Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1576 State Rte 26, South Otselic, NY 13155
Phone: (315) 653-0021
Website: https://murrayspizzany.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Murray’s Pizza NY
Now Open at 1576 State Highway 26 South Otselic, NY 13155. View our Menu Online! 315.653.0021.
Murray’s Pizza | South Otselic NY – Facebook
Murray’s Pizza , South Otselic. 1395 likes · 174 talking about this · 512 were here. Every day is a great day for pizza and we make great pizza.
Murray’s Pizza NY (@murrayspizzany) · South Otselic, NY – Instagram
552 followers · 1K+ posts · 1576 State Highway 26 South Otselic, NY 13155.
Reviews
John Choo
I still dream about this pizza. It was one of the best I’ve had in ages — thin yet perfectly crunchy, with a savory, toasty crust. The meat was juicy, and the melty cheese exceeded all my expectations for quintessential New York pizza.
But that’s not all. We ordered a variety of dishes, and each one was exceptional. The garlic bread was soft and bursting with flavor, while the chicken crust bread was utterly satisfying with every bite. But the pasta I had was the true masterpiece — hands down, the best I’ve enjoyed in years. It was smoky and savory, with a subtle undertone of heat and sweet, achieving that perfect balance of being both light and rich at the same time. I don’t know how the chef does it.
I honestly didn’t expect to find such a high-caliber pizzeria in this part of New York. Coming from the city, I’m accustomed to a wealth of best dining options, yet this place easily stands shoulder to shoulder with the top-tier pizzerias in the competitive New York market.
I learned that the chef/owner had previously worked in some of the finest restaurants in the city — his story reminded me of “The Bear,” which tells so much about him! This place truly has soul. You can feel the love and care he puts into every dish for every customers, and it’s clear he has a close bond with the locals and the community. You just don’t find places like this anymore.
This town is lucky to have this pizzeria as a local gem!
… moreBut that’s not all. We ordered a variety of dishes, and each one was exceptional. The garlic bread was soft and bursting with flavor, while the chicken crust bread was utterly satisfying with every bite. But the pasta I had was the true masterpiece — hands down, the best I’ve enjoyed in years. It was smoky and savory, with a subtle undertone of heat and sweet, achieving that perfect balance of being both light and rich at the same time. I don’t know how the chef does it.
I honestly didn’t expect to find such a high-caliber pizzeria in this part of New York. Coming from the city, I’m accustomed to a wealth of best dining options, yet this place easily stands shoulder to shoulder with the top-tier pizzerias in the competitive New York market.
I learned that the chef/owner had previously worked in some of the finest restaurants in the city — his story reminded me of “The Bear,” which tells so much about him! This place truly has soul. You can feel the love and care he puts into every dish for every customers, and it’s clear he has a close bond with the locals and the community. You just don’t find places like this anymore.
This town is lucky to have this pizzeria as a local gem!
Matthew D
Best Pizza in the area! I’ve enjoyed the New York Style Crust multiple times; got the Sicilian Style today and it’s amazing. Airy artisanal crust reminiscent of really good ciabatta and high quality toppings. The garlic knots, throat punch wings, and Mango Habanero wings were all excellent as well. Thanks Mario!
… moreVal kenyon
What a great place. Amazing food with unique dishes every day! What a great addition to South Otselic. A beautiful area for a drive if you e never been with great food and drinks. Occasional bands with great music. Wonderful friendly owners.
… moreKimberly Grace
What a find we stumbled upon! We had the riggies pasta with peppers, mushrooms, and onions in a thick, spicy tomato cream sauce. It was downright gourmet! The garlic knots are homemade with fresh garlic. Who would have known a place like this existed in such a rural area. Cool atmosphere, and good music as well!
… moreJohn Weiss
We have been coming to Murray’s for about a year and every time I order I ask if they have dessert, and they say no or not yet today they surprised me with a Brookie, brownie , thank you Murray’s your the Best& put a huge smile on my face
… moreStephanie Tashjian
We ordered a white pie and an order of garlic knots Saturday night. The wait time on the order was super quick (25 minutes) and everything was hot when we arrived. The pizza was delicious and I am excited to try the Sicilian crust next time. As good as the pizza was, the garlic knots were even better. Honestly next time we will be ordering a double order because sharing was difficult. I loved how they were smaller and had some crunch and texture to them. You could actually see and taste the garlic which doesn’t always happen at other places.
Next time we will definitely order in as their beer options look fantastic!
… moreNext time we will definitely order in as their beer options look fantastic!
David Francis
Stopped in after fishing. Enjoyable and then some. I will be back
… moreeli S
The Pizza is delicious which is all I’ve had, but my friends also tried various wings and absolutely love them.
The owner and staff are really nice and they really put in a lot of effort (with great results!) to give it a nice atmosphere.
… moreThe owner and staff are really nice and they really put in a lot of effort (with great results!) to give it a nice atmosphere.
Gina Krumholz
Whenever we’re in town, dinner at Murray’s is a must! We’ve sampled most of the menu and the food never disappoints. Fresh quality ingredients reflect the passion of the owner in delivering an exceptional product. The atmosphere, service and conversations all contribute to having a pleasurable dining experience. Always looking forward to our next visit.
… morecharlie jamieson
Murray’s is a great little secret! Good food, fast and pleasant service, awesome background music while you visit!
… more