Falls Firehouse Pizza

by

  4.5 – 560 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

Offbeat, casual mainstay in a historic building with pizza, sandwiches & desserts, plus wine & beer.

✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery Falls Firehouse Pizza 53085

Menu Photos

firehouse-pizza.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Firehouse Pizza | Sheboygan Falls Restaruant | Dining Near Me

acebookFacebook. Phone: (920) 467-8333 109 Maple St, Sheboygan Falls, WI 53085. Hours: Sun, Wed, Thu 4p-8p. Fri 11a-1:15p; 4p-9p. Sat 4p-9p.

Falls Firehouse Pizza | Sheboygan Falls WI – Facebook

⏰ Weds/Th/Sat: 4:00-8:00 ⏰ Friday/Sat: 4:00-9:00 Call ☎️ 920-467-8333 after 3:30 to place an order or to make a reservation! ———————— December Pizza of the …

Menu – Firehouse Pizza

Menu. View Our Menu Below, Contact us (920) 467-8333 For Orders. Downloadable PDF Menu. Address. 109 Maple St, Sheboygan Falls, WI 53085. Phone.

Reviews

George Red
Up front I was skeptical. Can a Chicago guy get what he is used to? Left incredibly impressed. Ordered hot Hawaiian and build your own large 4 cheese with double pepperoni extra thin crispy with jalapeño. Amanda was our server and was excellent and has a very jovial fun personality. This is now our GO TO!
… more
Where’s The Foul
I read the reviews about the pizza and decided to try it. I am a pizza connoisseur …. this was the lowest grade, from any pizza parlor, I’ve ever had. Our entire family felt like this was cheap frozen pizza. DiGiorno, Tony’s, and Red Baron have better quality.
The food was just edible. I’m sure service and atmosphere is wonderful but pizza is not even mid for the price. If you’re looking for great pizza, this is not it.

Este lugar es muy caro para la calidad. Una pizza conjelada tiene mas sabor y cuesta menos. Tengo mucha experiencia probando varias lugares y este fue lo peor.
… more
Jeanette Wiskow
We were visiting from out of town so it was our first time here. We had a group of 10, (5 adults, 5 children, ages 1 1/2 to 11)so we made a reservation to ensure we didn’t have to wait long. The waitress was good about getting our drink orders first and then our dinner choices. We ordered several different kinds of pizzas and a spaghetti for the 4 year old. The waitress then asked if it was a kids spaghetti.( The waitress didn’t bring us or ask us if we wanted a kids menu prior to ordering & we were not aware there was one) thus only 4 stars on service. With 4 small children, that should have been brought right away. The pizzas were all delicious with a nice thin crust, however the crust could have been a bit more crispy. ( It was drooping when picked up) The spaghetti was good as the 4yr old finished it all. We also had cheese bread- very good, and an order of popcorn chicken that was just average. ( tasted like frozen breaded chicken nuggets, only 1/4 the size) All in all, we would eat there again for pizza and would like to try some of the other non-pizza things offered as well.( was so hungry I forgot to take pictures, oops!)
… more
Dena’ Langdon
Ordered specialty pizza hardly any mushrooms on it. The wait was over 30 minutes with no check in on how we were doing or if we needing anything and at check out we waited drop off the cash, no thank you or acknowledgement. The girl was more interested in chatting to her friends. I will never go back, one and done.
… more
George Cooper
We ordered a medium pizza and the Laguna for dinner..
The Pizza was very good like people had said but the Laguna that wasn’t the case at all..
I don’t recommend the Laguna it was a total disappointment the portion size and the Quality was both not even close to any Laguna I’ve had ..So take it for what it’s worth..Its a hard No for the Laguna..and that was surprising we had the Spaghetti and meatballs before and that was pretty good, so imagine our surprise on this..very disappointed for the money and flavor, Please do a lot better on this..Thanks for reading this and I’ll let you decide for yourself..
… more
Ann Bitter
We decided to order for delivery from Firehouse Pizza in Sheboygan Falls this week. It had been a couple years since we visited the restaurant or ordered food but we always used to enjoy their food. This experience was different. The supreme pizza we ordered was soggy. And their pizza crust is really thin. I mean like paper thin. We knew it said thin crust on the menu, but I’ve never seen anything like this. I also ordered a taco salad and chose the beef in it. Well, it came with no beef. No meat of any kind in it at all. I’m sure someone made a mistake and neglected to add it, but we ordered delivery so you can’t just send it back. With an $8 tip for the nice delivery kid, we paid $50 for what ended up to be a soggy lackluster pizza, a few heals of hard garlic bread, and a taco salad with no taco meat. We won’t be spending money at this restaurant again.
… more
Kris Johnson
It’s been a while since I’ve been here and it’s good as usual. Had the spaghetti to change it up a bit and it was a good choice. Good meat sauce and meatballs. I’ll be back more often.
… more
Eric Risch
Was looking for a new pizza place because we love pizza! So we thought we’d try something new right? Service was below par. We sat down and got our menus. Waitress came n asked what we wanted to eat. Not hi I’m so n so. Not what would you like to drink. Just “do you know what you want”. Seemed pushy n rushed. Tip did reflect this. We got appetizers and they were delicious! High expectations for food then… very thin. Very very thin. Sausage didn’t taste like sausage. Just Blanned meat. Very little sauce. I personally couldn’t even taste it. I’d go for appetizers and that’s it. First impression is big to me and maybe I’m too picky but definitely not the place to go for me to have good pizza
… more
Linda Ader
Great place for Great pizza! Service was awesome! We’ll be back again and again.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment

© 2026 Marketer • Built with GeneratePress

Privacy Policy

Terms

Contact