Adam Scott
The food was decent overall, but significantly overpriced for what we received. While everything was fine, nothing stood out enough to justify the cost.
The service was just okay. We felt a bit rushed, like the goal was to have us order quickly and move on. Our server didn’t walk us through the menu and gave very brief answers when we asked about specific dishes, which made the experience feel less welcoming and engaging.
With so many great dining options in the area, I don’t see us returning anytime soon.
… moreDustin Hostetler
Early dinner at 530 pm in the tourist off season was unrushed and uncrowded. See the included photos of the current menu with prices. The calamari was breaded in some of the lightest, crispiest breading we’ve tried to date. The dipping sauce seemed to be soy based with a splash of fish sauce maybe…it was very unique and tasty. The spicy Thai red curry seafood and linguine was delicious and filling. Just enough heat (spice) to leave your mouth humming slightly at the end of the meal. The beef short rib fettuccine was so well executed and the beef clearly was hand prepared in house. This entire meal reminded us of upscale comfort food. We enjoyed our meal and will be back. We did not include the extensive alcoholic beverage menu in our pictures as we did not consume alcohol with our meal. We also did not include the specials menu that had three or four different options.
… moreMoni Keo
Baker & Wife is an absolute gem! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warm hospitality and excellent service. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely made us feel welcome.
The food was nothing short of fantastic—each dish was expertly prepared, beautifully presented, and bursting with flavor. You can truly taste the quality and care that goes into every bite.
The ambiance was perfect—cozy yet stylish, with just the right balance of energy and comfort. It made for a truly enjoyable dining experience.
Overall, Baker & Wife exceeded our expectations in every way. If you’re looking for a place with amazing food, top-notch service, and a great atmosphere, this is it. Can’t wait to return!
… moreLeah Longyear
This was our first time dining here and we were so pleased. The food is excellent. The choices are unique. The sauces are amazing. We very much enjoyed the creative bartender, and our waitress was spot on!
… moreAleksandra Trojnar
I’m not local so sometimes it’s not easy to decide where to go for dinner. I was looking for a nice spot with healthy options. Baker and Wife seemed like a good fit, so my boyfriend and I decided to try. It did not disappoint! We started with a French glass of wine each while waiting for our food. Our server was very polite and friendly providing information about the menu since it was our first time there. We like to try different foods so always order two different meals. Spicy Thai red curry seafood & linguine + oven roasted salmon with cilantro sauce and a side of salad (I wasn’t a fan of raw green beans in my salad, I think a better option would be – asparagus ). We ended up splitting a cheesecake with some tart cherries and sweet cream – we enjoyed every bite!
That was a very romantic night. Great spot for a date night.
I recommend.
… moreKatalina
Visiting for Christmas, this was the best cocktail I think I’ve ever had. Food was also delicious. The tuna and the naan were incredible. Will come back the next time we’re in town!!!
… moreJane P
I recently visited this quaint spot for dinner and had a delightful experience. The Thai red curry seafood linguine was flavorful and satisfying, though I personally felt it could have been spicier to enhance the dish. On the other hand, the Korean BBQ meatloaf was exceptional—rich, tender, and packed with flavor. Overall, it’s a great place to try, offering a unique mix of dishes that cater to different tastes. The cozy atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a pleasant spot to enjoy a meal. I’d definitely recommend giving it a visit!
… moreLily Haak
a solid 4. i had the chicken with couscous, which was delicious — so is the tuna tartare. steak frites was just steak frites, and beware, the goat cheese, broccoli and butternut squash is served cold! no bread basket and laissez-faire service. good, but not great.
… moreRebecca Garcia-Larson
Disappointing first visit, especially given that I shared this feedback privately via email / the restaurant’s website and received no response.
There were issues with reservation handling by the hostess team affected the overall experience. Our server was attentive and apologetic but this issue could have be solved earlier instead of (kindly) being told to leave within 5 mins of being served dessert.
I had a 5:45 p.m. reservation booked through OpenTable. I arrived early and was told the reservation could not be found, even after showing the confirmation email. At one point, the hostess turned her screen toward me to show that my reservation “wasn’t there,” in a way that felt flippant and implied the issue was on my end rather than a system or process error.
I overheard staff mention they were unsure how to access OpenTable, and the interaction felt dismissive rather than treated as a system issue. I mentioned I was happy to sit at the bar, eventually seated, but it was presented as a favor, despite the restaurant having just opened and not being busy.
The larger issue occurred later. About 5–10 minutes before 7:00 p.m., just as dessert was served, we were told there had been a mistake with the reservation and that we needed to vacate the table within minutes. While the server was polite, no alternative seating was offered, or even comping the dessert.
Being rushed out immediately after being served dessert, especially on a first visit left a poor impression. With clearer reservation management and better guest recovery, this could be a much better experience.
Food was tasty, portions were good, and the ambiance was nice. I’d consider returning, but if you book through OpenTable, be prepared to defend your reservation.
… moreNYJ Sale
The atmosphere and décor were charming, and the food presentation was beautiful. Unfortunately, the quality of the meal did not match the prices. The 1/4 chicken was the smallest portion I’ve ever been served and extremely dry—barely edible, even with the accompanying sauce.
Service was also disappointing. Our server was inattentive, leaving no opportunity to address the issue during the meal. When I mentioned the problem upon receiving the bill, I was offered a replacement, but by then the rest of my party had already finished. There was no apology and no manager follow-up.
With so many excellent dining options in Sarasota, I would recommend choosing somewhere other than Baker & Wife.
… more