Terry Groth
What an amazing experience with our waiter Lucas! We came with our friends from Buffalo and were not disappointed! This was the best meal we have had since they have been here. This was the 3 course meal special. Salad, Dinner and Dessert! The soup was fabulous and the salad was beautiful and delicious! The dinner was short ribs in a delectable sauce with nice pasta. We couldn’t even eat the whole meal. The cheesecake tops the meal off and was superb. The restaurant was clean and very inviting! Lucas our waiter was an absolute delight! He was there filling waters, describing all the dishes they offer and just pleasant to have as our guide through the meal. We will DEFINITELY be back! Thank you!
… moreJessica Robin
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Pastaio in Palm City delivered an unforgettable meal from start to finish. Every dish felt thoughtfully prepared, beautifully presented, and full of rich, authentic flavor. • Fried Calamari — Light, crisp, and perfectly seasoned. The mix of rings and tentacles had great texture, and both dipping sauces complemented the dish without overpowering it.
• Beef Carpaccio — Silky, paper‑thin slices of beef paired with arugula, shaved Parmigiano, and capers. Bright, delicate, and balanced.
• Spaghetti Carbonara
spaghetti, pancetta, egg yolk, Parmigiano, roasted garlic
A rich, velvety carbonara with incredible depth of flavor. The pancetta added the perfect bite, and the egg yolk brought everything together into a luxurious, glossy sauce.
• Chicken Francese
egg batter, white wine, lemon, butter, herbs
Tender chicken in a silky lemon‑butter sauce with just the right amount of brightness. Comforting, elegant, and beautifully executed.
• Eggplant Stack
panko‑crusted eggplant, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, spinach, pomodoro sauce
A standout twist on a classic. Crisp on the outside, soft inside, layered with fresh mozzarella and vegetables, and finished with a vibrant pomodoro.
• Pepperoni Pizza — Golden crust, melty cheese, and generous pepperoni. Simple, classic, and done exceptionally well.
• Meatballs in Tomato Sauce — Tender, hearty, and served bubbling hot in a cast‑iron skillet. The cheese on top added the perfect finishing touch.
Desserts That Ended the Night Perfectly
• Tartufo — A nostalgic Italian classic done right: rich, cold, chocolatey, and beautifully plated.
• Espresso Toffee Mousse Cake — Light, airy mousse with deep espresso flavor and a hint of toffee sweetness. Elegant, indulgent, and the perfect balance of bitter and sweet
The cocktail was refreshing, bright, and visually stunning—an ideal complement to the richness of the meal. The atmosphere is warm, the ingredients shine, and the kitchen clearly takes pride in every detail. A true gem in Palm City and absolutely worth the visit!
… moreDani Warrington (Dani)
Pastaio was amazing! We came for happy hour on a Saturday night. We had several apps on the happy hour menu which were all phenomenal. The beggar’s purse is a must! The service was also very good and the atmosphere was as well. You can actually hear yourself talk – some places are so loud. If you live in or near Palm City, definitely check this place out!
… moreDebra Buritica
We have not visited this restaurant in some time and so happy I chose this place. We were meeting up with some friends who are not familiar with Palm City. The hostess greeted us with a smile upon our arrival and she was very polished. The Food was so delicious! The Service was AMAZING! Our Server Gigi was extremely attentive and we never had to ask for anything. The atmosphere was great, no loud music in the background so you’re able to actually engage in conversation while dining! What a great dining experience! We will definitely be back soon. I’m so happy I chose Pastaio to bring our friends.
… moreFrancesca Marini Whalen
Great party option!! We had my husband 60th birthday there with over 30 people in a semi private room, they allowed us to decorate ahead of dinner. The manager, Niki is super nice and so helpful. She let us make changes to the menu up until the last day and she never rushed us; she oversaw the event with much care. We had two servers Hudson and Lucas and they were amazing as well as the rest of the staff. The food was fabulous—fresh and tasty. We had calamari, pizza, Salmon, lasagna, chicken francese, Chicken Parmesan, Rigatoni Primavera and all cooked perfectly and beautifully presented. Our family is still raving about it; thank you Pastaio!! We’ve dined there several times before the party and never been disappointed and so I would highly recommend them !!
… moreTom Arato
We had the pleasure of having Jessica as our server and she was just fabulous !! Great hospitality, great recommendations- we chose to purchase a bottle of wine and she suggested a great Appetizer! We have already made 2 recommendations during our vacation. Than you again Jessica sincerely, Laura and Tom Arato
… moreTIKIA81
I have been dying to try this restaurant for a long time. It did not disappoint! The service was amazing and the food was incredible! The garlic bread was the best I’ve ever had. The beggar’s purse was incredible! We also got the pesto pasta and the carbonara and it was amazing! I can’t wait to go back!
… moreDoug Bomeisler
A solid choice for Italian food for our party of four. Staff and atmosphere were top-notch. Overall, the food was very good with the chicken Milanese being the absolute winner. I felt the salmon serving was embarrassingly small, and the kale Caesar while delicious was a bit on the dry side but I realize that is personal taste.
… moreAlex B
This restaraunt feels like a hidden gem, quality food, casual setting but slightly upscale, great place for a family dinner or a date. The bread they serve was absolutely delicious, I went with the mussels they were plump and savory, generous portion for an appetizer. The riggatoni boscaiola was probably one of the best rigatonis Ive had the bits of pancetta were crispy and complimented the dish well. We went with the clam pizza, it tasted very clean not briney at all, I would like to try their other pizzas in the future since all their ingredients seem high quality. Overall a quality restaraunt at a great price. Service was impeccable as well.
… moreSamantha Joan
Incredible! Fresh, expertly crafted dishes. We started with the special of pear and truffle pouches called “beggars purse” and it was divine. I’m always picky about truffle but Pastaio truly knows what they’re doing as it complimented every dish it was in and was not overpowering. The kale ceasar was also a knockout, kale can be tough and too firm but this salad was delicious and gentle. Without having a kids menu they still accomadated my child perfectly with adaptive options. The pasta was nothing short of incredible. My entire party left agreeing to meet once a month. Our service was provided by Chase who was the cherry on top of a fantastic meal. Accommodating, kind, patient while we talked over one another, and we never had empty waters or a dirty table. Will request him next time. Thank you for making the experience incredible!
… more