Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Unassuming local chain eatery serving up thin-crust pizza, plus calzones, subs & salads.
Hours
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1960 S Frontage Rd, Wendell, ID 83355
Phone: (208) 471-5010
Website: https://www.lucysnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria
Give your family the quality time they need and the down time you want. Have a sit down, family style meal at Lucy’s. Here at Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria …
Menu – Lucy’s Pizza
Order Online from Lucy’s NY Pizza. Get the best prices and service when ordering directly … 1960 Frontage Rd, Wendell, ID. Change location. Appetizers. Salads.
Lucy’s New York Style Pizza – Pizza Restaurants in Wendell, Idaho …
Discover Lucys New York Style Pizza at 1960 S Frontage Rd, Wendell, ID! Enjoy delicious thin-crust pizzas, fresh salads, and hearty subs.
Reviews
Lisa G
We don’t often eat in gas station eateries, but we were hungry and there wasn’t much in Wendell. Lucy’s was a pleasant surprise. We really enjoyed the loaded baked potato pizza slices: potatoes, bacon, sour cream, and green onions. I asked about iced tea, and the server warned me it was out of the fountain, not fresh-brewed (thank you), so I got a diet Dr. Pepper with vanilla cream. Tasty and not overly sweet. Their drink menu was bonkers: dozens of options, including huckleberry milkshakes. The decor was cute, for being in a gas station. Will definitely stop here again.
… moreJohn M.
Usually we dont have any issues at any of the Lucy’s locations, especially the Wendell location! This time though when we called to place an order for pickup, the phone was literally answered with a rude sounding “yeah!?” Now I dont know if thats the new greeting for Lucy’s but it sounds very unprofessional to me, definitely not what I’m used to and ive eaten at this location a lot since I live in Gooding. The girls attitude just really sucked all around…this was on 02/28/26 around 445pm. Hopefully next time it will be better.
… moreGoogle User
Can’t believe I payed for this. 18″ peperoni, onions and mushrooms. Where’s the sauce ??? only visible on out side edge. The onions mostly in center of the pizza. Basically just on 3 slices. Mushrooms on the opposite side again basically on 3 slices. First bite long stingy onions no sauce just greasy cheese covered dough. Ever thought of chopping up the veggies? So ya if you want greasy cheesed cover warm dough this is the place for you. I will never be back. Peperoni looked good and service was ok. Hope the tip didn’t go to the cook. My pizza went straight to the trash!
… moreRobert Milburn
I ordered the meatball sub and I had a coupon for a free 12″ pizza. The sub was good but the pizza crust was burnt . Threw away the hole pizza. I’m not one to throw away food, but this was uneditable. Good thing the pizza was free. This was the first time I’ve ordered food from Lucy’s and the last time.
… moreRyan Steel
Let me start off by saying Lucy’s is a refreshing addition to wendell. I love thin crust pizza. This isn’t the best I have had but it isn’t bad for truck stop pizza. The cheese sticks were I thought better than the ccb pizza we ordered. Beware the Fried Motz is a 3/4 in thick by aprox 3 x 4 inches of mozzarella and wasn’t completely melted through.
Ice cream is a little grainy. I am looking forward to trying something else on the menu.
3 stars for food because it wasn’t the best I have had
4 stars foe service because it looks like everyone is new and we’re a little slow.
3 stars for atmosphere because we are in a truck stop / convenience store.
… moreIce cream is a little grainy. I am looking forward to trying something else on the menu.
3 stars for food because it wasn’t the best I have had
4 stars foe service because it looks like everyone is new and we’re a little slow.
3 stars for atmosphere because we are in a truck stop / convenience store.
Tallie Flint
The staff at Lucy’s always comes in clutch when I don’t want to cook! So friendly, always get my order right, and such good NY style pizza. Thanks for dinner, Wendell Lucy’s!
… moreJim Johnson
Whoever is managing this lucys pizza needs to train their employees to communicate and cook better. Toppings are undercooked because they don’t know how to space out the toppings , so its pointless to ask for anything well done cause the crust will burn before the toppings r cooked. I tried the honey garlic sauce, flavor was great but the pizza was drenched with it , toppings were sliding off and made a huge mess. Staff needs to let other staff members know if orders r ready and who the order is for, instead of letting the food sit around.
… moreAngie Bohan
We normally love Lucy’s and the fact that we can get delivery here in Wendell Idaho. We have had great pizzas in the past. Today was different! We had a large order for pickup. When my husband went to get the pizzas he was told that one was burnt but that it would be replaced, which was great! When he got the pizzas home, behold all the pizzas were burnt, a couple partially (we ordered 5) and several at least half the pizzas were burnt. Part of one was charred black. Very disappointing! I should have taken pics!
… moreTyler Rogers
Great pizza place! They also have great salads and subs! Emmie, Morgan, Megan, Maya, & Jennifer are always the best at what they do, great service!
… moreLason Cope
Emmre and Ricardo were great help! The pizza was perfectly. I highly recommend this place.
… more