Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Long-standing family-owned pizzeria serving brick-oven pizzas & Italian fare in a modest cottage.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 252 Main St, Firthcliffe, NY 12518
Phone: (845) 534-7003
Website: http://www.pizzaofnewyork.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Prima Pizza
We are closed on Monday but we are available to take future orders for any other day. We start shipping Tuesday orders for Wednesday arrival. Prima Pizza- …
Menu – Prima Pizza – Restaurant in Cornwall, NY
Menu for Prima Pizza in Cornwall, NY. Explore latest menu with photos and reviews.
Prima Pizza – Exceptional NY Style Pizza in Cornwall, NY
Discover This Place. At Prima Pizza, nestled on 252 Main St in Firthcliffe, NY, diners are treated to a delightful journey into the world of authentic New …
Reviews
Drew Bear
This place has a charming interior. I ate here close to closing time so the pizza wasn’t super fresh. The Sicilian pizza looked really delicious but unfortunately I didn’t get a bite. The pepperoni had a unique flavor at first but became too much as I kept eating it. Overall it’s decent pizza and worth try if you are visiting Cornwall!
… moreAllen Rodriguez
Prima Pizza on Main Street in Cornwall never disappoints! My regular go-to is the pepperoni with extra cheese, and I love dipping each slice in their marinara—absolutely delicious. The customer service here is top-notch—fast, friendly, and always attentive. The place is constantly buzzing with customers, which tells you it’s the local favorite.
Being right in the heart of town, it’s clear this spot has a loyal following, and for good reason. I tried something different tonight with extra cheese, and it looks amazing. Can’t wait to dig in! Highly recommend Prima Pizza to anyone in the area
… moreBeing right in the heart of town, it’s clear this spot has a loyal following, and for good reason. I tried something different tonight with extra cheese, and it looks amazing. Can’t wait to dig in! Highly recommend Prima Pizza to anyone in the area
THE SHADOW
Had a wonderful time with wifey and our husky. Ordered a Queen Margherita pie and a few cold ones on hot day. Vincent is a very nice waiter and made sure everything was ok. Thank you, we’ll be back.
… moreSketchy Pam
We stopped here for a couple of slices before going to the Stormking Art Center. Thin crust perfection. I had the margarita pizza – an awesome treat. You can get a pizza deliver anywhere by mail too. Go here.
… morewilliam wortmann
Cornwall staple of NY style pizza. I used to go here as a kid with my buddies, get a slice and play video games in the back. They took the games out, but it still has the same feel as back then. We enjoyed the white slice and Margherita, garlic knots and calzone. The place is family owned and very friendly/attentive service. They even deliver nationally, my wife has had it delivered to us in Oklahoma multiple times!
… moreHeather House
Great little place in Cornwall with good pizza and open on Monday! I love the inside decor and how cute it is. There is a great outdoor patio and a few seating options on the sidewalk to people/car watch. I took the recommendation of our server and got the Thursday app special of meatball sliders and the 3 Amigo’s pizza. It was ALL delicious. They were out of the Cab and brought me a Chianti, which wasn’t too shabby. They were able to scrounge up.s9me garlic bread, which I had heard was amazing… it was. Planning to bring the work folks at the end of July here for Monday dinner. Great place to chill and have a little bite.
… moreGeoff Grant
We enjoyed a late lunch in the small but cozy restaurant. The waiter was enthusiastic and proud of their food and provided us with samples of their bread, sauce and plain pizza. Everything was delicious. Creative, soft crust pizzas with unlimited options for toppings. The 12-inch pizza can easily be for two, but we each ordered one and have been enjoying the leftovers. Highly recommend!!
… moreJoe Quartuccio
Love this place! The pizza is delicious; the crust, the sauce… oh my.. outstanding. In town on business. Brought a pie home and had to drive 2 hours with that wonderful aroma. Worth the wait! Spectacular pie. Oh and Maddie behind the counter is so friendly as is everyone! I will be back!!
… moreAsgard Hu
Apparently according to Google I’m a top 10% of restaurant reviewers so I feel obliged to continue to enhance my Google rep by reviewing Prima.
First off my history: I once went to Mario batallis pizza restaurant. I ordered two pizzas and nomnomed on them. I expected fireworks, but my friends it was.. ok.
Why do I bring that up? Because the first time I went to Prima I ordered some kind of chicken Parm pizza slice. When I took a bite of that sweet sweet slice, the fireworks went off. I can literally taste it just typing about it.
I thought maybe it was because I’m from Los Angeles and maybe all New York pizza is just really really good. But then I ate somewhere else and it was “good” not great. Went back to Prima for a three cheese rectangle of heaven. Jesus Christ I love this pizza. It’s actually scary how much I think about it. It’s too dangerous for me to order and bring home.
I love you Prima pizza. You’re so much better than Mario Batallis or whatever.
♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
… moreFirst off my history: I once went to Mario batallis pizza restaurant. I ordered two pizzas and nomnomed on them. I expected fireworks, but my friends it was.. ok.
Why do I bring that up? Because the first time I went to Prima I ordered some kind of chicken Parm pizza slice. When I took a bite of that sweet sweet slice, the fireworks went off. I can literally taste it just typing about it.
I thought maybe it was because I’m from Los Angeles and maybe all New York pizza is just really really good. But then I ate somewhere else and it was “good” not great. Went back to Prima for a three cheese rectangle of heaven. Jesus Christ I love this pizza. It’s actually scary how much I think about it. It’s too dangerous for me to order and bring home.
I love you Prima pizza. You’re so much better than Mario Batallis or whatever.
♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Carly Kaicher
I am so mad that I have lived up here for three years and just now came here. Everyone working there was so friendly, and went above and beyond. It’s super family friendly, and the food was amazing. This will be our only pizza spot going forward. We can’t wait to come back soon. 10/10.
… more