Social Profile: 
… View more
Coyles Ice Cream has been a beloved fixture in Bay Shore since 1985, offering delicious homemade treats crafted with care and quality ingredients. From classic flavors to innovative creations, we pride ourselves on providing a delightful experience for our customers. Whether you’re craving a cone, a sundae, or one of our famous ice cream cakes, Coyles is the place to satisfy your sweet tooth. With a commitment to community and a passion for flavor, we’re dedicated to spreading joy, one scoop at a time. Come visit us and taste the difference at Coyles Ice Cream!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 75 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone: (631) 666-2229
Website: https://www.coylesicecream.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Coyle’s Ice Cream | Homemade Treats & Community Tradition Since …
Discover the joy of homemade ice cream at Coyle’s, a Bay Shore tradition since 1985. Locally sourced ingredients, family-friendly atmosphere, and timeless …
Coyle’s Ice Cream | Bay Shore NY – Facebook
Coyle’s Ice Cream, Bay Shore. 11517 likes · 58 talking about this · 3708 were here. The best homemade ice cream and cakes since 1985! Sit in one of…
Coyle’s Homemade Ice Cream – Grubhub
Coyle’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu Info. Dessert, · Ice Cream, · Waffles. $$$$$$$. 75 Howells Rd Bay Shore, NY 11706. (631) 666-2229. Check NY Health Score. Hours.
Reviews
Sonia RS
It’s an incredible ice cream place and it left me in awe! With an impressive selection of 60 homemade flavors and a wide range of toppings, it’s a true paradise for ice cream lovers. The friendly atmosphere and the heartwarming display of pictures showcasing happy customers added to the overall charm. I give it a perfect 10/10 for the taste, and I’m already planning my next visit to explore even more delightful flavors. Can’t wait to be back!
… moreKaitlin Zenyuh
Coyle’s of Bayshore always delivers a wonderful ice cream experience. All of the employees are cheerful, helpful, and friendly. Anna, the manager, has created a welcoming and family-feeling environment. To top it all off, all of their ice cream is homemade on premises, and you simply can’t find better. This place is a must-visit for any ice cream fan; my family travels all the way from Huntington for it!!!
… moreFeed My Wife
May very well be my favorite ice cream ever – and I’ve eaten a LOT of ice cream.
The old timey vibe inside the place is so fun.
The ice cream is perfectly creamy, not too sweet. Just right.
If they made their cones in house this place would be off the charts.
… moreThe old timey vibe inside the place is so fun.
The ice cream is perfectly creamy, not too sweet. Just right.
If they made their cones in house this place would be off the charts.
Natalia Salas
Ana at Bay Shore Coyle’s did an amazing job with our birthday cake. She was very thorough and made sure all the details were right and went above and beyond to make us the cake we wanted. Thanks again Ana for all your help and making this birthday memorable.
… moreLauren Neiderfer
Last November you had a blueberry crumble flavor that was amazing . I come back each month to see if it’s back . Please bring this flavor back . It was so good not sure why it never made it to the regular menu .
… moreBethany Dennis
Absolute sweetest staff and best ice cream ever! They always accommodate your needs and simply care for your needs at all costs. I wouldn’t choose any other ice cream shop, they’re delicious and you can taste the freshness in their dessert.
… moreCristian T
I don’t usually leave negative reviews, but my experience at this ice cream shop was disappointing enough to say something. There was a young Spanish girl with glasses working behind the counter who had a really unprofessional attitude. From the moment we walked in, she was dismissive — barely acknowledged us, rolled her eyes, and spoke with a tone that came off as rude, not just to me and my girlfriend, but to other customers too.
Customer service matters, especially in a place that should feel welcoming. Instead, it felt like we were bothering her by simply placing an order. I noticed other people in the shop having similar reactions — it wasn’t just us.
Everyone has bad days, but if you’re working with the public, basic respect goes a long way. Hopefully management addresses this, because the service left a bad taste — and it had nothing to do with the ice cream.
… moreCustomer service matters, especially in a place that should feel welcoming. Instead, it felt like we were bothering her by simply placing an order. I noticed other people in the shop having similar reactions — it wasn’t just us.
Everyone has bad days, but if you’re working with the public, basic respect goes a long way. Hopefully management addresses this, because the service left a bad taste — and it had nothing to do with the ice cream.
Cody Foster
Absolutely the best ice cream I ever had and friendly staff couldn’t speak more highly of this place. Definitely will be back when we return.
… moreTekla Tchelidze
Me & my husband have been coming here for 5 years now, one of the best places to get ice cream, PROMISED.
… moreRaven Smith
I love this place! Homemade ice cream. Many amazing flavors to choose from. They have soft served ice cream as well. There are weekly specials for different days of the week like; discounted root beer floats, banana splits, sundaes, I’m not sure which days are which but you can call ahead or there’s a sign up when you go. Service was lovely.
They let you mix and match flavors
They also sell homemade ice cream cakes and ice cream sandwiches which I haven’t gotten to try yet but they look amazing.
… moreThey let you mix and match flavors
They also sell homemade ice cream cakes and ice cream sandwiches which I haven’t gotten to try yet but they look amazing.