todd eichler
UPDATE 1/8/2026 – I’ve ordered a few more times now and the staff and ordering systems seem to be working very well now. Check this place out if you are in the area
I like this place. Good food, hires local kids, but they need to fix their system. This is the second time in a row placing an online order and when I get there in the time window provided the order is not even started. I normally have to tell them exactly what I ordered, they ask me about other orders that are not mine, then they tell me 10 min and take 20 min. I understand staffing shortages are hard, but please, fix your system so it gives accurate pick up times. I would like to actually eat my food on my lunch break and not cold after work.
… moreDavid M. Dwight
Before leaving Oceanport swung by 18 Wolfhill Avenue to see if the rumor about Nicky’s Oceanport Pizza was true.
It was brought to my attention that ownership had changed sometime during the Summer and that Gigi’s of Sea Bright had opened a second store front.
Picked up a plain slice since there was not much of a choice as there was at Federico’s on Main Street for lunch today.
The slice was warm, as can be seen the crust was soggy and had a significant New York Flop.
The taste was average, oily and is what I consider to be a late night game night pizza.
I have been to Gigi’s of Sea Bright and this location needs to step up their game to meet that locations standards.
It’s a sad day since I loved Nicky’s Pizza and will miss them!!!
… moreSheryl
Pizza is to-die for!! Highly recommend for picking up. Only complaint is that delivery always takes triple the time. Every time i’ve ordered delivery it arrives 20-40 minutes AFTER the time told to me- so order accordingly!
… moreTasawar jan
Man. This shop is small but they do something SPECIAL with their pizza. I work in the area and have eaten at many local pizzerias. This place is different. And also a big fan of thin crust style hand stretched.
… moreKatherine Herrick
Moved to the area recently, and tonight is my first time ever getting food at Gigis. Such a cute little spot. Grabbed an eggplant parm pie and believe me when I say it is HANDS DOWN one of the best pies I have EVER had– and I am a pizza snob. I can’t wait to try other things!
… moreVinny Russo
Wow, $30 for half of a pizza. What is wrong with the world today? I wonder how this place has business after what I just received. First, I tried to order buffalo chicken pinwheels and the person taking my order told me not too – they were too busy and the pinwheels were too difficult to so I switched to the Philly cheesesteak. I went to pick up my order where I noticed they were making all half tray pizzas, so I waited patiently for mine to be done and once it was I was told they didn’t make the cheesesteak because they were too overwhelmed. What the actual F. This place should be ashamed of themselves, I will never order from them again and if you have any sense after reading this, you’ll give your money to a more deserving pizzeria.
… moreWill B.
Been here a few times over the last couple months. Last time we ordered the Famous Pepi-Roni and when I got there they had made a regular pepperoni pie (which I’m sure was also delicious). The lady did not hesitate to apologize and begin whipping up the beast that I wanted, despite being right at closing. She tried her best to not charge me the difference between the pies, but she did not win that battle. Take my money. Keep taking my money. And I’ll keep coming back… like I’ll be in the next 35-40 minutes.
… morecraig baker
Excellent food at reasonable prices. Big fan of the Sea Bright location and was very excited to see a new location right down the street.
They have a creative menu with lots of interesting pizza and sandwich options. Definitely worth a try if you stick with their specialties. The general tso and money pie are among our favorites.
Ignore the bad reviews from stuck up crowd that wouldn’t know good food if it sat on their face.
… moreP Newman
Great pizza so why only 1 star? Two of the five people in this tiny take-out were not wearing masks and one was the cashier. The pizza was prepaid using Slice and I included a 20% tip for a total of $38 for one cheese pizza with two toppings. It was so disappointing and unexpected that staff does not respect their customers and enforce that everyone wear a mask. No pizza is worth exposing yourself.
… moreAnna Whetstone
Amazing pizza, got the Billy’s special pizza and grandma pie and both we great. Love the sesame crust! Close to new brewery birdmouth so great to bring with, get delivered, or you or get after a visit there!
… more