Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 340 Mt Vernon Rd, Newark, OH 43055
Phone: (740) 344-0368
Website: https://slicelife.com/restaurants/oh/newark/43055/alley-cat-subs-pizza/menu
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Alley Cat Subs & Pizza – Newark, OH – 340 Mt Vernon Rd – Hours …
Order Hours About. 3:00 PM-9:30 PM; Shop address is 340 Mt Vernon Rd, Newark, OH 43055340 Mt Vernon Rd, Newark, OH 43055; (740) 344-0368.
Alley Cat Subs & Pizza – 340 Mt Vernon Rd, Newark, OH 43055 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Newark, OH! Alley Cat Subs & Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Alley Cat Subs & Pizza | Newark OH – Facebook
Alley Cat Subs & Pizza, Newark. 435 likes · 3 were here. Alley Cat Subs & Pizza located in the heart of Newark is a neighborhood favorite.
Reviews
Jeanna Cochran
I ordered a 16 inch pepperoni pizza and a 1/2 Italian sub, it was not only delicious but under $20. Very thin crust if that’s your thing. The pizza reminds me of the cartoon pizzas with the cheese pull. 10/10, will definitely be a regular customer.
… moreJennifer Bourne
This pizza is delicious. My boyfriend and I have ordered from here almost every week since we found out about it.
Not only is the pizza good, but I’m a sucker for cats and puns so the cat named pizzas like Tom Cat, Fat Cat, and Cat Tails just gives me a good chuckle every time I read the menu.
I’d also like to say the owner is awesome. He’s been the one that hands us our pizzas when we go pick them up. He’s been very accommodating with requests for little changes to our pizzas and has even told us about some new toppings and crust types he’s been thinking of adding to the menu.
Looking forward to hopefully seeing a Spicy Cat (hot honey) on the menu some time. It’s one of the topping choices that was brought up as a future possibility. I’d try a Spicy Tom Cat for sure!
… moreNot only is the pizza good, but I’m a sucker for cats and puns so the cat named pizzas like Tom Cat, Fat Cat, and Cat Tails just gives me a good chuckle every time I read the menu.
I’d also like to say the owner is awesome. He’s been the one that hands us our pizzas when we go pick them up. He’s been very accommodating with requests for little changes to our pizzas and has even told us about some new toppings and crust types he’s been thinking of adding to the menu.
Looking forward to hopefully seeing a Spicy Cat (hot honey) on the menu some time. It’s one of the topping choices that was brought up as a future possibility. I’d try a Spicy Tom Cat for sure!
Taylor-Mae Evans
My experience here was amazing. We had just moved into town and I was trying to find a good pizza! We walked in and before we even ordered, he offered if we just wanted a slice to try it. So thoughtful. It was amazing. We got a pepperoni pizza and he made it so fast. Really genuine guy working & kind. Gotten take out a few times from here since and always really good
… moreDesiree Vaitkunas
We ordered on New Year’s Eve and doordash failed. The owner felt so bad and was so proud of his food. We went down and picked up our order. Amazing food. The pizza was great and the steak sub was perfect. Very friendly. Prompt. Great food
… moreEric Peacock
I hadn’t tried this place before but got a large pepperoni and ham tonight, and this is a phenomenal pizza. The sauce is great, the toppings were plentiful and the crust was thin and crispy, which is my favorite. The owner chatted with me for a few minutes and he also made me feel very welcome and appreciative of my patronage. I will absolutely be getting this again, and soon.
… moreMichelle Wood
Pizza is delicious! It was prepared fast and the price is so good for what you get. Service was great too…. I’ll definitely be back
… moreMitzi Thompson
I have to say they did call to check that I picked what I wanted. I realize they also use a third party delivery but when they delivered our order they sat it on the steps and walked off. No doorbell no knock and yes a $5.00 tip was included in the price. Might have to rethink but the food was good.
… moreBrent Kyler
This pizza was delicious. Hot, fresh, ready with a quickness. Thin crispy crust. Fresh cut veggies. Will 10/10 recommend to others.
… moreTy scott
Great pizza spot , made with passion and by far the best value in the area hands down !
… moreBlake
It’s very underrated and deserves more attention I may be 13 but this is very good pizza employees are nice and kind
… more