Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
My Pie Pizza has the best pizza you’ll find in Holladay, UT! Our New York authentic pie is built to order using homemade recipes from our family archives. Our motto is local, fresh, and fast! Our menu contains customizable pizzas, salads, and calzones as well as gluten-free and vegan options. Our neighborhood pizzeria is perfect for family dinners, date nights, or even a business lunch. Once you taste a My Pie you’ll be hooked! You can never go wrong with a visit to My Pie!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4655 S 2300 E Ste 101, Holladay, UT 84117
Phone: (801) 748-5888
Website: https://pizzayourway.com/mypieholladay?utm_source=google
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best Pizza in Holladay, UT | Pizza near me – My Pie Pizza
At My Pie we pride ourselves in being your neighborhood pizzeria. Our New York authentic pie are built to order using homemade recipes from our family archives.
My Pie Pizza Online Menu | Best Pizza in Town
My Pie Pizza Holladay. 4655 S 2300 E Ste 101, Holladay, UT. 4655 S 2300 E Ste 101, Holladay, UT. ·. Open now. Pickup. Pickup. Delivery. Delivery. 4655 S 2300 E …
My Pie Pizza | Holladay UT – Facebook
My Pie Pizza, Holladay. 129 likes · 133 were here. My Pie is a fast-casual pizzeria in Holladay, Utah that offers customizable build-your-own New York-s.
Reviews
Jb McDonald
Great pizza shop, workers are very friendly and helpful, tried pickles on one slice of my pizza it was good, love pizza and pickles and never thought to put the two together, it was definitely interesting, but I will stick with my favorite pizza
… moreL
I am from Chicago , so , nothing is Utah pizza -wise is going to wow me.. BUT … considering I am not in Chicago AND I need GF crust.. this is place is VERY IMPRESSIVE!!!! Actually tastes fresh and flavorful! Better than The Pie IMO.. even though they are good too, this is my go to place for ‘ZA!
… moreBeanie G
I really want to give them 5 stars because we absolutely love their pizza, you can taste the wood fire they cook it with. We also really loved that they had options that were gluten free and take some precautions such as using a dedicated gf pizza pan and stick to transfer the pizza. However, the sauce and all toppings come directly from the line and are at high risk for cross contamination. The person making my gf pie used the same tool to place sauce on all the pizza, gf or not meaning that sauce and all toppings are contaminated and not gluten free or safe for those with celiacs. I was disappointed when I watched her spread the sauce that had touched multiple gluten containing pizzas using the same tool they had on all of them. As someone who suffers with celiacs I have a very small amount of restaurants that I can safely eat at and the list unfortunately keeps shrinking and I keep getting sick from issues such as this. The pizza is delicious we appreciate the effort to be gluten free and understand there’s risk for cross contamination always but it seems a bit off that they would strive for gluten free and have some practices to keep us safe I just wish that proper safety precaution was taken with using fresh ingredients from the back that haven’t been cross contaminated such as the toppings and sauce. Should they change their practice for gf pies I’d love to come back but until then it’s not truly gluten free and there’s much higher risk for cross contamination with how they prepare the pies. Again I understand the difficult of reducing the risk of cross contamination but it is possible and those who do have celiacs really appreciate it a lot because not a lot of restaurants care if we can eat there and it becomes difficult to find restaurants I can safely eat at, celiacs want to eat out and spend their money too
… moreEmily B
Ollie he was so rude and disrespectful to me and my friends when we were trying to have a good time and was not being honest and threw my friends Pizza box at her. we also thought that it was a place where they clean up after you so we left our stuff there and right before we left and walked through the door to leave. He yelled at us and said we have to get back here and that we cannot be leaving huge message when we didn’t even know and said it’s very disrespectful when we didn’t even know he was mean about it and didn’t take accidents. but overall, the pizza was good just don’t get Ollie as your server.
… moreDenise Smith
I used to love the food here. The last three times have been very disappointing; 3 strikes, you are out. Strike 1, my order was 100% wrong (door dashed) and I received a $3 refund for a $30 order. Strike 2, ordered a pepperoni and olive calzone with extra cheese. There was no cheese and basically no pepperoni or olives. I got a pocket of air with tough crust. Strike 3, crust was so tough I couldn’t even chew it. Not sure what is happening, but it is really a bummer.
… moreAlison Parsons
Love My Pie! This time I just came in for garlic knots and cinnamon-knots to take to a dinner gathering. Both are just amazing!!
… moreAdam Christensen
Working in the area I stumbled across this corner restaurant, I was skeptical but upon entering I was greeted with warmth, I asked the individual to make me his favorite and he made me a decent cheese pizza, my wife got the Palermo pie. So good we came here 2 or 3 times a week.
Try the Pear-fict, it contrasts perfecty
… moreTry the Pear-fict, it contrasts perfecty
Jane Robinson
The pizza here is SO good! They have so many kinds and lots of yummy ingredients. However it can be very difficult to actually place an order. It seems like the employees might be turning the door dash off as well as the phones. Trying to call to order and reaching a full voicemail box at 7pm on Saturday, very frustrating. Otherwise great place!
… moreCalvin Brubaker
Ordered one small pizza for take out. I am frankly offended that you need to do keyboard gymnastics to opt out of a tip. It is easier to just pay one. I will order again probably, but not often.
… moreCanyon Hunter
Food was great, but the lady at the counter gave horrible customer service. When walking up to the counter, I said hello, and was ignored. I then walk over and order the lunch special with a pizza, aside, and a drink. When checking out she says that my order does not apply for the deal, although she knew that that’s what I had wanted and didn’t say anything. As she was bringing the food out, I said thank you as she sat it down pretty hard and said “Yep.” maybe she was just having a bad day, but either way bad customer service and did not feel welcome.
… more