Rob Hartung
My experience started with really positive interactions with staff. I think everyone who came in tonight would agree as I noticed the way staff greeted and took care of guests. My pizza was really good. Well prepared and nicely baked. The place would seem to be geared more for carry out than dine in, as there are very few tables, and they are really too small to hold your pizza and your plates. The pizza is enough of a treat for us that we will order again, but get it to go next time. We also had some cannoli, which were ok. They had likely sat around long enough to lose their freshness and crispness.
… moreSamantha Fitzgarrald
My family tried Williamsburg Pizza last weekend for the first time and it was so delicious! We ordered the Cup and Char Grandma XL and it was a ton of pizza we had a lot for leftovers the next day, the house salad, and Cannolis. The pizza was delicious not just your basic pepperoni that is for sure. I was very impressed with everything and will order again to try different options they offer.
… moreCameron Ziegenfuss
I tried this place for the first time last night and it was amazing! I ordered online and the pizza was ready when I arrived about 15 minutes later. Crust was crispy but soft (as it should be). Perfect balance of sauce, cheese and meat. Truly a NY style pizza.
The only suggestion I’d make is sending a text with the estimated pickup time. After I ordered I didn’t see any indication of when the pizza would be ready.
I’ll be ordering again soon.
… moreJesseca Babecky
I went here when it first opened and I loved it, however, things have quickly gone down hill. First, we tried to order on Christmas eve because online showed it was open until 5pm and it was not, we tried to order online, couldn’t place an order, tried to call and was sent right to voicemail / end call.
Today we ordered a pizza at 7pm, store hours online say they close at 9pm however when we arrived to pick up our pizza all the chairs were put up and they looked closed for the night. We went inside and walked to the counter and the young man was snickering /laughing and walked away from us. It was very weird but the older gentlemen gave us our pizza and salad and we left.
We got home and the salad was inedible and tasted old and the dressing tasted of butter … weird
The pizza was NOTHING like the first time we ordered pizza, the crust was as thin as a dime, had very little cheese, and looked undercooked. What is going on here… I have no clue but won’t be returning. Such a bummer
… moreChristopher “Digi” Diehm
Great New York style pizza in west Omaha. Good crew, and amazing food. Garlic knots were good too along with the cannoli. You can get Brooklyn style or grandma square crust style pizzas. Definitely a step above your regular chains. There is only a couple of tables, and tables at a counter, not a lot of seating, plan accordingly. Order Ahead!
… moreGluten and Dairy free Queen
Kinda pricey but the pies are larger than you would think.
Gluten free crust was okay, nothing amazing but they offer vegan Violife cheese. That won it for me.
… moreNicole Hasenjager
Amazing pizza! The garlic cheese knots were off the chain good!! I did a pickup order — it was ready right on time and absolutely delicious. The staff was super friendly and welcoming. So glad to have you guys so close! My family and I will definitely be ordering from you often!
… moreAndrew Stiles
Best customer service I’ve seen in a LONG time. They deserve every five star review. Best New Style Pizza I’ve had in 2 decades.
… moreAndrew Neisius
I was looking for a New York slice and I sure found it. Crust, cheese, toppings were a fantastic pairing with quality and amounts. There are a few tables to eat at but it’s more of a take away place. I saw a few chain restaurants on the drive here. Glad I didn’t stop at them.
… moreSarah Gage
BY FAR the BEST Pizza I have ever had!!! We are so excited they just opened next to our neighborhood. The sauce and crust is perfection!
… more