Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family-owned and serving Florida’s Treasure Coast since 1996, Goodfellas Pizza is known for handcrafted pizzas, hot wings, subs, fresh salads, and homemade pasta. With nine locations across Port St. Lucie, Jensen Beach, Fort Pierce, Vero Beach, Jupiter, Sebastian and more.We offer fast delivery, takeout, and reliable corporate catering. Whether you’re craving a meatball sub, Caesar salad, or the best pepperoni pizza around, Goodfellas brings bold flavors and quality you can count on.
Casual restaurant offering NY-style pizzas, subs & pastas, with delivery available.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 7550 S US Hwy 1, Port St. Lucie, FL 34952
Phone: (772) 336-1132
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
goodfellaspizza3.hrpos.heartland.us
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Goodfella’s Pizza Pasta Subs | Family Pizza Restaurant near me
Goodfellas Pizza serves fresh pizza, pasta, subs, wings, and family meals across the Treasure Coast Florida. Order online for pickup or delivery from your …
Goodfella’s Pizza – 148 NW California Blvd, Port St Lucie, FL 34986
Homemade Lasagna. Tasty Meat Sauce, layered with Pasta, Romano, Ricotta & Mozzarella Includes fresh Tossed Salad & Homemade Garlic Knots · Homemade Spinach …
Goodfellas Pizza (7550 S US Highway 1) Menu Port Saint Lucie
7550 S Us Highway 1, Port Saint Lucie, FL 34952 · Pizza • Pasta • Desserts • Alcohol … COLD SUBS. HOT SUBS. PASTA DISHES. PASTA DISHES BAKED. ENTREES. DESSERTS …
Reviews
Shawn Dusseault
My wife and I really love this place for its food and people are friendly and seem to be good at what they do. Our problem is now with the prices. Even without delivery fees, ordering a single large pizza was supposedly $18. Perfectly fine with that. Then we added olives, mushrooms, onions, and sausage. Final price… $36! Seriously. Again, this is without the delivery fee. This is just straight up toppings and the pizza. With the delivery fees we were looking at over $50 for a single pizza. Not worth it, Even without the delivery fees. Ended up ordering from Papa John’s and paying half that price with delivery fees included. Personally I prefer Papa John’s pizza over goodfella’s Pizza, but Goodfellas has better appetizers, like the fried ravioli. And my wife prefers Goodfellas. But we both agree that it is absolutely not worth the price anymore.
… moreEric Easterling
Order pizza on a Thursday night and it was about an hour out. Which wasn’t so bad other than they delivered it about 20 minutes after that. When I received said delivery the delivery driver didn’t even take my pizza out of a pizza bag. When I get inside my kids and wife are complaining about the pizza being ice cold, as well as the garlic knots hard as a rock and basically inedible. The pizza edible was after my wife put it in the microwave though. 10 out of 10 will not order from goodfellas ever again and sad part is this was my first time ordering from there and my last time.
… moreCharlotte Vaccaro
Amazing food that was fresh, came out quickly, and great customer service from Anthony! After a bad experience at Jimmy John’s, we decided to come here for subs. Anthony hooked us up with freshly made sandwiches, that not only tasted amazing, but were huge and 100% worth the price. Bread was fresh and super soft. 10/10 recommend! Truly the goodestfellas lol
… moreDon Marie
I’m so upset right now. I waited 30 minutes and paid $40 for a pizza that was NOT mine. I live to far away and thought since I was in the area, we could take home dinner. I absolutely hate HAM and BLACK OLIVES. Take your time and get your customers orders right!!! I don’t appreciate wasting my money at all. I just gave it away. Disgusted smh…
… moreMashell Lewis
I’ve ordered from Good Fellas for quite sometime now…well I ordered in November and had it delivered, it came to me ice cold. I was told that I would get a redo at my convenience and it would be free. So I call tonight, January 20th, get some guy on the phone who tells me he doesn’t see it in the system and I would have to pay half for the pizza. No Sir! This doesn’t sit well with me. No one wants to stand up and take accountability for anything anymore. Time to move on, Goodfellas isn’t that good anymore!
… moreShanon Most
So last night we ordered the Buffalo chicken salad pizza from the Prima Vista store, they were extremely busy about a hour wait. Pizza comes but is not completely right. I called and had such a wonderful experience with the beautifully sweet young lady working the orders over the phone. Not only did they have the correct Pizza the was picture perfect! There was a hand written note on the box! Above and beyond! Good job all the employees! Thank you and this will be our #1 place!
… moreJessicaSomar3
Ordered a delivery order around 3pm. It took over an hour to be delivered. The pizza was cold and gross and the boneless wings were like Styrofoam balls. Absolutely disgusting
… moreErick C
This place charged me twice and both times I tipped thinking there card reader wasn’t working properly I went back and supposedly they didnt find and error even when shown my bank statement. I said screw it ill just avoid this place. A few days later the wife suggest we get food from there and i suggested otherwise. She ordered anyways and tonight we have a whole sub missing from the order. Was told nothing can be done…………
… moreFlorida Driving
Tonight I ordered a large cheese pizza too be well done.
I opened the box it looked delicious the crust was well done as ordered but the cheese was so thin I only tasted it only on a few bites. Was like eating a pizza without any cheese. I often order and get good tasting pizza but tonight must have been an off night. Wasn’t enjoyable
… moreI opened the box it looked delicious the crust was well done as ordered but the cheese was so thin I only tasted it only on a few bites. Was like eating a pizza without any cheese. I often order and get good tasting pizza but tonight must have been an off night. Wasn’t enjoyable
Dawn Pecci
This was mine and my Son Brandon’s first time here. After running errands all day and still having to go to Publix we opted to try this Pizza place for a quick bite since it was in the same plaza as Publix. Wow, what a find! They have a special, 2 – Cheese Slices and a drink for $6.45! So, we asked if 1 of the Slices could be a Meat Slice? And Yes, but for a small up charge which is still an amazing deal! We also decided to order 6 garlic knots for I believe $2.95 and we both agreed that these were some of the BEST garlic knots we’ve ever had! The knots are served with wonderful chunks of real garlic swimming in butter and then a side of red sauce. I didn’t even need or want the sauce because of how good they were all on thier own but my Son said how delicious that was so I gave it a try. You could tell the red sauce was homemade and it had this awesome sweetness to it, I couldn’t decide if I wanted with or without, lol! As we were throughly enjoying our knots out came our slices which were bigger than our heads!! We couldn’t believe the size of these slices and it had that nice thin and crispy crust, with the cheese that was stringy when I tried to cut this enormous slice and the flavor of thier pizza sauce and cheese was truly delicious! Needless to say I couldn’t even finish my slice after eating those 3 delicious garlic knots! Also, that special does come with a fountain drink with unlimited refills (All Pepsi products) my Fav! This unplanned trip to just get a slice of pizza, turned into the best pizza and garlic knots we’ve had in some time!
Now, there are several Goodfella’s locations all around (look at the photos I took to find a location near you) plus, they DELIVER! The delivery area has a mileage restriction! Unfortunately, we are just out of thier delivery area but we will certainly drive there for a carry out!
… moreNow, there are several Goodfella’s locations all around (look at the photos I took to find a location near you) plus, they DELIVER! The delivery area has a mileage restriction! Unfortunately, we are just out of thier delivery area but we will certainly drive there for a carry out!