Chris Isaacs
We came in during a visit to Hill City and had a great time. We were given some inaccurate information unfortunately by a third party that arranged our visit and reservation, however the owners were beyond fantastic and handled above anything I would have expected and were a pleasure. We were glad we didn’t let it damper the night because the food was all delicious. We started with steak tips and also tried a steak as well as a burger. Everything was cooked exactly as ordered and the food quality was great. The Mac and cheese was a great surprise as a side and well made. We didn’t have room for dessert but will come hungry next time we are in town. We would absolutely recommend coming in when you’re in the area. Thank you Scott for handling the awkward situation so well with us and going above and beyond anything you needed to do to make the visit memorable. Stop in for a great meal!
… moreShawn Kislenger
The 1885 was a wonderful and surprising find. We stopped in with no expectations and left with one of the best meals in South Dakota. The cocktails are top shelf. The food, exquisite. Service, outstanding. Atmosphere, vintage. Get the ribs, you won’t regret it. We had chicken which was fantastic and ribs, corn, potato salad, old fashioned cocktails. If you’re traveling through the black hills make this the first place you eat and everywhere else will pale by comparison.
… moreMelissa Davis
The service was great, it smells of fresh wood which I loved, was conveniently located. It’s a super easy walk to shopping and the train depot from here. However the food was just okay and I thought overpriced for what we got. The macaroni and cheese was delicious but I had a tummy ache shortly after. Bonus is they have decent sweet ice tea, I drank 3 glasses! This southern girl is always on the hunt for some good tea. I’d give them another chance and just order something different. Id love to check out their dinner sometime as this visit was for lunch.
… moreCharlotte Banyard
Food was delicious, we had Walleye and Ny Strip with green beans, which were both cooked perfectly and the green beans were amazing. service was great. Wish we had room for dessert, maybe next time. Would definitely recommend this to anyone passing through Hill City, or even staying in town. It’s really a great place to have dinner. We did make reservations as it’s the week of Sturgis and didn’t know if it would be too busy.
… moreMatt Davis
A good experience overall. The staff were very friendly and we were sat immediately. The food was on the pricey side but you could taste the quality. The waiter was very attentive and pleasant. I would go back.
… moreKäea B
While we had a little bit of a wait (due to rally season), it was worth it. We did tapas with drinks and had the delicious steak bites, shrimp with the boom sauce (very good and straight for ease of eating), and bread with the rasberry butter. Very enjoyable and neat to find out about this old saloon!
… moreKevin Towe
We stopped by 1885 after riding all day. There was a short wait and we waited in the bar area with some ice cold beer. We were seated a short time later. The waitress was very pleasant and attentive. We started with the deep feied guacamole and jalapeño ranch dipping sauce, incredible! Me and my wife shared a full rack of ribs, loaded baked potato and coleslaw. The food was really good. The only complaint/recommendation that I have is that the ribs need the membrane removed from the backside. Other than this, we had a great experience and enjoyed the food/restaurant. I would recommend it!
… moreJohn Szesnat
Dinner was awesome! Not the best steak I’ve had but really fresh. Really good. But our waitress Katie was amazing. She was all over it. Whatever she needs to do. She did it with a smile.
Would definitely come back
… moreAmanda Blackwell
This place is cool. The decor is rustic. The food was delicious. I had the peach bourbon pork chop, and my husband had the Elk medallions. The bread came with an amazing house made butter. The service was good and our drinks were never empty.
… moreSafira Ramirez
Fenominal. The service was amazing our waiter was so nice like unexplainably amazing. The atmosphere was a warm busy nice feeling with amazing detail in the tables. The food was crazy good. Like 10000000000/10.the ribs were fenominal. This place is definitely one of the best places I’ve ever been to. Our waiter was Shelly. This woman’s needs a raise
… more