Calixto Guzman
**Under New Management**
I recently visited Nonna’s Pizza and had a great experience. The new owner Bob was very friendly and truly appreciated our visit. He took the time to talk with us about the business and his past experience, and it is clear he cares about bringing this place back to life. If you stopped coming because of previous ownership, it is definitely worth giving it another chance.
The pizza was excellent. It reminded me of the pizza I had growing up. The cheese tasted fresh and real, the crust was cooked perfectly and not too thick, and the sauce was balanced and flavorful. It was not greasy at all. I haven’t had pizza this good in a long time.
The wings were also delicious, especially the Garlic and Hot Honey flavors. I am from Connecticut so I won’t be able to visit often, but I will absolutely stop in again whenever I am in the area. Highly recommend this place for great pizza! I rate it 5 slices out of 5.
… more215 Dave
Sam makes the best pizza great slice I love coming here on my break!!! Crust was perfect and cooked great!!
… moreDavid Faust
So glad we stopped for lunch yesterday. The pizza and sandwiches were excellent. Great service, food came out quick. Met the new owners, very nice people. Looking forward to trying some of their new dishes.
… moreTom Brown
We got the $5.99. Which was two slices and a can soda. The cheese was melt and stingy as it should be. Sauce was not too sweet and not cheap or watery. Dough was born soft and crunchy. I would highly recommend for a quick bite or take out a while pie.
… moreJoanna Janiszewski
On vacation and decided to try some of Nonna’s pizza! I must say it was delicious. I had the spinach pizza and the cheese pizza. Flavor was delicious and crust was perfect! I loved it so much I got a 3rd slice. Service was welcoming and kind. Plenty of seating and very clean. Will be our new go to spot when we are in Cap May.
… moreTatiana arana
Well, when you order half broccoli, you expect to get more brocolli than shown in the picture. Pretty disappointed since this USED to be my favorite pizza spot. The crust is good and fluffy, but come on…more broccoli!
… moreJohn Sallade
Loud owner of the place sat and did business while we were eating. Even kept his phone on speaker. Cheeseburger was OK, fries good. Came with the world’s tiniest soda cup.
… moreEd Bier
My wife and I just happened to see this place while in the shopping center & decided to try it out. It is under new management as of this month & they are great! We had a chicken steak & a pizza steak hoagie. They were both great! Pizza steak was the best we’ve ever had. Definitely recommend & will be coming back when in town!
… moreQuinn Maguire
I eat here all the time on my lunch. The pizza is amazing. I always get the two slices and a soda special. It’s a great place if you want a quick meal.
… moreSarit Higgins
Super disappointed I have been wanting to try this place for some time. Pizza had barely any sauce and definitely different than what they had on display. The pizza came out flimsy and not as hot as I like my pizza to be. I felt like I just had a bunch of dough.
… more