Amaya
Enjoyed my first time at L’incontro! Loved how crispy the calamari n veg appetizer came out. The cucumber salad did not have a noticeable flavor but was crispy with fresh ingredients. The crab pasta had a bit more kick than I expected but I loved the noodle shape/texture & first time I’ve had crab in pasta which I enjoyed.
… moreRachel B
Delicious food and wonderful service! We had the burrata & prosciutto crudo, as well as the calamari fritti to start. My husband and I raved over the cacio e pepe and ended our meal with the torta cioccolato. This is a perfect spot for a date night or dinner with the family. We cannot wait to return!
… moreJacob R
An absolute must! Food was nothing short of divine. The Vodka Sauce was a delightful blend of sweet & heat with the pasta cooked perfectly al dente.
The focaccia was baked fresh & served hot with oil.
The wine was freshly corked, I recommend the Chianti.
We were able to eat the bar and had the place to ourselves.
Our bartender & and server, Michael, absolutely crushed it! Polite & interesting conversation with lots of laughs.
I will definitely return and highly recommend it.
… moreNolan
This past Friday my girlfriend and I went to L’incontro for a dinner date. Everything on the menu looked delicious it was hard to narrow down our order and it was impossible not to order too much food. The meatball appetizer was delicious. The Cacio e pepe and chicken parm were also standouts. The pepperoni pizza was the best pizza we’ve had in a long time. The crust is light, but crispy, sauce was delicious, and the pepperoni, peppers, and honey are the perfect combination of sweet and spice. We finished our meal off with a piece of cheesecake and to no surprise based off of how everything else was, it was phenomenal.
… moreJessica Zarnowski
Eating at L’incontro was such a great experience. The atmosphere and ambience is perfect for dinner (great playlist!) and the staff is very friendly. We tried a bunch of dishes and they were all excellent! The lamb shank and black sesame pasta were so delicious and freshly made. I’m particular about espresso martinis and theirs did not disappoint. One appetizer really stood out to us and that was the seafood rangoons. Delicious! Highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a date night, family dinner, or just fantastic Italian cuisine. Can’t wait to see how the menu changes seasonally!
… moreGarrett Yim
Went for the Filipino pop-up but ordered some Italian fare such as the calamari fritter. Overall food was delicious. The Lechon Kawali and the Ube Tiramisu were standouts. Would definitely come again.
… moreEric C
L’incontro was a refreshing change of pace to modern Italian. Rotating menu featured great dishes like Kimchi Arancini and Sunday Sauce pasta. Welcoming atmosphere with great drinks as well (Espresso Martini on tap)!
… morejami leach
Such a cool, new spot! I’ve had multiple dishes here and loved them all. You really cannot go wrong with homemade pasta. One of my most recent favorites that I’ve tried is the spicy crab pasta(pictured). The service is attentive, cocktails are well curated, and the ambience is super cute. It’s a great date night spot. I’d recommend getting there early and grabbing a beer at their next door spot, Izzy Hops!
… morePeyton
Phenomenal new restaurant in Milwaukee! I got the Sunday Sauce which was an amazing bolognese sauce. Meatballs were the best as an app! Had to start off with an Espresso Martini which didn’t disappoint followed by a classic Aperol Spritz. Also, the real plants decorating the restaurant are a nice touch along with the eclectic artwork. Will definitely be back!
… moreRachel Stochelski
We had such a great dining experience at L’incontro! We tried a little bit of everything, from the meatball appetizer to the Cacio e Pepe and pepperoni pizza, and all the food was absolutely delicious – chef’s kiss! Also loved the aesthetic of the restaurant itself. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a cute new place in Milwaukee to go on date night, or just hang out with some friends!
… more