Jamie Esposito
I may be bias because I work here now but before I did I’ve dined here many times and each time my expierence was amazing! Michael is there to greet you with an aura that makes you feel like family! From the minute you sit with a personalized menu till the time you leave with a handshake or a hug, 2nd Floor Supper Club is a vibe! Sammy in the kitchen, making every meal delectable! My absolute faves are his Bolognese, Pork Chop, Veal Milanese, Liver Pate, Brussels with hot honey and goat cheese and now the Lentil soup made its appearance! I’ve never heard one complaint! Obviously the drinks are flowing and delicious (you’re welcome )! If you haven’t been here you need to make a reservation right after you read this review! See you soon!
… moreLaura Shapiro
Always warm and welcoming! The most delicious food and cocktails! Never disappointed! We feel like part of Sam and Michael’s family. Professional and classy servers!
… moreMorgan Easton
This tiny restaurant is AMAZING! So private and staff was super nice. Don’t rely on the website for food – the chef changes it with the seasons! Just call ahead of time to make sure! But overall, the meals were delicious and the atmosphere was perfect. The specials we got were fried brussel sprouts with goat cheese and grilled octopus (separate dish – both not pictured) and the portions for the entrees were perfect!!
… moreEd Kraucis
Great dinner with friends for my wife’s birthday. Food was phenomenal. Michael and Sam and the staff are the best. Highly recommend.
… moreRich Kromphold
This is an upscale eating experience that cannot be matched by any place in the area. A small apartment turned intimate dining experience, it is hard not to fall in love with it. When the meal’s over, I recommend moving to the bar and let the night continue on just a little longer. You won’t want to leave just yet.
… moreMichael Danoz
Five Stars is an understatement……last night was our 5th time here and Michael and his crew never disappoint….. place has a cozy “Feel Good” Vibe and the menu is simple yet covers all the bases. The meals are Exquisite !! The Octopus appetizer is a must…If you have never had Octopus, don’t be shy, you will not be disappointed. * * * * *
… moreR Suss
Seriously GREAT FOOD!!! Outstanding, warm feeling from the second we arrived to the time we left. Food here is made with love and pride. Each dish we had was outstanding! The octopus app was the best octopus we had all year! Our server was fantastic!! All in all, we can’t wait to come back!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
… moreKathleen Galano
We really enjoy eating here! Michael is very welcoming and the chef comes out to make sure all is well. The food is delicious, the menu is creative and we will be back of course! We sat in the back room this time. Unfortunately a big party came in and they were basically yelling instead of talking. We couldn’t hear ourselves with our 2 dining partners…
… moreT
We had an awesome experience at 2nd floor restaurant. The host was exceptionally thoughtful and accommodating. Our waitress was fantastic. The food was delicious. I very much enjoyed the hanger steak and the cinnamon croissant dessert. Thank you to the staff for making such a wonderful birthday dinner!
… moreMark Elia
Love, love this place. Owners Michael and Sam nail it. Great atmosphere, unbelievable food (get the octopus!) and perfect drinks. Friendly wait staff and bartenders. And don’t OD on the homemade bread sticks, save room for dinner. Come here if you want a quality meal, screw that Pier nonsense.
… more