Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Thin-crust pizza, pasta & Italian mains, plus a lunch buffet, in a casual setting with a fireplace.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 16201 W National Ave, New Berlin, WI 53151
Phone: (262) 786-6699
Website: http://armelisrestaurant.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Armeli’s Restaurant & Pizzeria – New Berlin
We serve traditional Italian-American and Italian dishes with an Armeli touch, along with our famous pizza, crowd-pleasing favorites, and Wisconsin staples.
Armeli’s Restaurant & Pizzeria | New Berlin WI – Facebook
16201 W National Ave, New Berlin, WI, United States, 53151. Links. . armelisrestaurant.com. Contact info. . (262) 786-6699. . [email protected] …
Order Armeli’s Restaurant & Pizzeria- | New Berlin – – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Armeli’s Restaurant & Pizzeria- at 16201 West National Avenue in New Berlin. Order online and track your order live.
Reviews
Laurie Youknowwho
My husband and I decided to dine hear after looking at the reviews. Unfortunately, they missed the mark.
We ordered the homemade wonton Mozarella Sticks and a large Armeli’s Deluxe. The Mozarella Sticks were sub-par, the pizza was acceptable. Make sure you read the fine print regarding cost if interested in additional toppings.
What made our meal less than was the service. We sat quietly for awhile and waited awhile for water, which is an indication of how the service will go. Our waitress was inattentive. My husband went without water for quite some time. We were promised a pitcher which never arrived. She was carrying out waters for other dinners and brought us one of theirs instead. Although the restaurant was not busy, our food took quite some time. The appetizer arrived and was suffice. We then waited another fifteen plus minutes for our pizza. Normally I wait yet decided to ask how much longer it would be. By the time our pizza arrived the mozza sticks had settled which meant we took at least 75% of the remainder home. Had the older waitress served us, we would have been so much happier. She was consistently stopping at all of her tables checking on her patrons.
When we parted, the host asked how the meal was to which I replied “slow” and decided to forgo leaving a tip. I believe a tip is earned, not a right. I hope they use this review as an avenue to train employees who can learn from the seasoned wait staff.
… moreWe ordered the homemade wonton Mozarella Sticks and a large Armeli’s Deluxe. The Mozarella Sticks were sub-par, the pizza was acceptable. Make sure you read the fine print regarding cost if interested in additional toppings.
What made our meal less than was the service. We sat quietly for awhile and waited awhile for water, which is an indication of how the service will go. Our waitress was inattentive. My husband went without water for quite some time. We were promised a pitcher which never arrived. She was carrying out waters for other dinners and brought us one of theirs instead. Although the restaurant was not busy, our food took quite some time. The appetizer arrived and was suffice. We then waited another fifteen plus minutes for our pizza. Normally I wait yet decided to ask how much longer it would be. By the time our pizza arrived the mozza sticks had settled which meant we took at least 75% of the remainder home. Had the older waitress served us, we would have been so much happier. She was consistently stopping at all of her tables checking on her patrons.
When we parted, the host asked how the meal was to which I replied “slow” and decided to forgo leaving a tip. I believe a tip is earned, not a right. I hope they use this review as an avenue to train employees who can learn from the seasoned wait staff.
Will
Two orders of Penne Carbonara – $28.95 per dish.
Photo attached so you can judge for yourself if you want to order from here. Food speaks for itself better than any worded review.
… morePhoto attached so you can judge for yourself if you want to order from here. Food speaks for itself better than any worded review.
Drew Kusick
After reading all the reviews Tony, maybe you should consider making some changes, like pricing,cooks,whatever you may need to do to change people’s reviews about this place, pepinos was good but after that? Wow, the prices seem sky high for the food that I see here. Change is needed here and there tony,just saying,return the buffet and lower your prices and maybe things will improve,just saying.
… moreLarry Kopperud
We got together with a few family members, some from out of town. Some had been here before and highly recommended it.
We got three pizzas, one house special, one vegetarian, and one custom Mozzarella, Artichoke Hearts, Sun Dried Tomatoes & Roasted Red Pepper and feta cheese. I was surprised when the latter didn’t have a red sauce.
Everyone liked their pizzas, but I was disappointed with the custom. It was dry and I longed for a sauce base. The artichokes were a bit skimpy and dried out. It wasn’t a bust, but I don’t think it lived up to the rest of the family’s view of the restaurant.
Sorry no pictures.
… moreWe got three pizzas, one house special, one vegetarian, and one custom Mozzarella, Artichoke Hearts, Sun Dried Tomatoes & Roasted Red Pepper and feta cheese. I was surprised when the latter didn’t have a red sauce.
Everyone liked their pizzas, but I was disappointed with the custom. It was dry and I longed for a sauce base. The artichokes were a bit skimpy and dried out. It wasn’t a bust, but I don’t think it lived up to the rest of the family’s view of the restaurant.
Sorry no pictures.
Nathania Massie
We dined in-great food, great service. We had the gluten free chicken marsala, gluten free penne with marinara and combo plate and meatballs. (See pics) Updated interior with a cozy feel. The dining area has a fireplace in it-super cute! Outdoor seating available, nice bar and counter height tables. Entrance is wheelchair friendly. Would definitely recommend. BONUS: They have gluten-free pizza and also gluten free dinner options.
… moreJustin Rebro
I had an order at Armeli’s for pick up. They made an error with my pizza and I had to get to my party and did not have time. They resolved the situation by going above and beyond, and delivering an extra pizza to my party that was meant to be on my order. This was fantastic service and remedied the situation. Extra bonus, the pizza is unbelievable. I will return again because of their exceptional ability to adjust on the fly and take care of me, the awesome quality of food. Thankyou
… moreBekah Lyon
This is a quiet Italian place right on national avenue in New Berlin. They remodeled at some point in the last few years so it’s a nicer vibe on the inside for sure. Very cute silverware chandelier in the front entryway! On this trip my husband got his own pizza so he had leftovers for lunches…he liked the pizza. It wasn’t like the best he’s ever had, but it was good! I’m on keto to lose more than a few unwanted pounds so I bypassed the pizza and went with their blackened cod. Yes…it was $17. But it was SOOO GOOD. They give you two roughly 5 oz chunks of cod, so I was able to eat the one and take the other home. Even the next day reheating it in the microwave for a minute was all it needed and it was just as good day2. It’s a quiet place, has a small bar attached you can drink in while you wait and you get bread and butter at the table.
… moreGreg Mehlberg
Ordered a 3 Topping Pizza and Fettuccine Alfredo. Service was excellent. Light music playing in background. Very Relaxing. I am so full. Excellent Food. Will come back here if we can. Wait staff very outgoing and friendly.
… moreMary R
First time customers. Excellent service, very friendly! Excellent pizza!! Will definitely be back!
… moreclaire grandkoski
Mushrooms weren’t good. Pizza was dry, brittle, and thin. Our waitress, Laurie, was wonderful and is extremely kind
… more