Nowas Wastape
I stumbled upon Beekman Ale House during a trip to Sleepy Hollow, and it was one of those rare “random stops” that turns into a highlight of the trip. The atmosphere is wonderful—warm and welcoming, yet quiet enough to actually have a conversation, which is a breath of fresh air compared to some of the rowdier spots in town.
The food here is the real star, specifically the pizza. I had heard rumors about their Detroit-style pizza, and it lived up to every bit of the hype. The crust was the most fabulous crispy texture I’ve ever tasted, with just the right balance of toppings. My only regret is that the Detroit-style is currently a Tuesday-only special, though it definitely deserves a permanent spot on the menu! Even if you miss the Tuesday window, the regular pies are easily some of the best I’ve ever had. Don’t skip the garlic knots either; they are an absolute 10/10 and perfect for sharing.
To round out the meal, the Espresso Martini was mixed to perfection. I noticed the Guinness pour could have been a bit more precise, but the excellent service more than made up for it. The staff is consistently attentive, making the whole experience feel seamless. I’ll definitely be dreaming of that crispy crust until my next visit!
… moreKaycee DiPietro
Random stop on our trip to Sleepy Hollow and was not disappointed! The pizza was one of the best we’ve ever had! The garlic knots were AMAZING 10/10! Espresso martini We will always come back when visiting
… moreSusan O
It’s always a great experience at Beekman Ale House—wonderful atmosphere, excellent service, and consistently great food—but they have truly outdone themselves with their Detroit-style pizzas! Perfect in every way: just the right amount of everything, atop the most fabulous crispy crust we’ve ever tasted. We dined in and loved it so much that we brought a couple of pies home to share with the family, and they were a huge hit. I’ll be dreaming about that Detroit-style pizza until I’m back for it again…and again!!!
**Edit-
Detroit-style pizzas are currently only a Tuedsay special- hopefully they make it a staple menu item
… moreCybil Skar
This place gets busy so be prepared for a wait for a table. I sat at the bar and had a beer before our table was ready (about 15 minutes).
The bartender and the server were efficient and pleasant. We ordered the meatballs, wings, and garlic knots. The meatballs and wings were good, the garlic knots were okay.
The vodka burrata pie was a nice refreshing slice. The hot honey pie definitely has some kick, so if your spice tolerance is low or you are prone to heart burn, the mix of tomato sauce and spice from this slice might not be a great idea.
Fantastic beer selection if you like IPAs. Each of us tried something different and we all found something we liked. There are also plenty of non-alcoholic beer selections too, for those that appreciate the flavor, but don’t want ABV.
… moreShruthi Senthilmani
great spot for pizza and beer in sleepy hollow! we tried out this underrated restaurant and honestly it was a great!
the atmosphere was amazing and wasn’t hard to get tables. the pizza was lowkey one of the best i’ve had for such a good price. the have draft beer which paired well with pizza. great for groups and couples for lunch/dinner.
… moreCOLDSEMENOVA
The atmosphere was actually really nice — cozy and welcoming, and the staff were kind and attentive. However, our pizza came out completely cold. The servers offered to take it back or remake it, but that would’ve taken another 30 minutes, which was disappointing. So while I appreciated the people and the vibe, the food itself was honestly cold, crusty, and not enjoyable at all.
… morec v
Who’da thought a tavern would have terrific pizza and lots of great toppings and pizza options! We were pleasantly surprised after hiking to find this gem. Not to mention meeting a like minded couple at the bar and becoming friends!!! The salads, the prices and the portions along with back yard space, this is our new hotspot!
… moreBill Chuck
We took out these three pizzas. I found them each inedible. I’m fine with blackened tuna. I’m fine with blackened salmon. I’m not good with blackened pizza. What a huge disappointment.
… moreJon Shover
Do yourself a favor, and make it a priority to stop in here when in town! Best pizza around with a classic thin crust style and the best Caesar salad you can get anywhere.
… moreKimberlee Febus
Very cozy little bar, and restaurant. Came here on a Monday 12:30 pm before heading back home I seen this place on Instagram and had to stop by. Best choice I made! ☺️ The waitress we had was super amazing. Her name was Cat. and loved her cat tattoo. She recommended the garlic knots and the garlic chicken wings. They were to die for also had cheese and meatball pizza that was delicious as well. Will be definitely stopping by when visiting the area. Thank you for the good experience.
… more