Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bourbon Mill | New Oxford PA – Facebook
If you’ve not seen them in the past…do not miss this one! Show starts at 8pm. For reservations, call 717-624-8987.
Bourbon Mill | New Oxford PA – Facebook
Upcoming Events · Sat, Mar 14 at 8:00PM EDT · 4797 York Rd, New Oxford, PA, United · Music · 105 people. Past events. See all · Sun …
Bourbon Mill | Toast
Come in and enjoy! Location. 4797 York Road, New Oxford, PA 17350. Directions. Similar restaurants in your area. scroll left scroll right. Deja Brew Coffee …
Reviews
Miss Val
We came here on a Sunday afternoon because we saw that a band we like was performing.
We sat at the bar and were greeted immediately by the bartender. The place wasn’t crowded but she was the only one bartending. She was constantly moving but was friendly and attentive.
We ordered the hot honey chicken bowl and the chicken enchilada. It didn’t take long for it to come out, maybe 15 minutes or so. The food was ok. I was happy to see the rice bowls on the menu instead of just burgers and sandwiches.
The band sounded good. I liked the layout. I think you could see the band from most every table. It was nice to see live music scheduled on a Sunday during football season.
The atmosphere was easygoing and casual. It was a little dark in there but the ceiling is high and they had some string lights up giving it more of a cozy vibe.
Prices were good. Parking was easy – there is a parking lot right outside and there were plenty of spots.
I did see they have a pavilion out back and I’m not sure if that’s just for private events or outdoor music but if it’s open to the public I would like to come back in warmer weather to check that out.
… moreWe sat at the bar and were greeted immediately by the bartender. The place wasn’t crowded but she was the only one bartending. She was constantly moving but was friendly and attentive.
We ordered the hot honey chicken bowl and the chicken enchilada. It didn’t take long for it to come out, maybe 15 minutes or so. The food was ok. I was happy to see the rice bowls on the menu instead of just burgers and sandwiches.
The band sounded good. I liked the layout. I think you could see the band from most every table. It was nice to see live music scheduled on a Sunday during football season.
The atmosphere was easygoing and casual. It was a little dark in there but the ceiling is high and they had some string lights up giving it more of a cozy vibe.
Prices were good. Parking was easy – there is a parking lot right outside and there were plenty of spots.
I did see they have a pavilion out back and I’m not sure if that’s just for private events or outdoor music but if it’s open to the public I would like to come back in warmer weather to check that out.
Cindy Burgener
What a FIND! This has become our favorite place “EVER” in Gettysburg, PA! Alligator Bites as our appetizer, followed by one of the best meatloaf over mashed potatoes like my grandma made!
Folks don’t miss this gem in Gettysburg! If you live here or just passing through be sure to add Bourbon Mill on your “MUST STOP” list!
Our to-go order consisted of “Mark” (habanero + sweet chili) flavored hot wings, chicken & dumplings, Baja chicken soup and a crab pretzel … FOR our New Year’s celebration at home!
Now, the hard decision. What to wear to the new year celebration party? Oh well, if we can’t decide then we just won’t go!
Hope you like these fabulous photos snapped during our visit! Gorgeous holiday decorations! My friends, you WILL NOT be disappointed or dissatisfied making the trip out to Bourbon Mill for any meal! Many delicacies and delicious food and beverage options to choose from.
… moreFolks don’t miss this gem in Gettysburg! If you live here or just passing through be sure to add Bourbon Mill on your “MUST STOP” list!
Our to-go order consisted of “Mark” (habanero + sweet chili) flavored hot wings, chicken & dumplings, Baja chicken soup and a crab pretzel … FOR our New Year’s celebration at home!
Now, the hard decision. What to wear to the new year celebration party? Oh well, if we can’t decide then we just won’t go!
Hope you like these fabulous photos snapped during our visit! Gorgeous holiday decorations! My friends, you WILL NOT be disappointed or dissatisfied making the trip out to Bourbon Mill for any meal! Many delicacies and delicious food and beverage options to choose from.
Jamie Tsottles
I have not had wings this good in years. Price was great and flavor was spot on.
Good selection of beers and crafted drinks.
Band at 1 in the afternoon on a Sunday! Great rock and roll. Band name was Double Barrel. They gave away about 8 or 10 tee shirts.
… moreGood selection of beers and crafted drinks.
Band at 1 in the afternoon on a Sunday! Great rock and roll. Band name was Double Barrel. They gave away about 8 or 10 tee shirts.
Jeff Tate
Stopped in for lunch today and we were able to sit outside. It’s a really nice spot. We missed seeing the live music that will be later in the evening.
… moreJoseph Herche
This is my second time here. I have to say that the staff here is amazing. We came on a quiet rainy Taco Tuesday around 4pm.
We enjoyed every aspect of our experience.
Food is great and the servers were amazing! We were able to sit wherever we wanted and just felt “at home”
I feel this spot has much to offer. We can’t wait to come back!!!!
… moreWe enjoyed every aspect of our experience.
Food is great and the servers were amazing! We were able to sit wherever we wanted and just felt “at home”
I feel this spot has much to offer. We can’t wait to come back!!!!
C Gordon
I’ve driven by this place so many times but finally stopped in for lunch! I’m so glad I did! The ambiance inside is incredible, the food is great and the menu is endless with options. My server was very friendly and helpful. Prices were reasonable. My experience exceeded my expectations and I will be going back!
… moreM Taylor
Fun venue for music fans. Gorgeous outdoor area with covered patios and lawn games, and you can BYO folding chair if you’re there for the bands because the place gets packed. We asked around and heard the food was, overall, not great. I know, hearsay. But the fried pickles and chicken tenders with fries were the only recommended menu items from the people around us. Our friend had ordered the latter and thought the chicken was good, but the server said she’d come back with the fries and never did. My sister and I loved the fried pickles. They came with ranch dip that tasted like homemade, which was awesome. If the food had a better reputation, we would’ve ordered more. Also, our table only had counter service with food delivered to us. This could be why we only saw one server in our section of the patio. She was hustling! So busy, she could only partially clear our table one time in nearly three hours. (She only had enough arms to clear half the stuff once she got to us.) I felt bad for her because she was stretched so thin. Otherwise, besides hitting a drive-thru for food on the way home (we were starving), we enjoyed our night. Next time, we’ll try some of the bourbon along with the music.
… moreStephanie Anne Brewer
The food was delicious, homemade and fresh!!!! This was our first visit to Bourbon Mill and we will definitely come back. The waitress was very attentive and friendly. We sat on the patio which was large and clean. There is also a bar where you can sit. Loved it ! ❤️
… moreWilliam McLarin
Clam chowder arrived lukewarm. Server was very nice and warmed it up. Then we discovered it was way too salty. This from my wife who likes salty food. But her flatbread pizza and my quinoa bowl were perfect. So 4 stars not 5 because of the soup.
… moreChris Parsons
We went and it was busy but our server took our order and got our 1st drinks and then I watched her visit every other table at least 4/5 times but we never saw her again. The expiditer brought out food and only one person another drink . Then we sat and sat and sat I was ready to just walk out with leftovers on their plates. The I saw our server visiting the table next to us for a 6th time then I tapped her and and said we need boxes and a bill. TERRIBLE SERVICE. The food was meh, the chilli was the worst I ever had and I love chilli. The crab cakes were mostly filling. My wife got a quesadilla and it had bbq sauce and rice…yes rice in a quesadilla (who does that) which absorbs any moisture and made it very dry. The ribs were the only thing that was good otherwise would give food a 1 star. We took food home to try and doctor it but ultimately tossed it were it belonged…the trash.I will not be back.
… more