Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 404 Buffalo Plaza, Sarver, PA 16055
Website: https://toastedamo.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Toasted Amo Menu & More – Sarver, PA 16055
We’re located at 404 Buffalo Plaza, Sarver, PA 16055! Toasted Amo in Sarver, Pennsylvania, offers authentic toasted Italian sandwiches and refreshing smoothies.
Toasted Amo – YourMenu®
Get takeout from Toasted Amo at 404 Buffalo Plaza, Sarver, PA 16055 now! Browse the menu & prices, place your order, and track everything online here.
Toasted Amo | Sarver PA – Facebook
Welcome to Toasted Amo, your go-to spot in Sarver, PA, for genuine toasted Italian sandwiches… See more. Italian Restaurant · (724) 295-3665.
Reviews
Krystle Hall
Been wanting to try this place for a while and I am so upset with myself that I didnt try it sooner! The food is absolutely incredible, the amount of flavor and fresh ingredients is unmatched in this area. If youre considering going, you absolutely should!
… moreMaureen
I had a great sandwich today@ Toasted Amo! It was so delicious & there’s so many options it’s tough to decide what to choose. This place is very welcoming & you will be so glad you came! I wish the owners continued success!
… moreBailey Hamilton
I was really excited to try toasted amo! a new sandwhich place in sarver where your options are fast food, or chinese sounds great! my company placed an order for a later lunch, and we even picked it up before the scheduled pickup time. Although we picked up early, the sandwhich did not meet any sort of expectations. the bread was soggy, but incredibly hard on the shell at the same time. the mozeralla spread was very chunky and tasted like plastic, and there wasn’t a slice of parm that i saw. you can see how the bread stuck to the rest of the sandwhich that’s how soggy it was! on a positive note, i will say the restaurant dining area is very nice, and clean, and the french fries were pretty good. Overall, i can’t say that myself or coworkers will be back.
… moreLuAnn Cibik
Wow! Calling this a sandwich place really doesn’t describe it. The sandwiches are unusual and huge, the bread delicious and unique. Watching them make each sandwich like a piece of edible art was so much fun! I had the number 6, a meatball with loads of cheese and pesto. And i would have it again. These are big enough for two people to share!
… moreTyler Ferraino
If you haven’t tried Toasted Amo yet, do yourself a favor and GO! I had the #3 Tuscan Crunch and it was amazing! Everything tasted fresh and was delicious. Very chill vibe, I stopped around 1pm on a weekday for a quick lunch. Very friendly staff and extremely clean facilities. I’ll definitely be stopping again and bringing my coworkers!
My only recommendation is that maybe they add public WiFi. As a Verizon customer there isn’t much service in the Sarver area, especially inside and when you’re on a quick work lunch it’s nice to have access to internet.
… moreMy only recommendation is that maybe they add public WiFi. As a Verizon customer there isn’t much service in the Sarver area, especially inside and when you’re on a quick work lunch it’s nice to have access to internet.
William Thoma
They are so close to being awesome, but they are missing the mark in peculiar ways. Their Italian sandwich has only one meat, prosciutto. Prosciutto is sliced paper thin for a reason. It was 3/4 inch thick on the sandwich. No amount of acidity can balance out that much fat. The GOAT is one of their steak sandwiches offering ribeye strips. The actual meat looks like it was pre-chewed. The consistency was difficult to eat. It’s a shame. Their other ingredients appeared to be good and the dining area was, aside from the cheesy advertisements on the tables, was clean and modern. For the price point, the misses outweigh the pluses. Not going to return.
… moreKayci Dodgson
We had dinner here with some friends and brought our baby along. As first time parents it’s been hard to know where will be welcoming to the unpredictable presence of a baby but the staff was super accommodating and brought a high chair over without being asked and they overall just seemed happy to have us there! Plus the food was super delicious.
… moreBenny Balla
The thin fries are good. The workers were really nice. I always come in and get the G.O.A.T. as it is my favorite sandwich, but today the meat was so different. It has become this strange rubbery texture and it is hard to chew and the flavor has changed as well! Plz change it back to the good beef.
… moreKaren Claypool
1st time going and the three of us all unfortunately ordered the salad with the marinated cucumbers, chicken, etc. The marinated zucchini in the salad was honestly not at all palatable for any of us. It was such a disappointment. Having never tried anything else there if you go for the 1st time try a sandwich, they may be delicious, but trust me on the salad.(I literally am not a picky eater…I eat all foods)
… moreGretchen Ament
Super friendly staff
The sandwich was perfect. The bread was soft but toasted and the flavors blended well. I will definitely be back the next time I am in the Sarver area
… moreThe sandwich was perfect. The bread was soft but toasted and the flavors blended well. I will definitely be back the next time I am in the Sarver area