Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Contemporary, brick-walled pizzeria serving Neapolitan-style pies, plus beer, wine & gelato.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 799 W Gaines St #101, Tallahassee, FL 32304
Phone: (850) 558-6379
Website: http://isabellaspn.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana – Delicious pizza in Tallahassee
Isabella’s is a cozy place where you can taste the most delicious pizzas. Our menu contains the best products and have a variety of flavors with a distinctive, …
Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana (@isabellaspizza) – Instagram
663 Followers, 155 Following, 22 Posts – Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana (@isabellaspizza) on Instagram: “Serving Tallahassee’s best wood-fired pizza ✨ Be …
Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana | Tallahassee FL – Facebook
Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana, Tallahassee. 2402 likes · 1610 were here. To represent the authentic Neapolitan cuisine, allowing customers to…
Last Updates
Reviews
gordon devoss
Mid experience in general. Went during lunch, only one other patron there.
The dude working was ultra-disenterested and practically silent other than telling me the total.
See pizza pictured. Low effort. Toppings were clumped and not spread. Asked for well done, it was melted cheese with raw veggies….cheese was not toasted, only melted.
Crust was really good and well cooked. Pizza had decent flavor but I didnt like the huge (raw) veggie slices.
Small 10″ veggie + pepperoni, a can of coke, and a bottle of water was $24.50 before tip…..zzzzzzz
Tried it. It was OK, but very lackluster. I felt the product was LOW EFFORT for the cost. I would revisit to give it another chance.
… moreThe dude working was ultra-disenterested and practically silent other than telling me the total.
See pizza pictured. Low effort. Toppings were clumped and not spread. Asked for well done, it was melted cheese with raw veggies….cheese was not toasted, only melted.
Crust was really good and well cooked. Pizza had decent flavor but I didnt like the huge (raw) veggie slices.
Small 10″ veggie + pepperoni, a can of coke, and a bottle of water was $24.50 before tip…..zzzzzzz
Tried it. It was OK, but very lackluster. I felt the product was LOW EFFORT for the cost. I would revisit to give it another chance.
jennifer green
Absolutely not! I just paid $37 for hard cardboard thin flavorless pizza burnt on the bottom and the worst part is they automatically add 15% gratuity! FOR WHAT?! I order at a counter, pay at the counter. nobody served me, checked on me, even the cokes are $3 cans and not refillable. Asked for a cup of water and they don’t even do that they will only sell you a bottle of water. AND your employees are making at least minimum wage so what the hell is this tip for??????
In 2024 the pizza was good like a Napoli pizza.
Now their sign says wood fired and it’s actually neither, it’s the equivalent of those $3 disgusting cardboard frozen pizzas at Walmart. I am appalled by the entire experience. I don’t know if they changed owners, management, need to fire the pizza makers, or just went downhill but I am embarrassed that I ever recommended this place and I will NEVER be back and neither will my kid who is a FSU student. APPALLING
… moreIn 2024 the pizza was good like a Napoli pizza.
Now their sign says wood fired and it’s actually neither, it’s the equivalent of those $3 disgusting cardboard frozen pizzas at Walmart. I am appalled by the entire experience. I don’t know if they changed owners, management, need to fire the pizza makers, or just went downhill but I am embarrassed that I ever recommended this place and I will NEVER be back and neither will my kid who is a FSU student. APPALLING
Dennis Frye
It’s our “go to” pizza place whenever we are in Tallahassee. It’s perfectly located near the stadium and the Madison Social area. The food is PERFECT. The service is PERFECT. It’s highly rated for a reason.
… moreSteve Sanders
Pizza was decently flavorful, with a nice crisp crust that held up the toppings and a generous layer of cheese. They forgot the prosciutto and had to put some slices on top (I don’t know if it normally would have been baked with the pizza). Salad (greens, apple, blue cheese, pecans) also good, but they tried to charge me a dollar more than the menu price because they claimed menus hadn’t been updated. Service fine, food came out quickly. The white wine was warm because their wine fridge wasn’t working.
… moreSexy & Free Spiritualist
I found Isabella’s while in a hungry and horrible mood after ordering food across town and returning it. I just need to set this review up in total honesty to paint a clear picture. Pizza usually saves me, so I went for the old reliable as a New Yorker. The place was pretty full but still a chilled vibe. I attempted to order a small pizza. They were out of smalls. I guess they have a rolled dough quota for each day. I ordered a medium instead. It was a pizza like 4 veggies every two slices. Loved that as an option. Tomatoes, Artichoke, Olives and Mushrooms were atop a great sauce and yuy cheese. My mouth was happy! My only issue was the lack of hair coverings and the young lady who rolled and flattened the dough wore a long chained bracelet while working which was a bit cringy to watch. Hey Imma Virgo, we are into cleanliness! Any way, my pizza was a 10/10 on a Saturday they brighten my HANGRY mood. Amen!
… moreKatie Pruet
So far my favorite pizza place in Tallahassee! Crust is super thin, the toppings and sauce is great, and I love the atmosphere! It doesn’t take long either!
… moreTravis Harsha
Exceptional authentic Neapolitan pizza! “Soft and crunchy.” Fair price. Friendly staff and ambiance. Salsiccia e Ricotta was delicious. I’ll be back! A+++
… moreNate
Pizza tastes burnt in general. Half the pizza’s crust was burnt. Ordered the wings extra well done and still had gelatinous fat and not crispy at all. Also, hot wing sauce tastes super oily. Highly recommend not coming here.
… moreOleg Yurchenko
In a seemingly likeable place an a quiet time, everything went wrong. My wife and I ordered a green salad that already started to rot. We’ve never had such an experience before. Arugula pizza was large and expensive but they never managed to cover the dough base with the ingredients to the full extent, so we had to chew a lot of just baked dough. I wish we had olive oil with it but it was never offered. The soft drink was “served “ in the original bottle with a cheap plastic, and I struggled to take the cap off (it was probably counterfeit). They took the salad off the price list but never informed about the 15% enforced tip fee, so, out of politeness and a good taste of pizza base, I gave them a separate small tip, which I regretted later. And, of course, this is NOT a restaurant, mind you.
… moreXimena C
10/10! A fantastic place to eat delicious pizza. We’ll definitely be back every time we visit Tallahassee.
… more