Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Chain selling crispy pizzas featuring provolone cheese & lots of toppings, plus oven-baked subs.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Donatos Pizza
Order pizza online from Donatos. Fresh ingredients, Edge to Edge® toppings, and family-sized pizzas delivered to your door.
Donatos Pizza Menu
Order pizza online from Donatos. Fresh ingredients, Edge to Edge® toppings, and family-sized pizzas delivered to your door.
Order Donatos Pizza – Columbus, OH Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Donatos Pizza at 3389 Sullivant Avenue in Columbus. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Reviews
SARKTECHNO 237
Donato’s Pizza in Blacklick continues to be one of the most reliable and satisfying pizza spots in the area. As a delivery agent, Every time I walk in or place an order, the staff treats me with genuine friendliness and professionalism, making the whole experience smooth from start to finish. The atmosphere is always clean, calm, and welcoming, which makes waiting for your order or dining in feel comfortable.
What truly stands out is the consistency. The pizzas are always made fresh, with the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The crust has that signature Donato’s crispiness that keeps you coming back. Whether it’s their classic pepperoni, the edge-to-edge toppings, or any of their specialty pizzas, everything tastes flavorful and well-prepared. Their sides, especially the wings and garlic bread, also complement the meal perfectly.
The service is quick, whether you’re ordering in-person, online, or for delivery, and they rarely miss a detail. My orders arrive hot, accurate, and on time. It’s clear that the staff takes pride in customer satisfaction.
Overall, Donato’s Pizza Blacklick delivers great food, great service, and a dependable experience every single visit. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for quality pizza and excellent customer care in the Blacklick area.
… moreWhat truly stands out is the consistency. The pizzas are always made fresh, with the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The crust has that signature Donato’s crispiness that keeps you coming back. Whether it’s their classic pepperoni, the edge-to-edge toppings, or any of their specialty pizzas, everything tastes flavorful and well-prepared. Their sides, especially the wings and garlic bread, also complement the meal perfectly.
The service is quick, whether you’re ordering in-person, online, or for delivery, and they rarely miss a detail. My orders arrive hot, accurate, and on time. It’s clear that the staff takes pride in customer satisfaction.
Overall, Donato’s Pizza Blacklick delivers great food, great service, and a dependable experience every single visit. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for quality pizza and excellent customer care in the Blacklick area.
Zewde Deressa
Amazing pizza! But only 2 workers is crazy, I waited an hour for 2 pizzas. Just an old lady and a young man. I feel bad for them, they need a raise. The old lady is nice, she make it free for me, because I had to wait. If you want to work for donatos, please do! This will improve it way better
… moreTroy Clark
Don’t even try ordering from here. They don’t answer calls, when they finally do they put you on hold until you hang up. I let it sit on hold for an hour. I’ve never dealt with such horrible management. They owe me a credit from last time because I ordered for delivery and 2 hours later it never showed and they wouldn’t t answer. So I drove there and they said they got busy?? Like come on dude, every pizza place gets busy. Why does every other donatos manage to run smooth and answer calls?
… moreKyle Melfi
Always great pizza. Sub was incorrect. Staff needs to find a personality and not just display bitterness towards customers just because they walked in.
… morePaula Carter
One of the biggest pros are that they are usually open late for pick-up or 3rd party delivery. Super convenient for those midnight cravings. And it’s ready pretty quick. Their pizza quality is on trend with all of their other locations, good taste. And their salads are freshly made – I customize, so can confirm. Service is a little meh. How some greet you at the window is a little cold – “name?” All in all, a solid spot.
… moreMary
I will never order from here again. Every time I order at this Donatos, I have a problem!
I ordered online this Saturday and automatically was charged a tip. I went to drive thru to get order and the girl was nice, gave us our subs and no pizza. “Oh sorry, they forgot, it’s in the oven, about 5 minutes more, pull over and we’ll bring it out”. My subs are getting cold.
10 minutes later my pizza is ready, subs cold and I noticed a tip was put on my receipt! Went in to manager and he said he would take the tip off and give me some off my bill, never happened!
Worse Donatos, they can’t get it right!! I hate cold food,
… moreI ordered online this Saturday and automatically was charged a tip. I went to drive thru to get order and the girl was nice, gave us our subs and no pizza. “Oh sorry, they forgot, it’s in the oven, about 5 minutes more, pull over and we’ll bring it out”. My subs are getting cold.
10 minutes later my pizza is ready, subs cold and I noticed a tip was put on my receipt! Went in to manager and he said he would take the tip off and give me some off my bill, never happened!
Worse Donatos, they can’t get it right!! I hate cold food,
Ms. Monica
My order in this visit was for drive-thru pickup.
My order was ready in 20 minutes. Customer service was great and fast. My food was hot. I tried the Hot Honey Pizza and babyyyy, it has a kick but it is really good. If you can’t eat hot or spicy, then this is not for you. I also ordered the traditional pepperoni pizza with light sauce.
I definitely will be getting the hot honey pizza again. I hope it is not only available for a limited time. Everything about this visit was good. I also didn’t have to wait in line.
You can dine in here and there is plenty of parking too.
… moreMy order was ready in 20 minutes. Customer service was great and fast. My food was hot. I tried the Hot Honey Pizza and babyyyy, it has a kick but it is really good. If you can’t eat hot or spicy, then this is not for you. I also ordered the traditional pepperoni pizza with light sauce.
I definitely will be getting the hot honey pizza again. I hope it is not only available for a limited time. Everything about this visit was good. I also didn’t have to wait in line.
You can dine in here and there is plenty of parking too.
Dj Stocker
Ordered a larger extra pepperoni and banana pepper pizza. Only to receive it made completely wrong. Not having extra pepperoni and it being on only half of the pizza. So paying for 2XL and I get 1/2.
When asked if I could bring it back and have it made correctly I was told I was wrong and they made it correctly and then said I’d have to pay for a 2nd. You can see on my order screen that’s clearly not the case. Go somewhere that is more competent and has better customer service.
… moreWhen asked if I could bring it back and have it made correctly I was told I was wrong and they made it correctly and then said I’d have to pay for a 2nd. You can see on my order screen that’s clearly not the case. Go somewhere that is more competent and has better customer service.
d gray
I had delivery tonight. The last time they brought the wrong pizza but apologized and said I’d have a 20$ credit. Tried to use the credit and was told I couldn’t use it for delivery pizza! So, tonight I got pizza and 18 wings. I usually love their dry rub wings. However I don’t know if they changed how they cook them or changed who they get their chicken from but they were awful! They reminded me of grocery store wings I tried once! The wing was covered in what I think was fat just under the skin. I scraped it off 2 of them and just dumped the rest. They were barely brown so maybe they weren’t cooked long enough. I don’t know but they were really bad. They need to go back to the old ways if they’ve changed. Oh, also the pizza sauce was spicy it didn’t taste like it used to and there were 6 pieces of pineapple on the entire pizza! Wow my favorite pizza and wing place is gone!!
… moreAndru Voss
Thank god for donatos !! When we got that craving for pizza at 10pm donatos was the only pizza place open! Even tho they pricey compared to the others they came thru!
… more