Barry Thaler
I always look forward to stopping here for delicious sausage and Tomato Pie. Never a disappointment !!
… moreLadyana
I was excited to try Roma’s tomato pie because so many people rave about it. I had to get a whole pie because no slices were available. Unfortunately, it was extremely disappointing and disgusting. The sauce had a VERY sour/bitter taste to it, that was also super sweet. Maybe like soured milk or beer that was sitting in the sun for hours. It’s difficult to explain. Either way, it was inedible. I took one bite and spit it out. I had 8 other people try it and they had the same reaction. My husband and son were the only ones brave enough to eat a whole piece (they hate to waste food) and regretted it 30 minutes later. Thank goodness for 2 bathrooms! Idk if I got an old tomato pie that went bad…or if this was normal. I cannot recommend this.
… moreDavid S
Local, local, local… The best fresh Italian Sausage around! Nice meaty and tasty large sausage rings(and you pick the length). Lots to choose from here, but the sausage is the “bomb”! Great in a sauce or on a bbq too…Enjoy! Just did another shop( see pics ) at Roma’s for more sausage: ring and bulk, and a jar of riggies sauce…You must try this place out!
… morebill karash
Best tomato pie I have ever had. Worth the drive for me. 40 miles
… moreDiana Lyman
Delicious home made Italian foods! Meats, pastas, sauces, deli, Italian imports and locally made favorites like their famous UTICA PIES!!
… moreMark Piccolo
I grew up in the Valley, and when Roma’s Tomato Pie magically appeared in our kitchen: it was instant ‘s. 40+ years later it’s still amazing and I bring it home to Maryland after every visit to see my pals.
… moreStash Merritt
The one, the only, the legendary. Worth the 1.5 hour drive for their tomato pie. Don’t forget to order a day ahead!
… moreKate tobin
The best tomato pie I ever had! Deli is awsome too!!
… moreAllen Vella
Just came back to the Catskills from a day in Utica, stopped here for Tomato pie, brought back a half sheet. Wow, I know I don’t have anything to campare to..as locals do, but we absolutely loved this one. The dough wasn’t to thick, cooked nicely through, and a crispy bottom. The sauce and cheese really came through, not sweet (hate sweet sauce) and the cheese was excellent. Love this one. Also bought some red pepper taralli, and a couple of pounds of provolone cheese sausage (I think they call this Sicilian sausage, my heritage also). I haven’t had a good cheese sausage since Joe’s pork store closed in Astoria NY where I grew up. It was the ideal..hopefully this one will be too. Looking forward!
… moreKhoa Vo
Delicious as always. I grew up eating Roma’s tomato pie and missed so much. Finally was able to come back to visit Utica and had to pick me up their tomato pie (10$) and it was as good as I remembered. The sauce, crust and cheese combination is alway a hit. It just so simple but so damn delicious, how? Besides tomato pie, Roma also sells other goodies but unfortunately I wasn’t able to buy any because of my short time in Utica. Roma’s tomato pie is a staple and huge part of Utica. I hope they continue to thrive and do well.
… more