the money these guys are making now, at least use real cheese as your only option.
I know that was the last time getting bagels here, this social media hype ruined everything.
P.S.: Don’t waste your money on the hash browns, unless you like “hand seasoned” McDonald’s hash browns.
… moreI know that was the last time getting bagels here, this social media hype ruined everything.
P.S.: Don’t waste your money on the hash browns, unless you like “hand seasoned” McDonald’s hash browns.
Jake Giebel
Best bagels in Plymouth, hands down. The everything bagel with cream cheese is my go-to — always fresh, perfectly chewy with a nice crust. Staff is friendly and the line moves fast even on weekends. If you have not tried the jalapeño cream cheese, you are missing out.
… moreJohn Walker
These are the best bagels I’ve found in the twin cities.
… moreSherief
Pretty disappointing that I waited in like before 9am outside in the cold. Got into the store by 930am and by the time I got inside they told us that they wouldn’t take any more orders. They sent probably around 50 customers away. I have had the bagels before and they are good but should be something about honoring customers that get there well before the closing time.
… moreSeth Kuretsky
If you’re looking for a true NYC bagel, you’ll have to go to New York. But if you want a darn good bagel give this place a try. The bagel is soft and fluffy inside, slightly crunchy on the outside. If you’re like me, cream cheese is everything. It was a classic whipped style cream cheese that compliments the bagel well. Good shmear, they don’t skimp on quantity.
Only plain, everything, sesame, and poppyseed available. The menu has a couple sandwiches that looked really good as well.
If you’re local to the area, definitely give this place a try. We usually go to Bruggers, but this could very easily be the new spot. Make sure to check online for their special pop-up hours.
… moreOnly plain, everything, sesame, and poppyseed available. The menu has a couple sandwiches that looked really good as well.
If you’re local to the area, definitely give this place a try. We usually go to Bruggers, but this could very easily be the new spot. Make sure to check online for their special pop-up hours.
Annie McNeill
I had high hopes for this…We arrived at 9:30 and waited in line for over an hour. The line BARELY moved. Then One hour later an employee said, “sorry we’re not serving grill orders anymore.”
First of all, EXPLAIN that to the people standing in line. Terrible experience, the manager didn’t seem to be managing anything. It should not take over an hour to get a bagel sandwich, New York would be embarrassed. What a waste of time. Their website should be updated to explain how long the order process is going to take or make a a better way to prepare and process orders
… moreFirst of all, EXPLAIN that to the people standing in line. Terrible experience, the manager didn’t seem to be managing anything. It should not take over an hour to get a bagel sandwich, New York would be embarrassed. What a waste of time. Their website should be updated to explain how long the order process is going to take or make a a better way to prepare and process orders
David Bergman
Is it worth it to stand in line. I am not a bagel connoisseur. I love good bread. Never had a real Bagel from New York.
Are they better then Brueggers? They are different then Brueggers.
Bought 10 bagels. 4 everything 4 plain 2 garlic and some scallion cream cheese. I also bought a breakfast bagel sandwich with egg, bacon and cheese.
Maybe a better question would be, would I go back for bagels. Maybe I am missing something, but I don’t see or taste anything special or different about them.
I only ate the sandwich so far. I had it on a garlic bagel. The sandwich would have been better with some cream cheese on it and some salt and pepper. It was flat.
Everything bagel is really tasty toasted with the scallion cream cheese.
It’s a nice place and the people (employees) are really nice and polite.
I would like to try their pizza sometime.
… moreAre they better then Brueggers? They are different then Brueggers.
Bought 10 bagels. 4 everything 4 plain 2 garlic and some scallion cream cheese. I also bought a breakfast bagel sandwich with egg, bacon and cheese.
Maybe a better question would be, would I go back for bagels. Maybe I am missing something, but I don’t see or taste anything special or different about them.
I only ate the sandwich so far. I had it on a garlic bagel. The sandwich would have been better with some cream cheese on it and some salt and pepper. It was flat.
Everything bagel is really tasty toasted with the scallion cream cheese.
It’s a nice place and the people (employees) are really nice and polite.
I would like to try their pizza sometime.
Kasey F
Drove 40 minutes to try a breakfast sandwich I heard good things about. Get there 45 minutes before they close and they tell me they won’t serve egg sandwiches. Im watching them put eggs on the grill for other people’s egg sandwiches, so I know they are not out. They will not give me an explanation and are very rude on top of it.
Worst service possible.
… moreWorst service possible.
Duazong Thao
went there for their weekend bagel pop up and truly disappointed because they stopped selling sausage at a certain time to have enough for “later”. it should be first come first serve.
… moreMatt
Like they’ve done with the pizza game, they’re hitting bagels out of the park. Well seasoned and cooked to perfection they’re available plain, with a spread, or sandwich form – all relatively inexpensive. The jalapeño cream cheese was super fresh and flavorful. I do with they had a pizza bagel, I mean c’mon! This is how bagels should be – highly recommended.
… more