Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
New York-style pies with specialty toppings & other Italian bites in a laid-back storefront locale.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Joey Fratello’s Pizzeria – Findlay, OH
Joey Fratello’s Pizzeria uses only the freshest, finest ingredients available to bring you extraordinarily good flavor! New-York Italian Cuisine.
Joey Fratello’s Pizzeria | Findlay OH – Facebook
We live a town over from Joey Fratello’s Pizzeria which is located in Findlay, Ohio. It is hidden just off Main Street. They have some pretty awesome pizza pies …
Menu Joey Fratello’s Pizzeria
Joey Fratello’s Pizzeria menu — appetizers, salads, sandwiches, wraps … Findlay, OH. Home About Menu Contact. Menu. ✕. Home About Menu Contact. 419-427 …
Reviews
Sarah Gilbert
This place never disappoints! Hands down one of my favorite pizza spots in all of NW Ohio. The food is fantastic every single time. I absolutely love the chicken bacon ranch pizza and the asiago chicken pizza, both are packed with amazing flavor, fresh ingredients, and fresh sauce and dough made daily. You can definitely tell they use high-quality ingredients in everything they make. The garlic bread and cheese is also a must-get. Everything comes out fresh, hot, and always delicious.
I also want to recognize the team. Sajan is one of the delivery driver and works incredibly hard. He’s always friendly, professional, and makes sure orders arrive hot and on time. You can tell he truly cares about doing a good job. Dale, who manages the store and also works in the kitchen, does an amazing job keeping everything running smoothly. It’s not easy juggling management and kitchen duties, but he handles it with dedication and strong leadership. The entire staff is friendly, professional, and extremely hardworking, even during busy rushes.
Great food, great service, and a hardworking team. I will always recommend this place!
… moreI also want to recognize the team. Sajan is one of the delivery driver and works incredibly hard. He’s always friendly, professional, and makes sure orders arrive hot and on time. You can tell he truly cares about doing a good job. Dale, who manages the store and also works in the kitchen, does an amazing job keeping everything running smoothly. It’s not easy juggling management and kitchen duties, but he handles it with dedication and strong leadership. The entire staff is friendly, professional, and extremely hardworking, even during busy rushes.
Great food, great service, and a hardworking team. I will always recommend this place!
Mara Villaseca
Joey’s has been a staple for us now since boyfriend moved to Findlay. Take out or dine it, we really enjoy the food. The pizzas I believe are the best in town. The dining spot is super casual with towers of pizza boxes around but I feel that adds to the charm. We like the salads and sides too, but the pizza is it. The dessert fridge hasn’t ever disappointed either.
Come here if you’re looking for a quiet casual dining experience.
… moreCome here if you’re looking for a quiet casual dining experience.
Kimberly Nieset
The staff and delivery person were amazing. They were super busy on New Years Eve and still had service with a smile. Pizza was AMAZING! I wish they would have had a crustless pizza, but the salad O got is so big it will take me days to eat. Highly Recommend and Appreciate their wonderful efforts to helps us have a great night.
… moreLuke Dice
I have been here twice, both exactly a year apart. The first time I went I was not too impressed both with the atmosphere, taste, and service. The second time I went, my mind was completely changed.
Our server was kind, attentive, and ready to help wherever she could.
The food was pretty good. Pizza is hard to review because everyone has a personal preference, but overall it’s not a bad pie if you add pepperoni. I did not enjoy the plain pie. Surprisingly the calzone was the star of the show. I would have a slice or two of that again.
Main reasons for the lack of 5 stars are the atmosphere (things are a little run down), the lack of pizza holders so you don’t have too much room, the cold red sauce, and the overall taste. Would recommend anything other than the cheese pizza.
… moreOur server was kind, attentive, and ready to help wherever she could.
The food was pretty good. Pizza is hard to review because everyone has a personal preference, but overall it’s not a bad pie if you add pepperoni. I did not enjoy the plain pie. Surprisingly the calzone was the star of the show. I would have a slice or two of that again.
Main reasons for the lack of 5 stars are the atmosphere (things are a little run down), the lack of pizza holders so you don’t have too much room, the cold red sauce, and the overall taste. Would recommend anything other than the cheese pizza.
Lisa I. S. A.
Pizza is pizza but Joey’s sauce is the real winner. It has a bit of sweetness to it. Ingredients are a decent quality and a step up from a chain. As you walk in there is a cooler to grab drinks and dessert.
It’s a great local spot to gather but keep in mind it isn’t a huge restaurant so be ready for your pizza to come out hot! Sandwich was pretty good but not the highlight of the meal.
… moreIt’s a great local spot to gather but keep in mind it isn’t a huge restaurant so be ready for your pizza to come out hot! Sandwich was pretty good but not the highlight of the meal.
Cynthia Thomasson
Great pizza and wings! Friendly service and nice atmosphere.
… moreAaron Crego
The Roasted Garlic pizza is…not good at all. It was bland. The only flavor on the pizza was the red onion. There was no garlic flavor and I’m not even sure if there was a sauce on it at all. The cheese was also bland and flavorless. Will not be getting this again. I’d recommend skipping it.
… moreEllie P.
Delicious option for lunch or dinner on the road. I called to order when we were ab 25min away and when I arrived everything was ready, warm and tasting amazing. I loved that you can customize your calzone. Friendly and helpful staff as well.
… moreTedintheShed
Great pies! Wife says best pizza place she’s had in a very.long time. Her.new favorite spot!
… moreMarnie Carpenter
In town visiting family found this place on Google. The pizza was very good. Better than the other pizza restaurants in Findlay. The prices on Google are much lower than the actual price. Person working there said the prices on Facebook were correct. Will definitely be back when I’m in town again.
… more