Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Goodfellas Pizza Italian Restaurant is a family owned and run business that takes great pride in providing delicious Italian American food, fine wines beers and cordials as well as delicious authentic Italian desserts at reasonable prices. Founded in 2016 Goodfella’s has been working to become an active part of our community contributing to our local schools in Port Jervis and Pike County. Providing donations of food and gift certificates to local charitable organizations. We aim to provide a quiet friendly atmosphere where family and friends can gather and enjoy delicious food drinks and great customer service. We look forward to serving you.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 111 Hulst Dr, Matamoras, PA 18336
Phone: (570) 491-8191
Website: http://goodfellaspizzapa.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: spotapps.co
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Goodfella’s Pizza Italian Restaurant – Matamoras, PA
Offering buffet, family style, and sit-down lunches and dinners with a wine, beer, and spirits bar, large screen TV, and projector makes it the perfect …
Goodfella’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant – Matamoras, PA – 111 Hulst …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-8:30 PM; Shop address is 111 Hulst Dr, Matamoras, PA 18336111 Hulst Dr, Matamoras, PA 18336; (570) 828-3632.
Goodfellas Pizza Italian Restaurant | Matamoras PA – Facebook
Goodfellas Pizza Italian Restaurant, Matamoras. 1509 likes · 70 talking about this · 2138 were here. Great pizza, italian-american food, cold beer,…
Reviews
George Betances
It was my first time in the area and looking for a spot to eat and their name caught my eye. Really nice atmosphere with pictures of characters from Goodfellas then you notice their pizza and wonder how good their food is. Their chicken parm was delicious and the sauce was rich and flavorful. My girl liked their chicken wrap with fries. I didn’t take any pizza with me and man it looked good and thin crust. I will come back for it soon.
… moregiovanna genovesi
I got delivery from here, and from ordering to delivery, to opening and eating the food, everything was easy and really good!
… moreItz Hollywoood
WOW, I’ve tried pizza in a variety of states, and a plethora of styles, original, New York, abstract places, mom and pop, and this is definitely in the top 5, honestly. Ironically we actually ordered a half n half, don’t usually do cheese but we wanted to try it just to test how good it was, but I love pepperoni so I just see it as meant to be that it was all pepperoni lol. Either way they were friendly, very nice place, and we also got the meatballs in marinara, and let me just say those were insane! Definitely be back, thank yall !
… moreA’drea Miller
The best pizza we’ve ever had. We get pizza here every time we visit Milford. Our waitress was great. She was so friendly and telling us how we’d have fun going to the Milford theater. It was a nice atmosphere.
… moreEthan
The food was delicious and the food experience was great until we had to pay. I handed the woman 2 cards because i only had 10 on one card and the rest of the money for the bill on the other. Once i handed it to her she replied with “why didnt you tell me separate check?” In a snarky tone. I explained to her that i only had 10 on one card and the rest on the other. Another employee tried to assist with the transaction but we werent having any luck at the moment. Our waitress and the other employee walked to the back while i tried to figure it out on my side. A couple seconds after they walked into the back i heard loud and clear “why cant he just put it on one card?” In the same snarky tone. We ended up figured it out with the bill, however this interaction was very conflicting towards my experience because the food was great-
… moreGuy Fierra
Five stars all the way for Goodfellas—this place is like stepping into the movie itself! “As far back as I can remember, I always wanted to be a gangster,” and let me tell you, I felt like one with every bite. The walls are dripping with memorabilia, quotes, and photos that make you want to shout, “Go home and get your shinebox!”
I started with the garlic knots, and oh boy—they’re chef’s kiss. Crispy on the outside, pillowy on the inside, and perfectly garlicky. I could’ve eaten a whole tray and still quoted Henry Hill, “For us to live any other way was nuts. Uh, to us, those goody-good people, they’re the weird ones.”
For the mains, I dove into the Chicken Marsala and Chicken Parm. The Marsala was rich and flavorful, with the perfect balance of sauce and tender chicken that practically melts in your mouth. The Chicken Parm? “Never rat on your friends and always keep your mouth shut”—but I’m shouting it out anyway because it’s that good. Breaded, cheesy, saucy perfection—like a punch to your taste buds in the best way.
To wash it all down, I had the Franky the Wop—Crown Royal Apple, cranberry juice, and a dash of magic. One sip and I’m thinking, “You’re only supposed to blow the damn doors off!” This drink hits just right, sweet with a little kick, and the kind of thing you’d want to linger over while soaking in the vibe.
Shoutout to the servers—“Never take sides with anyone against the family.” These folks are attentive, friendly, and know how to keep you smiling. They check in just enough without hovering, and make you feel like you’re part of the crew.
If you’re craving hearty Italian classics, drinks with a personality, and a dining experience that’s as immersive as a Scorsese film, Goodfellas is where it’s at. I’m already planning my next hit—err, visit. Five stars isn’t enough.
… moreI started with the garlic knots, and oh boy—they’re chef’s kiss. Crispy on the outside, pillowy on the inside, and perfectly garlicky. I could’ve eaten a whole tray and still quoted Henry Hill, “For us to live any other way was nuts. Uh, to us, those goody-good people, they’re the weird ones.”
For the mains, I dove into the Chicken Marsala and Chicken Parm. The Marsala was rich and flavorful, with the perfect balance of sauce and tender chicken that practically melts in your mouth. The Chicken Parm? “Never rat on your friends and always keep your mouth shut”—but I’m shouting it out anyway because it’s that good. Breaded, cheesy, saucy perfection—like a punch to your taste buds in the best way.
To wash it all down, I had the Franky the Wop—Crown Royal Apple, cranberry juice, and a dash of magic. One sip and I’m thinking, “You’re only supposed to blow the damn doors off!” This drink hits just right, sweet with a little kick, and the kind of thing you’d want to linger over while soaking in the vibe.
Shoutout to the servers—“Never take sides with anyone against the family.” These folks are attentive, friendly, and know how to keep you smiling. They check in just enough without hovering, and make you feel like you’re part of the crew.
If you’re craving hearty Italian classics, drinks with a personality, and a dining experience that’s as immersive as a Scorsese film, Goodfellas is where it’s at. I’m already planning my next hit—err, visit. Five stars isn’t enough.
Russ LaBosco
The food is pretty good here. They need to work on service. Our server didn’t came back to check on us once our meals came out. I would still recommend giving them a try. They were busy. They just could have been overwhelmed.
… moreSara
There were 4 of us who went to eat around 730pm on a Friday night.We walked in and were sat immediately. The tables were full and they were a bit busy. We got our drinks and looked at the menu. There is food on there for everyone. Vegetarian to a meat lover.
Our waitress wasn’t the friendliest, but I think they were short staffed.
Two of the people ordered pizza..one ordered a meat lovers roll, I got creamy parmesan rice pilaf with shrimp. We all enjoyed our food. You get a lot of it for your money! The slices are like 2 regular slice pizzas in one. The personal size pizza is a regular medium pizza,and the roll is like a calzone but in roll form, and everyone knows what rice pilaf is. Pictures show what I’m talking about.
… moreOur waitress wasn’t the friendliest, but I think they were short staffed.
Two of the people ordered pizza..one ordered a meat lovers roll, I got creamy parmesan rice pilaf with shrimp. We all enjoyed our food. You get a lot of it for your money! The slices are like 2 regular slice pizzas in one. The personal size pizza is a regular medium pizza,and the roll is like a calzone but in roll form, and everyone knows what rice pilaf is. Pictures show what I’m talking about.
Doug Militzer
Updating my review after a second visit…
This was our second time trying Goodfellows, and unfortunately it will likely be our last.
We were told our takeout pizza would be ready in 30 minutes. When we arrived, the staff seemed confused about our order and said it would be another 10 minutes. Thirty minutes after that, we finally received our pizza. It was clear they had forgotten to make it.
Mistakes happen — that’s understandable. What wasn’t acceptable was the lack of acknowledgment. There was no apology, no explanation, and no attempt to make it right. The service felt disorganized, with several people behind the counter but no clear leadership or communication.
When we got home, we discovered the pizza was undercooked, with rubbery dough that required additional time in our own oven.
Very disappointing experience overall.
_____________________________________________________
First time customer. Delicious pizza — got the meat lovers, it had lots of meat and was cooked perfectly.
… moreThis was our second time trying Goodfellows, and unfortunately it will likely be our last.
We were told our takeout pizza would be ready in 30 minutes. When we arrived, the staff seemed confused about our order and said it would be another 10 minutes. Thirty minutes after that, we finally received our pizza. It was clear they had forgotten to make it.
Mistakes happen — that’s understandable. What wasn’t acceptable was the lack of acknowledgment. There was no apology, no explanation, and no attempt to make it right. The service felt disorganized, with several people behind the counter but no clear leadership or communication.
When we got home, we discovered the pizza was undercooked, with rubbery dough that required additional time in our own oven.
Very disappointing experience overall.
_____________________________________________________
First time customer. Delicious pizza — got the meat lovers, it had lots of meat and was cooked perfectly.
Nick V
I recently had my daughter’s 16th birthday party in the bistro room. The service was superb, food was AMAZING and the room itself is beautiful. Highly recommended hosting an event there. Anthony and Karen were amazing and Doug is THE BEST pizza guy around! Thank you!!
… more