Comfy eatery offering surf ‘n’ turf such as grilled fish & strip steak, plus spirits & music.
Mat Bac
The catch is a catch when it comes to food – pun intended.
Go there, enjoy some of the best fresh grilled or fried fish there is, round it up with some homemade key lime pie and get a hug when you leave (and are lucky).
It’s not the fancy restaurant to watch the sunset over the seashore, but it has heart and soul for great food.
… moreDJ AJ Falcon
LOVED the “Keysey ” atmosphere here, and the locals who were hangin out. A charming, cozy, quaint, neighborhood joint. As a Wedding and Event DJ&MC in Key Largo, Islamorada, the Florida Keys, Miami, and South Florida, I was here to be DJ&MC for a wedding across the street at Dolphin Point Villas. My server Skye was sweet, charming and very attentive. Food was pretty tasty considering it’s a local casual place. Had the Coconut Shrimp, Tuna app, and Macadamia Encrusted Grouper, and on a previous visit, had the Grilled Mahi which melted in my mouth, but could’ve had a bit more flavor or I’d rate this place 5 stars. Still, I highly recommend you visit!! I understand there’s live entertainment on Friday nights. You’ll enjoy this restaurant!
… moreChandler Wright
The mozzarella sticks at The Catch were hands-down the best I’ve ever had — crunchy, creamy, and clearly homemade. I didn’t even know that mozzarella sticks could be this good! The marinara was so addictive we started dipping our sweet potato fries in it!
We also ordered coconut shrimp tacos (not even sure if they’re on the menu) and they were absolutely delicious — sweet, crispy, and perfectly balanced. Super loaded with fresh ingredients too! The Godfather Mahi was another highlight: light, fresh, and served over warm, creamy spinach. Cozy and comforting.
A true hidden gem in Key Largo. I’ll definitely be back!!
We got our order to-go, but the restaurant looks like a cute family owned business. I’ll probably come for dine-in service next for the whole experience 🙂
… moreTina Ell
My husband and I tried this place for the first time tonight. Why have we waited so long? This place is great! Everyone was SUPER friendly and the food was great. My husband had the prime rib special and I had the seafood platter and we took a key lime pie to go. The seafood was cooked perfectly and had lots of flavor. I swiped a bite of my husband’s prime rib and it was yummy. So glad we found another favorite restaurant to put on our list.
… moreSteve Fye
Very laid-back, low key dining experience. Drink prices are CHEAP!!! Food prices are what you would expect, but definitely an amazing value! The seafood was incredibly fresh and well-prepared. Some of the best seared tuna we have ever had! We felt daring and got the whole yellowtail fried and it was incredible! Highly recommend returning!
… moreErin McTigue
Really delicious dinner! Our family went to 3 different fish restaurants in Key Largo and this was everyone’s favorite and least expensive! Very laid back & live music on Saturday night. The grilled Mahi & coconut Mahi were our favorites, also liked the cucumber salad. Desserts were great too – tried rum cake, key lime pie, peanut butter pie & brownie sundae. Can sit outside too. Wait staff was very competent. You could also order off the lunch menu for dinner which made my kids happy bc there were tacos on the lunch menus.
… moreTheresa Taylor
We can’t say enough about the wonderful meal we had here. The service and food were out of this world. We had just returned from a cruise and this food was better than the cruise food. Husband had Aztec Mahi and I had a basket of coconut shrimp. Desserts we had were key lime pie and peanut butter pie.
… moreJMH
Cool quaint seafood restaurant.
Ordered the seafood broiled platter. Reasonably priced, but would have liked 1 or 2 more scallops or shrimp. Very tasty garlic sauce.
… moreJoel Terrazas L
Best fresh seafood in Key Largo Florida. I had the Grouper Hog sandwich with Potatoes salad . Everything was fresher than fresh . The food was steaming hot and the food was delicious. The atmosphere is 5 o’clock 24/7 at the Catch restaurant. Love this restaurant. . The Chef is truly the Best .
… moreRicardo Bacalhau
The Catch was amazing. Keys local vibe, lay back, family friendly and fantastic service, beer, cocktails are available.
Please ask for the catch of the day, the fried fish was fantastic… just fantastic, as I like, the head of the fish was crispy and well fried, so The head was delicious.
Also try the Key Lime Pie, I don’t have a photo because was end before I realized that I didn’t have a photo. Well, the pie is delicious, very well balanced.
… more