Italian fare & cocktails served amid old-school homey environs, with outdoor tables in front.
Gary Daniels
Had lunch here twice. Both times had Brittany was our server. Food was excellent. Today I also had the Limoncello cake for dessert. OMG! It was an awesome completion to my Italian lunch with a great glass of wine. And, the pre lunch house salad was fresh and crispy with the house dressing. I signed up for the VIP group and I’m sure I’ll be back again.
… moreBrandi Denyse
DO NOT LET THE MESSY PIC FOOL YOU! My food had a rough trip home but OMG! I usually complain about Columbus not having any good food but I think I have found my new favorite spot. This eggplant Parmesan was sooooooooooo good! It was hot and fresh, the sauce the cheese THE EGGPLANT! So delicious and I will be back again.
Can’t wait to try some of the other dishes, especially the seafood.
… moreTarren Bruce
So we visited Cafe Amici Thursday evening. Great experience overall. The restaurant was very clean and put together and the staff was courteous, well presented, and knowledgeable about the menu. We started off with Drinks, the pineapple Margherita was very good. Perfectly balanced in my opinion. Our appetizer was the mozzarella triangles which were absolutely outstanding, housemade, crispy, ooey-gooey goodness! My caeser salad was good, my wife house salad was as plain as it could get. Straight out of the bag it seems. My wifes Chicken Parm was pretty good cheesy, hot, well seasoned chicken breast. The pasta was perfectly cooked. My meal was bad, i tried something new so i wasnt really going to comment on it. It had a very intense lemon flavor that took over all other flavors on the plate. I’m not sure how its supposed to taste but im sure it shouldn’t be pure lemon. I ordered a lasagna to go, i wanted something else to review so i went with an Italian staple. It taste like it was glued together with tomatoe paste to quicken cooking times. It also was no good. The bread served to the table is a cut up bagget with a compoud butter smeared on it.
… moreLayne Beman
My husband and I had a great dinner here! We have been to this restaurant a couple of times and it has always been delicious. It was a cozy setting to celebrate my career milestone. We had a hefty portion of caesar salad, mozzarella triangles, lasagna, chicken piccata, brussel sprouts, and finally the tiramisu. Thank you Debra and Caffe Amici for a wonderful evening!
PS – my pictures are not the best, but we were laughing so hard I couldn’t hold the camera steady 😉
… moreJohnny Y
I did not get to visit during dinner time but they serve small plates with very reasonable price during lunch time! I tried 3 different kinds of pasta and I love all of them! I will go back and try everything. And you MUST try their tirumisu. Ladies who sat next to me were so excited when tiramisu was served. It is that good. Just go!
… moreHolly Player
Our servers were very nice and attentive, but it took forever to get our food and it was not even crowded. The lasagna was good, but the chicken alfredo was absolutely terrible. The chicken was dry, there were only a few pieces, and the sauce tasted like flour. Sadly, this was our first and last trip to this restaurant.
… moreChristine Gibson
Went to Cafe Amici the other night. First time there
8 /10
Yes, I’d go back but not alot like I would other places
Restaurant…clean, spacious, definitely had an Italian vibe to it
Food…was great…huge servings. I couldn’t finish it all. Definitely was impressed with the cheese, being a cheese person. Sauce was good, and spices perfect. I got the baked ziti, date got the Lasagna. Garlic bread was a bit cold but ok.
Service..started off great, we got there at 5 but it seemed as more people came in, we were forgotten a bit.
Overall, good place to try
… moreLasaundra Robinson
What an awesome meal I truly enjoyed this was my first time sitting down to eat at this restaurant A friend brought some home about 4 years ago and I have never been able to get to this restaurant why I don’t know so glad I decided to come and sit down and enjoy the meal that I had it was amazing the service was top-notch that young lady was so sweet she even mixed my alcoholic drink for me because I was so undecided so she made me something really special and I thank her for that the tiramisu was amazing I took that home had it the next day the one thing that I did want to try I forgot to try and that was the Caesar salad so that means I will be back for Caesar salad and something special this was a great treat. treat yourself love yourself enjoy yourselves
08/08/2025 I came here tonight for dinner and I didn’t remember to order the Caesar salad what a terrible mistake that was the salad was not very good at all to me the croutons were soft as butter the lettuce was wilted and the flavor was not great I’m a firm believer and not sending your food back to the kitchen because we all know what happens…. my spaghetti carbonara was awesome along with the sweet tea I did not get dessert this time outside of the horrible Caesar salad my mail did satisfy me wasn’t the best service either but I guess you can’t win them all one out of three isn’t bad
… moreCel St.Pierre
When you walk in, the sign on the wall states “meals and memories are made here”. ABSOLUTELY TRUE! We celebrated a special 70th birthday here. We were warmly greeted, quickly escorted to our private dining room, and had a FANTASTIC DINNER! Very attentive wait staff. They joined in presenting the cake and in singing Happy Birthday. Excellent Italian cuisine. Thanks for a great evening!
… moreRita Patel
The food was absolutely delicious. The Bruschetta and Florentine Dip appetizers were SO good. I ordered the mushroom ravioli which was okay, not bad, but I needed some more flavor I think. But the eggplant parm was wonderful. Would 100% come back again
… more