Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Take out
… View more
Grand Opening of Califon Location is October 2nd, 2025! Cookie Maven offers beautiful and delicious sweet treats baked from scratch. Classic and specialty cookies, bars, brownies, cakes and cheesecake by the slice and more! We also carry a large selection of premium ice cream for our made-to-order ice cream sammies. Choose any two cookies and your favorite ice cream flavor and we will make a giant ice cream sandwich for you to enjoy! We also provide dessert catering for events of all sizes, wholesale orders, parties and events in our brand new shop located at 427 County Road 513, Califon NJ location.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 427 County Rd 513 #3, Califon, NJ 07830
Phone: (646) 641-7322
Website: http://cookiemavenbaking.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Custom Cookie Catering | Cookie Maven Baking | United States
For the freshest cookies right out of the oven,visit our bakery at 427 County Road 513, Califon, NJ 07830. . Retail Hours: Wednesdays 10am – 7pm. Thursdays …
Cookie Maven Baking | Califon NJ – Facebook
Califon location opening Thursday, October 2nd at 10am! Cookie Maven is a boutique bakery located at 427 County Road 513, Califon, NJ.
Cookie Maven (@cookiemavenbaking) • Instagram photos and videos
Open Wednesday to Saturday 10am-7pm & Sunday 9am-2pm. For more info visit our website: Photo shared by Cookie Maven on September 28, 2025 tagging @cswein, and @ …
Reviews
Dana Smith
Absolute best cookies I’ve ever had! Toby the owner and everyone I’ve encountered in the store are beyond nice and helpful. I did a large special order for my baby shower favors and the cookies were a HUGE hit. Everyone was asking me where they were from. So happy they moved even closer to me now!
… moreAmy Charron
The espresso chip cake was beyond delicious. My kids enjoyed ice cream. They support other small vendors if you need something small to go with a gift card. So happy Califon has a fun new bakery!
… moreCAMI FILMS
Nothing to say about this place but YUMMY. Small in the cut spot. Very nice owners. Sweet and kind. I had the almond horn and the chocolate chip chunk. Both extremely good. Soft but firm. Not too sweet. Just made with love.
… moreRachel Wright
Fantastic local bakery, with an impressive selection of gluten-free and dairy-free cookies in addition to traditional. From the traditional cookies we loved the whoopie pies, almond thumbprint with apricot jam, and the Reese’s peanut butter cup-stuffed cookie (yeah, it’s awesome). In the gf selection so far we’ve tried the peanut butter sandies and chocolate chip cookies–all delicious. We’ll be back for more!
… morePeter Patino
Never thought I could love something that wasn’t alive. That is until I met cookie maven. Delicious fresh and sweet rich but not overbearing pastries. Extremely kind owner who never rushes and takes time to explain everything and any question I have. Cannot recommend this place enough and will never need to bake again as long as I live in NJ with cookie maven.
… moreRachael Lynn
I have been here twice now and both times the staff was friendly and the baked goods have been incredible. My favorite so far is the espresso chocolate chip cake. Everything was super fresh I will be coming back time and time again. It’s worth the 20 minute drive.
… moreAnastasia Kudless
The best! Gluten-free options are hard to come across especially ones that compete with their non-gluten free counterparts, but these really do earn an outstanding review. Great variety too. Will be back for more!
… moreNICHOLAS LEMOINE
Amazing cookies. Chocolate chip was the best, smores is great too!
… moreWinegeek!
I have cooked over 1000 times with a Michelin three star chef including helping out in pastry. This off the beaten path treasure stunned me with how well done are their creations. If you are passing buy treat yourself! I really appreciated that they understand how important not being too sweet is. Bravo!
… moreLorraine Rocha
Everything is crafted with such care and intention—from explaining the product, to packaging it beautifully, to delivering an absolutely delicious treat in every bite. It’s a wonderful experience, made by the kind and attentive owner. I brought a box to a friend’s BBQ, and it was the very first dessert to disappear from the table. Everyone loved it!
… more