At the end of a long day, few things taste more delicious than a gooey slice of New York style pizza or a plateful of hearty pasta. At Colonna’s Pizza, our family-owned and operated restaurant has taken these classic comfort foods and other authentic Italian staples to the next level since 1977. With the freshest of ingredients and years of family tradition, our dishes will have you saying ‘Bellissimo!’. If you ever feel like changing things up, we also offer salads, hot heros, calzones, stromboli, and more — all prepared with plenty of classic Italian inspiration.
Easygoing outpost offering NYC-style pies & slices alongside homemade pasta dishes & desserts.
Gregory Stewart II
YES PLEASE!!!! This was recommended by a local friend of mine. Stopped in with a buddy to grab some late lunch. Easy parking, greeted with a smile, asked some details on a certain pizza. Staff was ON POINT. Took their recommendation and did NOT regret it. Not only was the service exceptional, but they were also genuinely excited and happy. Our server talked with us about local stuff to see while we were in town. Now the pizza….DANG was it good. I’ve never had this kind (my buddy wanted it), but highly enjoyed it. Flavor was delicious. Next time I’m visiting I’ll try another new style. If you like pizza this is a MUST.
… moreJustin Hill
I am here today grabbing lunch because our first visit with a large group of friends was fantastic. We had a great time enjoying food and drinks.
I love the option of just grabbing a quick, fresh, slice of pizza.
Great spot for family dinner or a quick lunch.
Staff is always friendly and accommodating.
… moreSanta Jon
They have really good food and is pretty much the only place around me that has penne ala vodka, but the last 2 times that I’ve ordered it. I haven’t received what I ordered. I get somebody else’s order. I’m getting really tired of it, and I don’t know if it’s the doordasher or if it’s the restaurant, but this happens to be the second time in 4 months that I’ve ordered and gotten someone else’s order. I’m not gonna keep hoping that I get the correct order so I can eat! I hope whoever got my order enjoys cuz.What I got has tofu and mashed potatoes , and I don’t eat either!
… moreNamkyung Cho
This used to be our go-to pizza place, so we ordered again after a while — a 16” white margherita and BBQ chicken for pickup. When we got home and started eating, I was really surprised. I can overlook lighter toppings, but there was barely any cheese. The pizza tasted extremely dry. Instead of that rich cheese aroma and flavor you expect with the first bite, all I could taste was dry dough. It was dry overall — noticeably so.
We used to really enjoy their pizza, which makes this even more disappointing. I also left a review on the Toast website because I was asked, but it seems like just a couple of names dominate the reviews there… you know what I mean. The photos taken by another reviewer “Gregory Stewart II” 7 months ago looks great. I would have been super happy with that!
… moreJeremy Derr
Tasted good. Like a Margherita pizza should. Toppings, sauce. 2 knuckles deep?!? Another story.
Pic for example.
… moreEverett Lennon
We ordered from Colonna’s for the first time tonight and it was so awesome I’m writing a review as I finish my dinner. For the last few years we have been ordering pizza from another place on Arapahoe road that’s also pretty good, but the restaurant is very dirty and the people are mean, so we decided to try colonna’s tonight and I am glad we did. The store was spotless, the people were nice and the food was awesome! It’s about a 20 minute drive for us but we’ll be making it regularly going forward!
… moreStephanie Popken
I used to loveee this place about 6 years ago, pre-pandemic. I would always get the Trio, and I remember their alfredo being really delicious as well. I’ve ordered the Trio twice post-pandemic, and both times, it’s been disappointing. I think they use different sausage and pepperoni now. I can see the sausage they used pre-pandemic in an old review photo – it was large, round slices. It’s not quite as good now. Similar story with the pepperoni. The cheese still tastes great, but they use less. I appreciate this place a ton, but to me, it isn’t what it used to be.
… moreDonna Hickey
Hurumph. Was looking forward to a great, nearby Italian restaurant but served a pizza with scant toppings and sauce. Barely perceptible onions as though they only had one onion for the whole day to use on a day’s worth of pizza. Same with green peppers and mushrooms ~ scant being the operative word. No expected taste of oregano, basil or garlic. At all.
… morePrivate Name
The service was great! We constantly got checked up on and didn’t have to wait long for our food. We did end up waiting for the check for too long.
The pizza was very good, but I do think it was missing something. Maybe just more flavor in the cheese.
The atmosphere was awesome. Very upbeat, and we loved their playlist.
… moreDenver 303
My husband instead we drive from Brighton to this place . There pizza is good . But there WINGS are AMAZING I loved them . There sauce they use is omg the best I have ever had. There carrot cake was also very delicious. The restaurant it self is very clean and family friendly. They also sell adult drinks and have a small arcade for the kids to enjoy. If we are ever in the neighborhood again we will definitely be stopping by . Price for 16in pizza 12 wings 4 drinks mozzarella sticks and 1 sliced cake was about $60 .
… more