Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: Norman Island, British Virgin Islands
Phone: +1 284-443-1305
Website: http://www.piratesbight.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pirates Bight
top of page. OCTOBER 2025 THRU TO JULY 2026 11 AM – 9 PM / 7-days per week. Pirate’s Bight Logo[20].png. Logo_PiratesNorman.png.
Pirates Bight | Road Town British Virgin Islands – Facebook
Pirates Bight, Road Town. 9154 likes · 55 talking about this · 7166 were here. Norman Island, home of Pirates Bight restaurant, bar, and gift shop, is…
Pirates Bight (@normanisland) • Instagram photos and videos
Norman Island, home of Pirates Bight restaurant and gift shop, is most famous as the inspiration for Robert Louis Stevenson’s novel, Treasure Island.
Reviews
Cassie Smith
Yummy! Stopped for lunch on a boat day! Beautiful setting on the ocean, great food and wow the lime in the coconut and bushwhacker drinks rocked! We got the mozz sticks, coconut shrimp, Mahi Mahi sandwich, wahoo sandwich – all great!
… moreForrest McKay
If Pirates Bight were graded solely on atmosphere, it would be a slam‑dunk five‑star stunner. The place looks like a postcard someone forgot to Photoshop because it’s already perfect — turquoise water, soft sand, and a sunset that makes you wonder if God has a favorite color palette. We arrived early, plenty of open seating on the beach, and I thought, “This is it. This is the moment. This is the dinner scene from every Caribbean travel commercial ever made.”
And then… we were seated under the roof.
Only near the beach and tucked back just far enough to be obstructed by trees and sunshades. I asked if we could move to one of the many open beach tables, but apparently the difference between six people and seven is the difference between “absolutely” and “not a chance.” Never mind that we could have fit. Never mind that this is a once‑in‑a‑lifetime dinner on Norman Island. Rules are rules, and Pirates Bight was sticking to them like barnacles on a hull.
Friendly staff, yes. Flexible staff? Not so much.
Thankfully, the bartender was working overtime to keep the mood high. We started with a round of Painkillers — delicious, strong, and almost strong enough to make me forget the beach‑table heartbreak. Almost.
Then came the food.
I asked the waiter for his recommendation, and he confidently steered me toward the pan‑fried snapper. It arrived fast and hot, which was promising… until I took a bite. Kind of dry and notably bland. The kind of fish that makes you whisper, “Really? On an island? I can see the fish from here…” Honestly, my air fryer at home has produced more memorable seafood, and it doesn’t charge me $60 for a round of water which turned out to be bottled in Fiji. At that price, I expected the bottle to come with a treasure map or at least a pirate to come pour it for me.
Meanwhile, two guys in our group ordered the Pirate’s Pasta and were having a borderline spiritual experience. I sent my snapper back and made the switch, and suddenly life made sense again. Rich, flavorful, and exactly what you hope for when you’re eating dinner on a legendary pirate island.
So here’s the final verdict:
Go for the atmosphere — it’s flawless.
Stay for the bartender — they’re doing the Lord’s work.
Prepare for food that’s hit‑or‑miss and prices that qualify as legal piracy.
If you manage to snag a beach table, you’ll probably forgive everything. If not, well… at least the Painkillers are strong.
By the way, make time to do the amazing hike which starts on the left side of the restaurant, we did that the next day, not hard and the views are spectacular.
… moreAnd then… we were seated under the roof.
Only near the beach and tucked back just far enough to be obstructed by trees and sunshades. I asked if we could move to one of the many open beach tables, but apparently the difference between six people and seven is the difference between “absolutely” and “not a chance.” Never mind that we could have fit. Never mind that this is a once‑in‑a‑lifetime dinner on Norman Island. Rules are rules, and Pirates Bight was sticking to them like barnacles on a hull.
Friendly staff, yes. Flexible staff? Not so much.
Thankfully, the bartender was working overtime to keep the mood high. We started with a round of Painkillers — delicious, strong, and almost strong enough to make me forget the beach‑table heartbreak. Almost.
Then came the food.
I asked the waiter for his recommendation, and he confidently steered me toward the pan‑fried snapper. It arrived fast and hot, which was promising… until I took a bite. Kind of dry and notably bland. The kind of fish that makes you whisper, “Really? On an island? I can see the fish from here…” Honestly, my air fryer at home has produced more memorable seafood, and it doesn’t charge me $60 for a round of water which turned out to be bottled in Fiji. At that price, I expected the bottle to come with a treasure map or at least a pirate to come pour it for me.
Meanwhile, two guys in our group ordered the Pirate’s Pasta and were having a borderline spiritual experience. I sent my snapper back and made the switch, and suddenly life made sense again. Rich, flavorful, and exactly what you hope for when you’re eating dinner on a legendary pirate island.
So here’s the final verdict:
Go for the atmosphere — it’s flawless.
Stay for the bartender — they’re doing the Lord’s work.
Prepare for food that’s hit‑or‑miss and prices that qualify as legal piracy.
If you manage to snag a beach table, you’ll probably forgive everything. If not, well… at least the Painkillers are strong.
By the way, make time to do the amazing hike which starts on the left side of the restaurant, we did that the next day, not hard and the views are spectacular.
Dan Maltese
Great base for the start of a Norman Island adventure! There are numerous trails that start behind the bar. Breathtaking views, especially if you go up to the top of the mountain. You can then take one of the trails to a water entrance near Willy T’s floating bar. From there you can snorkel the entire Treasure Point (caves and reef).
… moreJennifer Hunter
Romeo is the best! We talked to a wonderful group of ladies running the gift shop. Has just about everything touristy except magnets and minor pharmacy items. We went with tapas and were more than satisfied! There’s lots of places to park a dingy but the moorings were full by 2pm. You can pay to moor at the restaurant or they will come collect near sunset.
Willie T’s closed surprisingly early compared to the reputation I had read about. Don’t forget to leave your sticker!!
Took a short walk up the hill to the back to look for birds and found a couple goofy common ones. Everyone is so incredibly nice!!
… moreWillie T’s closed surprisingly early compared to the reputation I had read about. Don’t forget to leave your sticker!!
Took a short walk up the hill to the back to look for birds and found a couple goofy common ones. Everyone is so incredibly nice!!
Steven Damalas
Just a great place to spend the day at the beach in a small resort setting. Boy, do they make a delicious bushwacker! The venue is only accessible by boat. We took the restaurant’s private ferry boat from Nanny Key, Tortola for $11 per person. The ride was great and the boat was very seaworthy. They have a great lunch food selection.
… moreMel S
I like to say “You don’t come to the Caribbean for the food!” and this place meets that expectation. It’s a pretty location with a nice atmosphere and the staff are friendly but the food is pretty mediocre (visited 2x in 2019 and 2026). The “fresh” snapper was overcooked as were the 2 scallops served alongside. My boyfriend had the ribs and they were just OK, though slightly better than the ones at the Willy T. Go with appropriate expectations and you can’t be disappointed.
… moreJan Oltmanns
A lot of waiting.
We had lunch here and were seated in the middle, close to the bar. Despite the place not being full we had quite the waiting experience. For the menus to arrive, for the orders to be taken, for the drinks to arrive, for the appetizers to arrive, for the main to arrive, for more drinks to arrive, for the cheque to arrive and for someone to take our money. We stayed over 2 hours for what was supposed to be a quick lunch.
The food itself was ok. The conch fritters were nice, the shrimp were strangely sweet. Chicken fachitas were nice.
The setting is fantastic but the acoustics are terrible if you are seated right inside. It got very loud just from conversations. Had we had drinks we wouldn’t have cared, but we didn’t. So we sat at our table with no food and no drink, trying to have a conversation over the noise.
All in all, for the food, I would go again. Bring time, make sure you order drinks right when you are seated or it will take a while.
… moreWe had lunch here and were seated in the middle, close to the bar. Despite the place not being full we had quite the waiting experience. For the menus to arrive, for the orders to be taken, for the drinks to arrive, for the appetizers to arrive, for the main to arrive, for more drinks to arrive, for the cheque to arrive and for someone to take our money. We stayed over 2 hours for what was supposed to be a quick lunch.
The food itself was ok. The conch fritters were nice, the shrimp were strangely sweet. Chicken fachitas were nice.
The setting is fantastic but the acoustics are terrible if you are seated right inside. It got very loud just from conversations. Had we had drinks we wouldn’t have cared, but we didn’t. So we sat at our table with no food and no drink, trying to have a conversation over the noise.
All in all, for the food, I would go again. Bring time, make sure you order drinks right when you are seated or it will take a while.
Amanda Schuller
A place on the bucket list that you can only come to by boat! The best pain killer I have had yet! The pork nachos are delicious!
… moreJessica Chan
Come to Pirate’s Bight for an afternoon drink and apps or lunch. Delicious coconut shrimp. We decided to make a reservation for 10 people to come back for dinner and waited 3 hours to be served over cooked food and under cooked shrimp. The trigger fish and red snapper were overcooked.
If you go there, order the Lime in the Coconut for a refreshing island frothy drink, coconut shrimp or Conch fritters, scallops with chorizo, and a salad. The entrees seem to take extra extra long to prepare.
… moreIf you go there, order the Lime in the Coconut for a refreshing island frothy drink, coconut shrimp or Conch fritters, scallops with chorizo, and a salad. The entrees seem to take extra extra long to prepare.
Heidi Fitzharris
We enjoyed a delicious dinner and appetizers at Pirates Bight! Wonderful atmosphere to watch the sunset and relax into the evening! Definitely make reservations. They have a cute gift shop too. We saw several sea turtles earlier in the day while snorkeling in Bight Bay too! Fantastic place to enjoy while sailing the BVI!
… more