Thad Sowinski
OK, I stopped to get the free slice of pizza plus to make an order cinnamon breadsticks were tasty but way too much cinnamon and we got a pizza with sausage mushroom, and onion. Wow the pizza was OK. This was her opening day. The only thing me and the Wife didn’t like barely any onions or mushrooms on a pizza. It’s almost like they might’ve just put a couple on them real fine. A couple months ago we ate at the one in Findlay, Ohio and around upper Sandusky. Both of those places were really really good. I sure hope they get better. I don’t know if they were so busy that they were cutting corners or something.
… moreBuckeye Mike
The pizza lives up to the name! Absolutely fantastic pie today. We ordered the breakfast pizza which is usually a hit or miss (depending on the place) but Heavenly Pizza knocked it out of the park. My wife and I are from NY and it’s been so difficult finding good pizza here in NW Ohio and FINALLY we have it. Delivery was on time, pizza was still hot and they cut it perfectly. Couldn’t be happier and we’d be glad to order again sometime.
… moreJeff Cross
Great service and fantastic pizza. $6 for 2 slices and a 20oz is a great deal.
… moreJay Rodney
Very disappointed on first order from a new pizza place in town. Got a medium 2 topping regular crust pizza. Crust was uneven, very thin for a non-thin crust order, looked like it didn’t get proper time to rise. Very little sauce, cheese or toppings. Tasted like a mid-level frozen pizza from the grocery store…. which is still better than no pizza at all
… moreJacklyn Ragsdale
So good. Lots of toppings. Two 16in pizzas easily feed 8-10 adults. Garlic cheese bread is delicious.
… moreKaleb Gordon
Ordered a pizza for delivery yesterday (10/18/2025) at around 6:00PM.
The delivery driver was very sweet, met with a smile.
The pizza’s flavors were very good, but it wasn’t hot, which I’m assuming is due to the 1 hour delivery time, but I guess it was a Saturday so that may be expected.
I reheated a couple of slices later on in the night, and upon taking a bite of one of them, I had to immediately spit it out and almost got sick. I’m unsure if one of the cooks wasn’t wearing gloves, or if they dropped ash in it, or spit in it as a smoker, but it tasted and smelled exactly like a cigarette.
It helps that the place is a Christian establishment, I love the logo and pizza box, but I don’t know if I’ll be able to get it again.
Maybe try a different location for faster delivery time and better kitchen practices?
… moreMark Piotrowski
Honestly I’m not a big pizza fan
I’m doing some construction work a couple of doors down. So I thought pizza it’s close
Wow Their name fits. It was heavenly
Had some cheese lasagna. Same thing
2 thumbs up. Very good pie
… moreKimberly Johnson
absolutely loved ajs. it was our first experience with ajs ever and we will be back. still we are talking about it almost a week later. the staff was phenomenal and helped open the door when I went in to get our jumbo pizza (i was so taken back, in a good way) cant wait to try everything else… especially the pickle pizza .
great job BG, this was a perfect addition to town.
… moreTodd Sanford
Pizza was fantastic will definitely be back
Ordered delivery they told me 1hr and showed up in less than 30 minutes
Try the thin crust you will not be disappointed
… morePat Torongo
Veggies very fresh! That’s the high point. Sauce was sweet, all good some people like that. Crust below average, may have been under cooked but it was $20+ I won’t spend again anytime soon or recommend to anyone.
… more