Experience the irresistible taste of authentic wood-fired pizza expertly crafted in Plainfield, Illinois. At Big Pauly’s, we use only the finest ingredients to ensure every bite is perfect. From our classic Old World Margherita to our meat lover’s favorite, The Butcher, and the adventurous Pizza Alla Vodka, there’s a pizza for every taste. Our menu also features delicious appetizers, fresh salads, pastas, and mouthwatering desserts to complete your meal. More than just a pizzeria, Big Pauly’s is a place where friends and family gather to enjoy great food, laughter, and memories. Whether dining in, taking out, or using our catering services, expect a warm welcome and food that will keep you coming back.
Elayna Hixon
We were incredibly pleased with our experience at Big Pauly’s. We were greeted by a lovely girl up front, and taken to our seats. The food came out pretty fast and wow, was it amazing! I’m not joking, these were the BEST garlic knots I’ve ever had in my life. My husband agreed! Make sure to get their Alfredo sauce added to dip. The white hot honey pizza was also delicious. The crust was phenomenal. Our waitress Leah was wonderful and very helpful! The girls that work there just have the best energy! Absolutely recommend and will be coming back. 10/10!!!
… moreGina Battista
We tried for the first time tonight after having a very soft, delicious pizza with fresh mozzarella at Tampa airport last week. My SO recently had serious oral surgery and we were looking for something soft and delicious. We ordered hot honey pizza and the garlic knots. I requested the knots be made not so crispy due to a soft food diet, and they delivered. They were so, so soft and delicious! So thank you, Big Pauly’s, for allowing my man to be able to eat FOOD!!!! We will definitely be ordering again. The ricotta on the pizza was chef’s kiss.
… moreRyan Fitzgerald
I recently got a chance to try Big Pauly’s Wood Fired Pizza on a recent visit to Plainfield. From ordering, all the way to pick-up, service was extraordinary. It’s very rare to see this level of accommodation at any restaurant, let alone a pizza restaurant. The staff were great, very friendly, helpful and interactive. I ordered a “Butcher” pizza, essentially a meat lovers. Prices were a little on the high side compared to some other similar wood fired pizza places in the area, but I am always willing to pay more if the quality is there. The toppings were a generous amount and tasted fresh. The cheese was a good amount and had a good melt, you can tell when a low moisture mozza is used. The sauce was a good amount, yet I found it to be very tart, almost sour. May have been an off day or maybe just a personal taste. The crust was dynamite, well flavoured, yet simple and cooked nicely. It had an airy, yet chewy taste, very nice. Overall, very well made pizza and incredible staff. Definitely worthwhile you check out Big Pauly’s if you are in the area or are craving a great pizza.
… moreMike Ackerman
I have been coming here for years. I was happy when I found a local wood fired pizza place and they have not disappointed. Everyone here is friendly, they remember you, they are attentive and passionate about their craft. They have special events for holidays like father’s day and easter. They have special pizzas they only release on a limited time basis. They have a good beer and wine selections. Here is a montage of the many pizzas I’ve devoted my stomach to over the years!
… moresteve nelson
Owners were super nice, I just wanted a small pizza to try so they let me order the 8″ off the kids menu. Pizza was very good especially the crust. And to my surprise they had beer and wine too! Can’t wait to come back and order a big boy pizza.
… moreJeanine
What a gem to find. The staff is really helpful and friendly, which speaks volumes in todays industry standards. The garlic knots were recommended to us, and they are SO delicious & sauce tasted homemade. The pizza we chose had mushrooms, onion, green pepper and sausage and it was cooked to perfection. What I liked about the pizza the most is that it wasn’t too heavy. I left the restaurant feeling good, not weighed down and bloated. We will most certainly be back.
… moreSara Latta-Young
✨ This Week’s Slice of Heaven ✨
At Big Pauly’s, every pizza starts with the freshest foundation: dough made fresh daily. But it doesn’t stop there; they hand-grind whole tomatoes and blend in fresh herbs and spices to create an all-natural sauce that’s become a town favorite.
Dive into their classic pizza flavors or explore unique creations like BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, and “The Great White.” Each pizza is a masterpiece, bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection in their wood-fired oven.
Not in the pizza mood? No worries! Big Pauly’s offers a tempting selection of appetizers, salads, and pasta salads that are sure to satisfy.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, a visit to Big Pauly’s is a must. It’s more than just pizza; it’s an experience – one that brings our community together, one slice at a time.
… moregeorge moder
Love the wood fired pizza. This was so much better than the standard cooked pizza. Service was quick and very friendly. I would definitely recommend that you give this place a try.
… moreNMK
Really good, but small place. My wife and I went for the 1st time recently. The inside is pretty small and was jam packed. Luckily it was nice out and there was a table available out front. We started with some BBQ wings that were delicious. Next we shared a pizza that had a great wood smoked flavor. You can customize your own pizza from the typical list of toppings or try one of their specialty pies. They offer some beer and wine as well. The menu options are fairly limited, but we were very satisfied with everything that we atedrank. We will definitely visit again.
… moreGloria “Gigi” Mendez
We totally enjoyed our food and service. We order the garlic knots. OMG, they were the best garlic knots we ever had! Mac and cheese was cooked perfectly, adding some alfredo sauce and took it to another level. The Butchers pizza was a tad salty, but it was full of flavor and the sauce was great. The cinque formaggio was delicious . Be prepared to spend some $$, but it is worth it. Come and try this place, at least just for the garlic knots!
… more