Social Profile: ![]()
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Wantagh, ranked the #1 Best Pizza Chain nationwide, serves bold Italian flavors with a local touch. Our hot honey pizza, coal-fired classics, and jumbo chicken wings are baked in 900° coal fire ovens using hand-picked Italian tomatoes and freshly grated pecorino Romano cheese. Conveniently located near Jones Beach State Park and Wantagh Park, we’re the perfect choice for post-beach dinners, family celebrations, or quick pasta takeout. Enjoy dine-in comfort, speedy pizza delivery, or easy online ordering for your next meal.
Casual chain serving charred-crust pies, plus wings, subs & Italian plates in a modern setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3430 Sunrise Hwy, Wantagh, NY 11793
Phone: (516) 679-2625
Website: https://acfp.com/locations/wantagh/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: acfp.com
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Coal Fired Pizza, Wings & Pasta in Wantagh | Anthony’s
Just steps from Wantagh Park and the LIRR, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza transforms premium dough, vine‑ripened tomatoes, and fresh toppings in a 900‑degree …
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings | Where Fire Meets Flavor
Experience the flavor of Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings. Enjoy handcrafted & authentic pizza, wings, & Italian cuisine. Order takeout, delivery or …
Anthony’s Locations | Find a Pizza Restaurant Near You
Explore Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza locations across the country. Find our nearest outlet for delicious coal-fired pizza, pasta, wings and more!
Last Updates
Reviews
Kimberly Tomlinson
The wings looked great but tasted burnt. They did not have a flavourful char on them. No seasoning was detected – just burnt chicken and honey drizzle on my taste buds.
The pizza was weirdly tepid. The name “Coal Fired” implies a hot, smokey meal, fresh out the oven. It was bizarre to me how my done to order pizza was not even hot; both the dough and the toppings!
For a pizza AND wings lover, it was a truly underwhelming & disappointing dining experience for my first time here. There are better options out there.
… moreThe pizza was weirdly tepid. The name “Coal Fired” implies a hot, smokey meal, fresh out the oven. It was bizarre to me how my done to order pizza was not even hot; both the dough and the toppings!
For a pizza AND wings lover, it was a truly underwhelming & disappointing dining experience for my first time here. There are better options out there.
Nicolette Christ
We were here for dinner sitting at the bar and this was our view in front of us. A cup swarming with flies. Made us itchy and disgusted. I understand restaurants have bugs but do the customers need to stare at that while they eat? Completely grossed out.
… moreSuzanne K.
Grabbed pizza here recently for the first time. Pizza was delicious and overall the place has a fun atmosphere. We were here on a Saturday night so it was quite busy and a bit noisy but will definitely go back if we are in the area!
… moreElana S (Ticketjackass.com)
Great Anthony’s salad, very affordable prices, good service, social distancing and famous chicken wings. For me personally it was a little bit burned. I can’t have little black coal pieces in my mouth. Sorry. But I know for sure some people love it. So, people it’s up to you.
… moreAshley Blum
Our waitress was so nice and attentive. I wish I remembered her name. She gave great suggestions on drinks and had the bartender make an amazing espresso martini. The food was fresh and delicious. The wings are amazing Definitely recommend after a beach day.
… moreafz777
Update:
They said they fixed the problem I’m told and I’m going back. Thank you!!
I’ll update again if not fixed… I trust them.
Need to fix the fruit fly problem asap or whatever tiny fly it was. Weird in the middle of the winter!
We saw one then more and it got really annoying and made our dinner very unpleasant.
… moreThey said they fixed the problem I’m told and I’m going back. Thank you!!
I’ll update again if not fixed… I trust them.
Need to fix the fruit fly problem asap or whatever tiny fly it was. Weird in the middle of the winter!
We saw one then more and it got really annoying and made our dinner very unpleasant.
Pedro Luis
I saw some negative comments about the pizza being burnt and what not but I gave it a shot anyway and this is the best pizza I’ve tasted so far. Cooked to perfection and tastes, absolutely fresh. I’m sure the guys probably have some off days once in a blue for those complaining about anything.
… moreMike O’Kane
No better place for salad pizza and wings among other things. Everything is fresh. The sauce on the Margarita Pizza cannot be beat. And the greatest thing is no matter what Anthony’s you go to they all have the same formula for awesome food
… moreAlisa
The bartender and manager were horrible. The bartender had a attitude the minute that we walked in. The Italian Lemonade was so sweet it tasted horrible. When I said something her attitude got even worse. She wouldn’t let us or another couple sit outside. She started to complain to other customers about us at the end of the bar without us knowing who tried to pick a fight with my husband. The manager did nothing at all to help. She acted like she was the manager instead of just the bartender. Do mot go to this location. Woodbury is so much better and a lot more professional!
… morebret callahan
If I could give this Wantagh location zero stars I would. How do you mess up wings not once but twice. I am beyond angry. First they were pink….I get no apology …then they were again awful and soaked in grease. Plus only 2 people working on the floor on a football Sunday is ridiculous!!! Thanks for nothing!!!
… more