Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Ithaca, NY, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Ithaca pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Ithaca or stop by 435 Franklin Street for carryout to order the best pizza in Ithaca, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Hours
| Thursday | 9 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 9 AM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 9 AM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 9 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 9 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 9 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 9 AM–12 AM |
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
435 Franklin Street – Ithaca, NY – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
Order from Papa Johns Franklin Street for the best takeout and food delivery in Ithaca. Order online, visit or call for pizza, wings, sides and more!
papa johns stores in ithaca, ny
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Ithaca, New York to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa John’s Delivery Menu – Ithaca | Order Online
View Papa John’s menu and order online for takeout and fast delivery from Ithaca To Go throughout Ithaca.
Last Updates
Reviews
Jack Allport
Always tastes great for a great deal on Tuesday. But id definitely deal with the call center and call ahead because the wait will be incredible, there’s way too many people for the small restruant to feed quickly. Not really the staffs fault
Most of them are polite despite the business, especially the man who I presume is the owner.
One guy will treat you like cattle though, and it seems he treats his Co workers like that too.
… moreMost of them are polite despite the business, especially the man who I presume is the owner.
One guy will treat you like cattle though, and it seems he treats his Co workers like that too.
Aydin B
Very nice staff and awesome pizza to match it! Everyone was very friendly and a great pizza place to stop by at
… moreАлексей Шевченко
TL;DR: Came for $1 slices on Tuesday, everything went wrong. They lost my first order, then forgot to put two slices in my second order, then I ended up paying $23 for 8 slices of pizza.
Suddenly it became very bad. I’ve ordered here a few times and all was good, but today I made an order, the cashier wrote it down and put the paper right near the desk with my name on it and every position of my order! He asked me to wait for 7 minutes because pepperoni wasn’t ready. I patiently waited for 30 minutes and many people after me made their orders. After half an hour I kindly asked another cashier (the first guy disappeared) where my order was. He told me that he knows nothing about my order, and we tried to find this piece of paper near the desk. Unfortunately, our struggle wasn’t successful, I guess this paper disappeared with the cashier. I ordered again, but different flavours, because their board was full and they weren’t making any new pizzas and were selling only already prepared. Almost immediately I got my new order because all pizza was already cooked. And that was the worst part because it cost me $23 for 8 pieces during $1 slices Tuesday. My bad that I didn’t get the receipt because I trusted them. At home I found out that they gave me only 8 slices when I ordered 10 slices. I’m not sure if they forgot slices or just screwed me over on purpose but it was definitely not the $1 slices Tuesday. The pizza was great though, loved its taste. Will not be returning. Also keep in mind that the place is small, crowded and noisy, almost no seats available
… moreSuddenly it became very bad. I’ve ordered here a few times and all was good, but today I made an order, the cashier wrote it down and put the paper right near the desk with my name on it and every position of my order! He asked me to wait for 7 minutes because pepperoni wasn’t ready. I patiently waited for 30 minutes and many people after me made their orders. After half an hour I kindly asked another cashier (the first guy disappeared) where my order was. He told me that he knows nothing about my order, and we tried to find this piece of paper near the desk. Unfortunately, our struggle wasn’t successful, I guess this paper disappeared with the cashier. I ordered again, but different flavours, because their board was full and they weren’t making any new pizzas and were selling only already prepared. Almost immediately I got my new order because all pizza was already cooked. And that was the worst part because it cost me $23 for 8 pieces during $1 slices Tuesday. My bad that I didn’t get the receipt because I trusted them. At home I found out that they gave me only 8 slices when I ordered 10 slices. I’m not sure if they forgot slices or just screwed me over on purpose but it was definitely not the $1 slices Tuesday. The pizza was great though, loved its taste. Will not be returning. Also keep in mind that the place is small, crowded and noisy, almost no seats available
Tim Fraser
Good pizza; staff works hard, but they have a hard time managing the line during high volume order times. There’s not a good queue, so everyone just mills about right in front. Cashier usually is also making pizza, so it’s hard to flag them down to just pick up your pizza, even if it’s already made and paid for. Kind of stressful as a customer. Too bad, because they make really good pizza!
… moreCecily Cox
Guy canceled my order because he said he did not feel like driving g. This was 11/26 and I asked him why, he proceeded to get a violently rude tone over the phone. When I asked for his name he hung up on me. I like Papa Johns better but Domino’s from now on. They treat their customers with respect. I was told I might get a refund in 48 hours, but no one gave me any more information . I called customer service, the lady was nice but clueless. Will have to probably challenge on my AMEX. Thank goodness AMEX cares about customer service!
… moreJustyn Butler
If I could give zero stars, that would be too many. I placed our order, waited in the lobby of the hotel for 1.5 hrs, and no one showed. I called the store, they said it has been delivered. So obviously they are eating my pizza and enjoying my tip. This is the most ridiculous operation I’ve ever seen. I will never order Papa John’s again. I know it’s just this store that sucks, but corporate needs to do something about this trash
… moreKirstie Readnower
I placed a delivery order at 4:55pm, it’s 7:35pm and I agreed to cancel because the manager said the order had already been sent out, yet I received nothing. Multiple drivers waited for extended periods of time at the store before giving up. At the same time that the manager told me that the order had already been given to a delivery driver, a new driver had accepted the order and was waiting at the store according to the Doordash tracker. The manager said they’re really busy (clearly) and people had called out but at a certain point they should have the discretion to stop accepting orders that they can’t fulfill in a reasonable time.
… morePamela Morris-Parish
Attempted to place an order for delivery at Cornell. The # given apparently does NOT go to the location in Franklin Market in Ithaca. The woman was rude and argued with us about the address we wanted it delivered to and we couldn’t seem to get it through her head it’s a college campus. She just kept saying it doesn’t show up on their list of accepted addresses, despite the fact we’ve had things delivered from them before. The call got dropped (or maybe she just hung up). A call back from us got the exact same results. Argument over the address and call terminated on her end. We will NEVER be ordering from Papa Johns again. – We want to talk to someone AT THE ACTUAL LOCATION where the pizza is being made and delivered from, not some clueless corporate call center.
… moreCameron Manley
This place has started running downhill, I’m not sure who the manager is but poor customer service, as well as when I ordered a Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust pizza and the dough is still raw and not fully cooked, the pizza you pick it up and it just falls apart because their is no bottom crust on the pizza. Just overall ordered 5 times and still isnt getting better. I would highly avoid ordering or placing any deliveries from this Papa John’s. Absolutely disgusting and a waste of money!
… moreTara F
Ordered pizza and 2 hours later the delivery person said that they left it outside my door did not knock or text and now my food is cold and it’s been sitting outside on concrete. I will never order from you again. The last time I ordered it also took two hours and at least that delivery person knocked out my door to deliver the food.
… more